Over the Counter (1932) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
something different
SnoopyStyle2 November 2021
The staff at the Drake's Department Store is at the end of their rope. The owner Mr. Drake has let his son Freddy do work and he has made plenty of crazy changes. He has hired beautiful chorus girls for a Check Your Husband counter. He converted the nursery into a nightclub, and made shopping into a radio show with an audience.

It's a weird concept but it's fine for a fun little surrealist comedy short. Like the concept itself, it has a lot of dancing girls for the male audience. It's filmed in 2-strip Technicolor. The colors look somewhat pastel. This is something different.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
America's leading "pin-up girl" suggests that live babies . . .
pixrox16 August 2020
Warning: Spoilers
. . . should join picture frames, pop tarts and pot holders on department store sales shelves during OVER THE COUNTER. Certainly, making "Infants to go" the Blue Light Special on Aisle Five could reduce or eliminate the risk of "stretch marks" for preening Tinsel Town Prime Donna's hankering for tots of their own. Also avoided would be the peril of "morning sickness," a malady known to interfere with early A.M. film-shooting schedules. Since no right-thinking guy wants to be anchored down by marriage to one of these Big Screen "Anybody's" gals, being able to purchase ready-made tykes could provide the sort of maternity-in-name-only PR boost that so many "starlets" crave. Just remember: No wire hangers!
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
No Way To Run A Business
boblipton11 June 2022
Store owner Warner Oland asks secretary Franklin Pangborn what his son, Emerson Treacy is up to. He's organizing the counter girls into a variety show in two-strip Technicolor, of course.

Which is the point of this MGM short. It's directed by Jack Cummings, before his elevation into a producer, where he would lead one of the three musical units, as well as a couple of Red Skelton vehicles. I found it intensely pleasurable, but I like the weird stuff.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Unusual...not good...but unusual
planktonrules22 February 2016
"Over the Counter" is a very unusual short film because it is in color...quite odd for the early to mid 1930s. However, unlike most two-color films I have seen of the era, the colors are a bit different. Instead of the mostly orange and green tones, this one is more pink-orange and turquoise.

The story is a bizarre and nonsensical thing with the owner of a department store (Sidney Toler) learning from his manager (Franklin Pangborn) that the son has turned his department into a strange nightclub! Does this make any sense? Nah. What also doesn't make any sense (though it is mildly funny) is the sporting event being broadcast of some insane women having a shopping contest. Finally, there is a hilarious (NOT!) sequence involving a woman abusing her husband. All in all, a not particularly good or remarkable film except for its early use of color.
5 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Pre-Code Oddity
brian-4011 June 2003
Warning: Spoilers
If you're into the sometimes just-plain-weird pre-code humor, this is a short for you. (And if you don't know what I'm talking about but get a chance to see it, do so...just to see what Hollywood was capable of in 1930.)

What follows isn't really a spoiler, but I sort of liked not knowing what it was all about when I saw it...good surprises.

Anyway, the son of department store owner replaces the regular sales girls with chorus girls...and song and dance wackiness ensues!!! Wives can now check their husbands (like they would their hat) to shop husband-free, which leads to a fantastic song and dance between the chorus girls and the men. And the new indoor sport is putting the best female shoppers in the ring to go after that one great sale item. Yea, it's sexist, and it's sexy innuendo all they way, and nothing like would ever be seen again once The Hayes Office came along.
22 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
There's nothing stronger over the counter.
highclark12 June 2006
Warning: Spoilers
This short film is filled to the brim with overt double entendre sexuality. The viewer is never more than half a minute away from a dozen scantily clad chorus girls hanging onto a rising phallus or a suggestive song and dance number mocking the average housewife and her attempts at seducing their libidinous husbands while shopping through the Drake Women's Underwear Department.

It's difficult to find the exact moment where this short film goes over the top, perhaps it is the rising phallus, but it could be the chorus girl who is bent over awaiting the thumb fingerprint of a blindfolded husband…please, don't ask.

No reason to get bogged down in the plot of the film, just enjoy the effort put forth by everyone involved. It's a little film, but a very sexy one at that. The film is titillating and fun, but most of all it's fun. And unlike one of the best lines in the film uttered by a very big and older housewife while grabbing her husband away from one of the younger looking nymphs, "A great big sofa may give more comfort than a chair", this film is that chair, and really, you might find rocking back and forth in a chair very comforting.
17 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Every department store should have a musical comedy section!
mark.waltz13 October 2015
Warning: Spoilers
Sure, Macy's has Broadway shows performing outside the entrance to their Herald Square store every Thanksgiving. But imagine if you went inside, and got to see a musical show while having a coffee or just taking a rest from your holiday shopping. I would certainly spend more than I do on an annual basis in department stores if I could do that. That is the premise of this delightful color short from MGM where department store owner Sidney Toler (aka Charlie Chan), is told by tattletale Franklin Pangborn that his son (Emerson Treacy) has turned part of the store into just that - a Broadway theatre for his desire for chorus girls and production numbers. This is a delightful little short that never ceases to be entertaining, featuring over the head shots that later became Busby Berkeley's trademark. It's more music then plot, but why does that matter when what is there is just so delightfully produced. This is forgotten gem that deserves to be rediscovered and I am so glad that is this on the Warner Archive Collection of musical shorts from MGM's golden age.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Beautiful ladies, entertaining musical short film
iamjasonwu2 January 2019
Warning: Spoilers
This film is a pre-code two tone technicolor metro short film from 1932. It is about a department store owner's son who put a bunch of chorus girls in the lobby and then the department store owner's supervisor on his son snitches on him and his father takes a look. Then the son says how great and marvelous these ladies are and then the ladies sing and dance with lots of skin showing. Later in the film, it shows husbands checking in with the ladies and starts to play with them. Then the green dressed black haired lady starts strolling and tries to seduce these husbands while they are drinking/smoking. However, the fat lady suspects something is up with his husband so she abuses her husband for playing with the girls and unchecks her husband. Then after that, the son creates a theatrical play like entertainment. He puts the husbands' wives into a horde and they start to chase at the items that are on sale. Then after that, the audience starts singing and moving their hands. Then more singing and dancing starts kicking in. In the end, the father approves the son's chorus girls in the department store section. This film is one of the best short films I've seen in my lifetime. It shows a bunch of beautiful, hot ladies and well dressed people unlike today that is very boring with jeans, no hats, t shirts, and casual style with hair no slick back taped back and beards. It shows a bunch of chorus girls singing, other women showing the 1932 fashion styles, and performances. This short film is NOT boring and is very entertaining. It shows how normal people were unlike today with transgender, gay, lesbian, 63 other genders, mentally ill people, etc... being normalized in society. Also, this short film is probably number 3 in my top 10 best short films list. Ignore those liberals, offended people who are offended by this short because it shows fat women are not attractive and unhealthy. Also, they find everything offensive, that is another reason to watch this short since they are censoring stuff.
7 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
An absolutely HOOT!
schochet-1948325 December 2023
This 1932 TECHNICOLOR! MGM short musical comedy is an historic joy: stupid, a bit risque (pre-sensorship), and full of laughs -- unless, of course, you're a Grinch. All the services and conveniences a. MODERN department store needs, most especially the MGM "Dancing (and singing) Girls," who put on quite a show, reminiscent of the saloon dancers in old westerns and certainly inappropriate by today's criteria.

Also included is the standard range of silly, uptight, and over the top characters who inhabited the short comedies that, along with a cartoon, a serial, the news, and a "Preview of Coming Attractions" made Saturday afternoons at movies in the 1940s and '50s wonderful fun and great escapes from whatever was lurking at home in our parents plans for our well-beings... and, however briefly, despite the news, blocked out THE WAR. And if you cannot "decode" that phrase, you're too young to be in my target audience!

But those of you who are "in the know," should find this movie and, as the opening of "THE LONE RANGER" on the radio had it, take a trip back to those thrilling days of yesteryear -- without WILLIAM TELL along for company!

PS: OVER THE COUNTER was recently shown on TCM following the dated but still compelling and creepy NIGHT OF THE HUNTER with.the ever-brilliant ROBERT MITCHUM.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed