Clearing the Range (1931) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Pretty silly but worth seeing.
planktonrules2 March 2014
"Clearing the Range" is pretty typical of many of Hoot Gibson's films. It has a comic element and certainly doesn't take itself very seriously. This helps, as the portion where Gibson pretends he is the Mexican bandit 'El Capitan' is very weak and laughable--and so I was willing to cut it some slack.

The story begins with Kildare murdering his partner at the bank. This is because Mr. Fremont discovered that Kildare was embezzling funds--and Fremont even told Kildare this when there were no witnesses around in case Kildare reacted violently. And, naturally, Kildare does EXACTLY what the audience expected! What Kildare didn't plan on was Fremont having a brother. Curt Fremont (Gibson) soon arrives in town. He has a note from his brother that explains that Kildare is probably embezzling funds. However, Curt plays it cool and behaves like a very peaceable man--a guy who hates danger or arguments. He even treats Kildare like an old friend when he knows the real Kildare is scum. However, using his alter-ego of 'El Capitan', he avenges the murder and in many ways behaves like Robin Hood or, more likely, like Zorro. The only problem is that Gibson's Mexican accent is lame and he can barely speak Spanish!! It was ridiculous and was a far cry from the amazingly good performances by Tim McCoy when he, too, played a Mexican bandit as a disguise in several of his films.

If this doesn't sound silly enough, one of Curt's friends, Juan, spends much of the movie in drag--hiding from Kildare and making an amazingly convincing Senorita! Because of all this silliness, it's hard to hate the movie--even when it is AMAZINGLY ridiculous. Worth seeing but certainly not a very believable western!
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Hoot Does a "Zorro" Act in the Old West
JohnHowardReid20 May 2008
When his brother is shot dead by crooked bank cashier Lafe Kildare, Curt Fremont poses as a weak-kneed scaredy-cat. In reality, he is vengeance-seeking "El Capitan".

The script sounds promising enough, but it's given an economy-budget treatment -- and worse, it's full of holes. One moment, Sally Eilers (Gibson's wife in real life when this movie was made) is telling us how she remembers the hero's act of bravery in saving her life, and next minute she's convinced he's turned coward. Maybe the screenwriter is trying to portray the heroine as a dumb cluck, but that's not the way Sally Eilers plays the part.

It's also rather odd to see Robert Homans, that perennial policeman on the contemporary city beat, transferred to a role as an avuncular rancher in the Old West.

Nonetheless, despite script flaws (including scenes that run too long and others that seem short-changed), director Otto Brower manages to invest the movie with a bit of pace and atmosphere, despite an obviously limited budget. Of course, he's helped by the fact that Hooper Atchley is playing the slimy villain with all stops out, while Edward Peil makes a convincingly sympathetic sheriff.

We could have done without George Mendoza and his occasional weak attempts at comic relief, but Hoot Gibson himself does a good job in both his characterizations. He's also admirably agile on his feet and performs at least two of his own stunts
4 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
The Two Faces of Hoot.
mark.waltz3 December 2016
Warning: Spoilers
A pretty decent early talkie western cheapie features matinée idol Hoot Gibson who lives his public life as a mild mannered and peace loving pacifist whom everyone assumes is a coward. But he's living a secret life as a masked bandit searching for evidence to pinpoint the corruption in the town and the murder of his banker brother. Hoot's real life wife at the time (Sally Eilers) is the heroine of the story, urging Hoot to fight for justice and obviously not in the loop of what's really going on. In addition to Hoot's disguise, there's a wanted Mexican man disguising himself as a senorita as Hoot's sidekick. Plenty of intrigue and action makes up for the creaky pacing and poor technical elements of this Z grade western.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Clearing the Range review
JoeytheBrit17 May 2020
Unlikely Western hero Hoot Gibson comes over all Zorro in this cheap B-picture. He plays the brother of a murdered banker who returns to his home town as an ineffectual wimp in order to put those he suspects of the killing off his scent. These bad guys aren't exactly master criminals, however - even though he doesn't wear a mask, they fail to recognise Hoot simply because he's dressed in his black Zorro outfit. At least there's no annoying comedy sidekick in this one - unless you count the Mexican lad who spends a worryingly large amount of time dressed as a woman.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Mediocre, At Best
dougdoepke11 July 2019
Mediocre oater, at best. Some good skyline shots, along with picturesque Vasquez Rocks north of LA, but also lots of rather pointless posse riding around scrubby LA area hills. Bad guy Kildare embezzles money from his bank and kills Jim Fremont when latter discovers the theft. Soon Jim's brother Curt rides into town but seems strangely uninterested in who killed his brother. Good thing Zorro-like El Capitan mysteriously arrives to make sure justice is served.

Gibson makes for a rather affable hero, no tough guy poses for him, but not very convincing either. Still, it's a stretch to have a mere change into black costume make him unrecognizable to the whole town. Good thing Eilers is there to offer plenty of attractive eye candy. The storyline may be hard to follow (it was for me) with all the characters coming and going. One thing for sure, the producers spared no expense in hiring an army of extras. Anyway, the flick's an antique (1931) which may be the best reason to catch up with it.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
"He must be naturalized by now!"
classicsoncall16 January 2010
Warning: Spoilers
To me, Hoot Gibson always looked like he had a face more for comedy than Westerns, and I wonder how his career might have gone in that direction. As for "Clearing The Range", Gibson gets to wear a couple of different faces, that of a sheepish drifter on the one hand, and the charismatic and romantic 'El Capitan', an alter ego he uses to good advantage to smoke out the outlaw who killed his brother.

I got a kick out of the way Lafe Kildare rose from the position of cashier at the Comanche State Bank to it's President after he knocked off Jim Fremont. Talk about a fast track up the corporate ladder! Hey, how about that big kiss Curt Fremont (Gibson) gives Mary Lou (Sally Eilers) under cover of darkness and her thinking it was El Capitan - almost a half century before Luke Skywalker would do the same just before swinging into action. I don't know why I thought of that, but it seems an apt comparison. It would have been cool if the character had a sword to rival Luke's light saber.

Never underestimate what the hero can do in pictures like these. How about Gibson's character making the save near the end of the picture by lassoing Kildare as he was just about to fall off the cliff! That was almost as good as Tim McCoy roping a gun out of the hand of an outlaw on horseback in "Forbidden Trails". None of the logistics or timing actually work to make those outcomes happen, but at least they're fun to watch.

Although it looked to me like Curt and Mary Lou made for a poor match up romantically, I was surprised to learn that Gibson and Sally Eilers were actually married at the time they made this picture together. Much younger than Gibson by about sixteen years, they didn't have to act to close out the picture in another big smooch.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Posing As A Coward
StrictlyConfidential18 September 2021
Warning: Spoilers
"Clearing The Range" was originally released back in 1931.

Anyway - As the story goes - A man arrives in town to look into the murder of his brother, the town banker. Appearing in public as disinterested in finding his brother's killer, the public believes the man to be a coward. What everyone doesn't know is the man has an alter ego, "El Capitan", and he uses this disguise to track down the killer and get his revenge.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Beautiful Sally Eilers Enhances This Western!!
kidboots11 January 2013
Warning: Spoilers
Hoot Gibson had been Universal's top Western star from the late teens to the late twenties when Ken Maynard overtook him in popularity. His films were the opposite of William S. Hart's, usually portraying him as a clowning hero who was often worsted in a few fights before he got the girl at the end but audiences liked him because they could relate to him. By 1930 most studios were worried about the future of sound Westerns so Gibson's contract was not renewed but being still a popular player he was immediately signed by Allied Pictures to do a series on a state's rights basis. And his first movie "Clearing the Range" also starred his new wife, Sally Eilers, whose beauty greatly enhanced this oater!!

Bank manager Jim Fremont has discovered the books have been cooked but is shot in the back by the crooked cashier Lafe Kildare (Hooper Atchely) who is then speedily promoted to Bank President!! Jim's brother , Curt (Gibson) rides into town after receiving a letter from Jim telling of his suspicions. He re-acquaints himself with Juan and his mother and also pretty Mary Lou Moran (Eilers) but to all appearances he has changed. He now calls himself a peaceable man and wants no part in gunfights and violence and spends most of his time sleeping and eating - needless to say the Morans are disgusted with the way they think he has turned out. Especially after he and Mary Lou have just had a conversation about the time he saved her life when they were just kids!!! Juan is the only person who knows his real agenda as Curt has to rescue him from the hands of Kildare's gang. For the rescue Curt disguises himself as "El Capitan" - a daring Mexican bandit who is also a wow with the ladies as Mary Lou finds out to her pleasure. Also Juan, who has to be hidden, finds himself disguised as a senorita for most of the movie!!

For a 1931 western this definitely has quite a bit of action - lots of riding, some stunts as Curt jumped from his bedroom window to the ground and a big fight scene, very different to the majority of 1930-31 Westerns I have seen which were big on talking and small on action.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
hoot and hooper !
ksf-213 June 2022
When a bank robber/murderer escapes into the desert, simple and innocent-appearing fremont dresses up as the masked hero el capitan, and goes after him. The usual western horse chases, on horseback and on the rockpiles. Not much new in this one, but to be fair, it was a pretty early talkie, so there probably hadn't been too many westerns filmed yet. It's okay. No big surprises here. Directed by otto brower... died young at 50 of a bad heart.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed