Less Than the Dust (1916) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Viewed at CINEFEST 2009... Less Than The Dust is a little story for Mary Pickford that gives the accomplished screen artist many opportunities to display her talents.
Larry41OnEbay-27 April 2009
Warning: Spoilers
Pickford's role is that of a little English girl who is left by her father, a dissolute officer in the British army serving in India, to a low caste Indian caretaker. She passes the early years of her life in the home of Ramlan, a native sword maker (Mario Majeroni), and only learns of her gentle birth when he is sent to prison for participation in a revolt. She then goes to England to seek out her relatives, to find that the young man invalided in the great country house of her grandfather is none other than the young officer, handsome British Captain Raymond Townsend (David Powell) she worshiped in India and whose life she saved during the rebellion. The eastern scenes are atmospheric with swarms of dark skinned men and women and their backgrounds of rich verdure and buildings of Oriental architecture. The presence of the girl amid surroundings of Occidental culture presents many chances for the rather naive kind of humor Miss Pickford knows so well how to convey. The contrast between her eastern and western selves brings out the quality she possesses in greater degree than perhaps any other screen actress – the faculty of reflecting in appearance, like a chameleon, the nature of her surroundings. – paraphrased from the New York Times review of November 6, 1916.

In 1916 Mary Pickford, already a major star, made five feature films. Less Than The Dust was the last one of the year but the first for Artcraft Pictures Corporation, a company created to distribute productions by Mary Pickford Film Corporation. After two years it was reduced to a distribution brand name for Paramount Pictures Corporation by Famous Players-Lasky Corporation. Debonair leading man David Powell was of Scottish birth and had made his reputation on the stage before Pickford cast him in her 1914 production of The Dawn of a Tomorrow, making him a screen star. Powell's career peaked in 1921, and then he went on to appearing in serials before dying tragically of pneumonia at the age of 31 in 1925. Assistant director Erich von Stroheim had just come from assisting D.W. Griffith on directing Intolerance; his career high-points of Greed (1925) as a director and Sunset Blvd. (1950) as an actor were far ahead of him. Less Than the Dust director John Emerson also trained under Griffith and later directed seven films with Douglas Fairbanks Sr., the future Mr. Pickford. Emerson and his wife Anita Loos wrote 43 pictures together including San Francisco in 1936!
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
America's Sweetheart Plays A Hindu In India
boblipton6 March 2019
Mary Pickford is a middle-caste Indian girl -- her father is a swordsmith. When British army officer David Powell is kind to her, she develops a yen for him. However, the locals rise up and matters grow very complicated.

Pickford is charming as a hard-nosed young woman who drives a hard bargain and isn't above filching food or a bolt of cloth. Powell is there to play the conventional upright love interest and certainly does so adequately. He was an accomplished actor, having come out of Beerbohm-Tree's company. His death at 41 in 1926 is a shame.

Mostly, though, this movie is another chance for Little Mary to play an exotic creature in an exotic land, as her vehicles in this period would have her, and she does so very nicely. The India in this movie directed by John Emerson is a place of caste and hatred and temples and sacred pools and cows, all of which are carefully explained in the titles. Most of the comic bits occur in the final third in the movie, when she has wound up in England.

What survives is a nice movie, although the last reel was missing from the print I saw. Rumor claims there is a complete 35 mm. print. It is undoubtedly on the Pickford Foundation's To Do list, although I expect that with the casual racism and hatred between Hindu and Muslim in Indian, it's nowhere near the top. Still, someday.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A rather odd movie that will no doubt appeal to most Pickford fans!
JohnHowardReid20 September 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Let me put it this way: I didn't like the movie on a first viewing, mostly because the whole idea of Mary Pickford posing an an Indian lass was so absurd and so ridiculously phony - which is something that absolutely no-one would dispute. But what I didn't realize is that she was supposed to be a phony. This puts a new light on the matter, but it still doesn't explain why ALL the characters, and not even the Pickford character herself, don't tumble to this fact, nut simply take her white skin as no more than an oddity, rather than a revelation!

In addition to this somewhat unbelievable plot and its none too convincing Indian background, a secondary problem is that it is also burdened with a can't make up its mind audience appeal. What audience is it aiming at? What's it supposed to be? A comedy? A drama? A woman's picture? One for the kids? An adventure? A romance? A war drama? A missing heiress tale? A love story?

I could go on and on, but you get the idea. Despite all the familiar clichés, the story makes little sense. The plot, such as it is, is full of holes and remains pretty unbelievable from first to last.

In addition to the somewhat tattered and unconvincing script, full of long-running and absolutely ridiculous co-incidences, the routine and rather clumsy direction is not only somewhat boring and irritatingly long-winded, but displays not a spark of imagination. The camera doesn't seem to move even a single inch. In fact, it seems to be bolted to the floor! All the players go through their long-winded business and make entrances and exits as if they were trapped on a theater stage! And some of them have no compunction about looking directly at the audience from time to time. At normal speed this is rather irritating, but at twice the speed, you don't really notice.

On the plus side, the Alpha DVD does improve immensely on all fronts if you run it at twice speed. At normal speed, the sub-titles seem to be held forever. At twice speed, all of them can still easily be read. Admittedly the characters are now moving with a slight jerk, but I emphasize the word, "slight". Personally, I'd rather they moved at a slightly abnormal speed than that they took forever to move from "A" to "B". And you can still read the sub-titles at least two or three times even at TWICE the picture's normal speed.

A great deal of money was obviously spent on the movie, and all of it is up there on the screen. So, all in all, I'm glad the movie is available on a quite good quality Alpha DVD.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Very Mary-- and not much sense
AnnieLola8 November 2021
Mary does her best to carry a thin plot by being as endearing as possible, so we get generous helpings of feisty, mischievous and cute. To pass more credibly for Indian (before the unsurprising revelation that she's actually English), they could at least have had her in dark hair, but evidently that would have been too much of a departure from the Little Mary Formula. However, since none of the other 'natives' are played by South Asians, her obvious lack of Indian-ness is not as glaring as it could be.

It doesn't make much sense for the supposed daughter of a respectable artisan to behave like a penniless street urchin. Doesn't Papa make a decent living? Or doesn't he know about her hoydenish pilferings and other misadventures? A decent Hindu daughter wouldn't be running wild racking up bad karma and mixing with unclean (if better washed) English people. But Mary makes such an adorable hoyden that all must be forgiven, right?

There's some fun after she goes to England, with a suit of armor mistaken for an idol and given offerings of flowers. Thankfully her ignorance of Western table manners doesn't deteriorate into slapstick, and her dismay at discovering cooked sacred cow on the table --and on her own plate!-- is handled with taste and restraint. But excuse me, when retiring to bed in the manor house she finds it too warm?? English houses are notoriously cool, but Radha, who comes from a warm climate, is sweltering indoors and wants to sleep outside on the grass. Could there be an unusually hot summer? Hmm.

Then there's the British boyfriend. They're supposed to end up as an item, wedding bells and all, once he learns that she's not really a swarthy Indian. Okay. So it even turns out that his wealthy uncle (different surname, so Townsend's mother would be Uncle's sister, right?) was the father of Radha's real father (who was disowned for his dissolute ways). With her grandfather as his uncle, that makes Townsend a sort of uncle to Radha, since Townsend's mother would be Radha's great aunt. That's a pretty close relative! Well, you know, this thing works best if you don't expect it to make sense. Just enjoy the Mary-ment and don't worry over logic.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Less Than the Dust review
JoeytheBrit7 May 2020
A brown-faced Mary Pickford stretches her acting chops by playing an Indian child instead of an American one in this rather pointless silent. There are some mildly amusing scenes early on - particularly when Pickford falls into a sacred pool - but the plot is so wafer-thin that you have to wonder why they bothered.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed