Efficiency Edgar's Courtship (1917) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
It Might Have Been More Efficiently Told In Three Reels, But Not As Amusingly
boblipton31 March 2023
In the workplace, where he is the office manager, Taylor Holmes' slighting nickname is 'Efficiency Edgar', but his methods get results. So when he spots his new neighbor, Virginia Valli, he instantly realizes that a married man is more efficient than a single one, and falls in love. As the title indicates, this movie, based on a Clarence Buddington Kelland story, is about that courtship. It is hampered by his rival for Miss Valli, Rod La Rocque and his guitar, and Miss Valli's father, Ernest Maupin, who does not care for the saxaphone (sic) which Holmes sort of learns to play, nor the dog Holmes buys for his daughter (which eats Maupin's shoes), nor, when it comes down to it, Holmes.

It's really a short story translated to the screen, but it's opened up to a greater variety of settings than a stage play might have, and Holmes is a pretty good comic visually. His expressions when he plays his saxaphone (sic) are very amusing, are are the increasingly violent reactions of Maupin.

It's Holmes' first screen appearance, and he would continue to work on the big and little screen for more than 40 years, dying at the age of 81 in 1959.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Difficult to review fairly, but...
hoppitysmummy31 October 2021
This early comedy feature came over to me as lamentably unamusing, but this could well have been due in part to a poor copy (lots of splices, and some illegible title-cards) as well as the lack of any music accompaniment.

However the main character is enormously tiresome (although presumably popular in print) and ditto with the situations and the repeated use of irises at the end of scenes. The bit with the cat and the saxophone raised a laugh, but I am usually a sucker for cat scenes.

Admittedly films such as this should be salvaged for archival purposes it even in this state of repair. Hopefully anyone viewing this one by chance will not imagine this is typical and be put off silents for life.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed