The Rag Man (1925) Poster

(1925)

User Reviews

Review this title
12 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Kelly and Ginsberg
lugonian30 January 2004
THE RAG MAN (Metro-Goldwyn, 1925), directed by Edward Cline, personally supervised by Jack Coogan, is a newly discovered silent film, long unseen in many years, that has made its world television premiere on January 30, 2004, on Turner Classic Movies, with a newly composed score by Linda Martinez. But more about that later.

Set in New York City ("A world within a city where anything can happen"), the story begins on the night of June 18th, on the lower East Side where a fire breaks out at St. John's Orphanage. With all the orphans accounted for, only one seems to be missing. The child in question is Timothy Kelly (Jackie Coogan), who escapes the flames by climbing down from the window on his bed sheets. Timothy, walking about the streets still in his night clothes, is spotted by a policeman who chases after him. The officer loses Timothy after he takes refuge in a junk wagon belonging to Max Ginsberg (Max Davidson), a lonely old man whose sole companion is his horse named Dynamite. After spending the night in the wagon covered with old clothes, Timothy acquires some of the used clothing for himself, including a derby, in spite the fact that they are a bit over-sized. When Ginsberg notices the boy in the back of his wagon, he chases him away. Only after Timothy notices the old man has dropped his wallet on the street and in good faith returns it does Ginsberg reward the boy for his honesty by taking him in, especially after much persuasion from Timothy. Time passes and the practical little Irish Catholic boy and the old but lovable Jewish man become partners, and when Ginsberg becomes ill, it is up to Timothy to take the wagon to the Fifth Avenue section of Manhattan and do the business for him, which he does, and does it well. It is learned that Ginsberg is an inventor who, years ago, had his patent stolen and was cheated out of a big fortune by his lawyer (Robert Edeson), now living in the kind of luxury that should have been rightfully Ginsberg's. From an old assortment of clothing Timothy had collected from a woman who happens to be the lawyer's wife, Timothy discovers a letter dated August 7, 1910, indicating Ginsberg's rightful claim. It is then up to the boy to take it upon himself to see what he could do, in spite that fact that Ginsberg's true happiness is not the money due him but the companionship and loyalty of Timothy.

The supporting cast features Lydia Yeamans-Titus as Mother Malloy, the middle-aged apple woman whose sole interest is Ginsberg, but keeps that secret to herself in spite of Timothy's hints; William Conklin as Richard L. Scott; among others, ranging from a little boy named Reginald whom Timothy mistakes for a little girl, but does some business with him anyhow, to the orphanage priest, whose names are not listed in the opening cast credits.

Discovered by the legendary Charlie Chaplin, with whom he made his initial success in THE KID (First National, 1921), Jackie Coogan immediately made it on his own with several little films to his name over the next few years, including PECK'S BAD BOY (1921) and OLIVER TWIST (1922), before moving from First National to the newly formed motion picture studio of Metro-Goldwyn. A little older and taller from his earlier days, Coogan continues to delight both the characters on screen as well as his movie going audience. But while his films for MGM are on a higher and more glossier scale, THE RAG MAN has become Coogan's first for the studio to resurface again. While enjoyable as well as predictable, THE RAG MAN, at length time of 68 minutes, is extremely a watchable item. While in recent years, newly scored silent films have ranged from mediocre to way below average, the newly composed score by Linda Martinez for THE RAG MAN ranks one of the finer orchestrations presented for a silent film in quite some time. Ranging from piano to violin backgrounds, among others, all the tempos blend in very well with the situations at hand, and the time, effort and hard work gone into this actually shows and should not go unnoticed. It is uncertain whether THE RAG MAN was filmed on location in New York City, which shows scenes ranging from Wall Street to East 63rd Street and Fifth Avenue, but watching the background of New York City of the 1920s is one from the time capsule.

The basis of the story to THE RAG MAN somewhat indicates that many of the Jackie Coogan silents of his day rely on the same type formula, in this case as an orphaned boy who changes the lives of those he meets, as in this case, Max Ginsberg, a lovable loser with unwise business judgment. It's a little known fact that this newly rediscovered THE RAG MAN did acquire an immediate sequel titled OLD CLOTHES (MGM, 1925) with Coogan and Davidson reprising their roles. What's more interesting about OLD CLOTHES is the support of a very young Joan Crawford in one of her first major screen roles. Let's hope some day that TCM will also take OLD CLOTHES out of moth balls and put it out on display, in fact, presenting it on as a double bill to THE RAG MAN.

For those who feel they have seen it all, and would love to have more silent movies available to enjoy and study, as well as watching little Jackie Coogan decades before he was a household name again playing the bald-headed Uncle Fester in the Gothic television sit-com of THE ADDAMS FAMILY (1964-1966), THE KID and THE RAG MAN should be good for starters. (***)
17 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Metro-Goldwyn-Coogan
wes-connors20 September 2008
In "New York, a world within a city, where anything might happen," Irish Catholic lower East Side kid Jackie Coogan (as Timothy Kelly) survives a fire at St. John's Orphanage fire, and takes to the streets. Ten-year-old Coogan meets Jewish junk dealer Max Davidson (as Max Ginsberg); and, after Coogan returns Mr. Davidson's dropped wallet, he moves in with the rheumatic old man. The two become business partners "Ginsberg and Kelly", after Coogan proves his "Rag Man" mettle by filling Davidson's junk truck with four dollars worth of merchandise. Along the way, Coogan helps right and old wrong; he tracks down thieving Robert Edeson (as Mr. Bernard aka Mr. Bishop), who robbed Davidson of a patent fortune.

"The Rag Man" is a top-of-the-line Metro-Goldwyn-Coogan production, smoothly directed by Edward F. Cline; it is highlighted by the Frank Good/Robert Martin photography, which features some great New York City sets and locations. Coogan and Davidson aren't very original, basically re-treading their "Kid" and "Izzy" characterizations; but, the Irish/Jewish teaming adds some freshness (as does Linda Martinez' new soundtrack). In the sequel "Old Clothes", Coogan and Davidson wisely take in young Joan Crawford (as Mary Riley) as a boarder.

******** The Rag Man (1925) Edward F. Cline ~ Jackie Coogan, Max Davidson, Robert Edeson
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
THE RAG MAN documents how America's scheming leeches . . .
cricket3020 November 2014
Warning: Spoilers
. . . commonly referred to nowadays as "The One Per Cent," were about to drag the U.S. into the depths of financial ruin when this flick was released like the corpse of the canary in the coal mine four years prior to the onset of 1929's Great Depression. Title character "Max," played by Max Davidson, is a brilliant inventor reduced to rag-picking here by shyster lawyers who produce nothing but heart-ache. Since America is run on the Principle "Of the Fat Cats, By the Fat Cats, For the Fat Cats," Max grows old, his productive years wasted, his health ruined. Had not the producers thrown in child actor Jackie Coogan for "comic relief," THE RAG MAN would have been an unremittingly tragic Sinclair Lewis-style expose of Wall Street's seamy side. The disparity between Rich and Poor set a world record for the U.S. around 1925 which stood until being broken by today's America. My family knows Max's anguish first-hand. My great uncle won General Motors' top inventor's prize of $6,000, as well as a dozen smaller cash bonuses, for manufacturing and safety innovations which saved GM millions in their plants around the world. However, the bloated stooges that always have run Corporate America begrudge Brains and Brawn from having even the crumbs off "their" feast table. So when my relative topped himself with an even more widely-adopted cash-saving (as well as life-saving) "suggestion," they stiffed him with some unwritten "rule" about workers being limited to one "Major Award" per lifetime! My great-uncle's health declined as he fretted about how the ungrateful jackals had treated him, and he never submitted any more of his many ideas for consideration. I'm sure that GM's culture repeated such crimes against the Common Man (and Common Sense itself) thousands of times over the years, resulting in the most famous corporate bankruptcy in history, as well as this year's record for vehicle recalls. Take it from me, THE RAG MAN is an important American story which rings as true today as it did in 1925.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Excellent Movie
lwsroute662 October 2004
This is a must-see movie! It took a long time for me to finally get the opportunity to see it, but it was well worth the wait!!!! I had previously seen young Jackie Coogan in The Kid (1921) and knew that he was quite a charmer and a scene-stealer -- he did it AGAIN in The Rag Man! Young Jackie Coogan displays an excellent acting ability at such a young age.

This movie was, in so many ways, reminiscent of The Kid. The rapport between Coogan and Max Davidson was super! One cannot help feeling emotion when watching this. Although this is definitely a comedy, there are some heart-wrenching scenes in the movie, as well! So, be sure to have a box of tissue handy when watching it!

Hopefully, before long, this movie will be released on DVD and/or VHS.
10 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Rag Man has a nice fabric.
st-shot7 November 2012
When little Tim Kelly's orphanage burns down he is mistaken for dead. Making a run for it he crosses paths with rag man Max Ginsberg. Sullen Max wants no part of Tim but the kid is persistent and he is soon moved in and part of the business renaming it Kelly and Ginsberg. He is soon driving his horse and wagon about Manhattan for the disabled Max haggling with housewives for old clothes. It is by way of this that he finds out Max was robbed of a pattern by two partners years before. He sets out to square things for Max.

Max Davidson and Jackie Coogan make for a good teaming as dueling ethnic stereotypes. Davidson in particular without stridency brings across a cosmic inflection to his title cards. The debates are spirited, the familiarity between the two convincing. There are some slow moments as well as incredulous ones but overall it is a sweet odd ball buddy movie.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Ginsberg & Kelly/Kelly & Ginsberg
canpp25 June 2005
An absolutely heart-warming tale about a young lad, Timmy Kelly, masterfully played by child star Jackie Coogan, who runs away from an orphanage after the shelter suffers major damage from a fire, The Rag Man,(Metro-Goldwyn, 1925), directed by Edward Cline,is truly a classic.

Young Timmy befriends a junk dealer, Max Ginsberg, poignantly played by Max Davidson. The two embark on a comical journey becoming close friends whereby each depends on the other. Young Timmy proves his loyalty and devotion to the man who took a chance on him whose sole companion to this point was an old Derby winning horse named Dynamite. Dynamite's oats bowl is a key element to this story too. You must watch to see what I mean.

The musical score was masterfully written by the late Linda Martinez.

This is a must-see film and I would be hard-pressed to believe anyone not enjoying this delightful film which has a running time of approximately 75 minutes. The film had a sequel later in 1925, titled, Old Clothes. The sequel is of particular interest because it features Joan Crawford in one of her earliest roles.

I sincerely hope these two wonderful films become available on DVD or VHS soon.
15 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Jackie Coogan is still The Kid
SnoopyStyle12 September 2022
Tim Kelly (Jackie Coogan) runs away from his Lower East Side orphanage after it burns down. He's presumed dead and starts roaming the streets of New York. He encounters Max Ginsberg, an old Jewish junk dealer and begs to join him. They become the best of friends as the young boy tries to care for his aged senior partner.

Jackie Coogan was the child star of his day. This is not quite The Kid. He's a little older and this doesn't have Chaplin. The humor is nice and there are great bits like pouring out the bottles. It does need to get going with the drama faster. The patent story takes forty minutes to start. I can't believe the man's name is Henry Winkler. The story isn't that dramatic although the movie does have some fun moments.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
The Rag Man - an inadvertent documentary
sosuttle17 August 2010
I'd heartily agree with those above who praise this film. I've check Max Davidson's filmography on this site and it was interesting to see how lengthy his career was. I don't remember seeing another Davidson vehicle, but I will watch for them in future. Coogan, of course, is superb in this film. In my opinion, as good as he was in The Kid. The Rag Man is an American jewel and a wonderful snapshot of its times. Like Speedy, the New York City location footage in Rag Man is a great example of the "inadvertent documentary," literally freezing the Lower East Side in time. The two Yiddish intertitles are a treat. Sadly, sharp, but gentle contrast in ethnicity is almost lost as a comedic device in the wake of today's "political correctness" (who coined that stupid phrase anyway?) Face it kids, people are different and those differences can be humorous without being mean or berating. And finally, the film contains possibly one of the best Prohibition gags of all time when precious wine bottles are emptied for their value as recyclable glass. I highly recommend this sweet little movie.
12 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Funniest Film...and it's SILENT!
Sweet_Fiddler10 September 2008
I have seen more comedy flicks in my life than I ever care to count, and yet this SILENT film, made in the 1920s, trumps them all! By chance, I caught it on one of those old-movie channels, and it had me on the floor dying with laughter. I was amazed--that little boy had such a phenomenal understanding of humor, and what makes a punch line or a reaction or comedic timing funny! Brilliant. If a movie keeps me laughing the whole way through, it deserves ten stars. (I am normally very picky about my comedies.) It's definitely a new favorite.

Does anyone know where I can get it? I'd love to see it again! Apparently Netflix and Amazon have never even heard of it. Blockbusters, of course, do not hold it.
12 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Funny? Only occasionally...but it is very sweet.
planktonrules30 October 2015
"The Ragman" is a very sweet little film and it's actually aged very well. When the film begins, the local orphanage burns down and everyone thinks little Tim Kelly (Jackie Coogan) was killed. However, instead the kid just took refuge with a nice old Jewish rag dealer (Max Davidson). Soon the boy and the old man become best friends and their time together on the screen is quite sweet. How can the boy pay off his nice benefactor for taking him in...see the film and find out for yourself.

I liked pretty much everything about this film. Max Davidson is mostly forgotten today, but I love his films. This one, however, isn't a comedy so much as a sweet film--and Davidson's usual Jewish character is still VERY Jewish but toned down a bit an not played for laughs. While some folks today might think the film contains a few too many Jewish stereotypes, as you watch you realize the film is an excellent portrayal of a Jewish immigrant. Sure, he loves to make money BUT he's decent, honest and someone with a lot to like. This combined with the nice writing make this one well worth seeing...even 90 years later!
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Loved this movie!
jjwells-131 January 2004
The on location scenes showing 1920s New York were incredible, as were the performances of Jackie Coogan and Max Davidson. Especially liked the new score, it was perfect for this movie, you would not know it was not written in 1925. I don't generally like silent movies but this one was much better than most.
13 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Delightful minor film
finki30 January 2004
The teaming of Jackie Coogan and Max Davidson elevates this movie from a routine plot. Even though it is not an important production, it is quite enjoyable, well directed by Eddie Cline, and features a nice location cinematography in New York.

Linda Martínez score is excellent.
7 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed