Melody Trail (1935) Poster

(1935)

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Quite unlike all the other Gene Autry films I've seen in so many ways.
planktonrules31 August 2020
"Melody Trail" is one of the strangest Gene Autry films I've seen. It seems to violate the usual formula in 1001 different ways, though it's still enjoyable. How is it different? Read on....

The story begins with Gene performing and winning at a rodeo. Later that night, a Gypsy* sneaks into Gene and Frog's room and steals all of their money. Without money, the pair go out to look for work the next day and they get jobs as cooks on the ranch of a very grouchy man. They are complete busts, as they don't know how to cook AND the dog, Souvenir, is a klepto and stole the cookbook. But to make it worse, that accursed Saint Bernard has stolen all sorts of things...including a baby!!!! I am not kidding. This becomes a problem for many reasons. First, Gene incorrectly assumes that the girl he is smitten with (Ann Rutherford) is a mother...and this cools off his ardor. Second, the baby's real father turns out to be the evil Gypsy who stole Gene's rodeo winnings! What's next? See the film.

Nearly all of Gene Autry's films center on some baddie--who usually is involved in cattle rustling or perhaps running the territory. In this case, however, the emphasis is on humor...such as the kleptomaniac dog! It's a huge departure from the usual...possibly because it's an early Autry film developed before the formula became hard and fast. Regardless, it's strange and also features a gang of sexy cowgirls as well as the weirdest ending I can recall! See the very end...see what I mean.

This is an enjoyable movie with less suspense than usual and more comedy. Not a bad mix...but also one which is a weaker Autry effort. Still, a weak Autry film is still awfully good.

Souvenir in the movie is billed because it happens to be a famous dog--Buck from "Call of the Wild". And, with Champion (Gene's horse) also getting billing, it's as I've said...a most unusual film!

*I know 'Gypsy' is not the most politically correct term...it's the one they used in the film. Today, Romani or Roma is a much more acceptable term.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A formula western, but reasonably entrtaining!
JohnHowardReid29 January 2018
Warning: Spoilers
It didn't take long to establish the Autry formula. Admittedly, his 5th movie, namely "Melody Trail" (1935), does present an unusual conclusion in which Gene actually marries heroine Ann Rutherford (looking much older here than in her later "Andy Hardy" movies), while Smiley is hitched with the even more attractive Gertrude Messinger.

And would you believe, there's a dog in the cast too - "Buck, the wonder dog!" - who competes with Champion for the audience's attention.

As with all the Hoppy movies, all the action is saved for the last reel, nut it's good stuff: Autry's double performs three thrilling leaps - from horseback into a speeding car, a tree-branch fall to clobber a villain in the saddle, and an acrobatic somersault down an incline.

I wish we knew the double's name, but more likely there were at least three of them!
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Radio star wins at the rodeo.
michaelRokeefe25 July 2006
Warning: Spoilers
Real early in Gene Autry's film career and a very busy western movie. Autry, the popular radio singer wins $1,000 at a rodeo and in the night his money is stolen by a gypsy, Black Frantz(Willy Castello). Gene and his sidekick Frog Millhouse(Smiley Burnette)take jobs at a ranch that is plagued by cattle thieves. Autry becomes attracted to the owner's daughter Millicent(Ann Rutherford)and helps her and her cowgirls round up the rustlers. Instead of Gene riding his famed horse Champion...he catches the bad guys by automobile. The cowboys are given their jobs back on the condition they marry the cowgirls that took their place on the ranch.

There is a handful of songs in this mid 30's Republic Picture and Gene sings "A Lonesome Cowboy on the Lone Prairie" and "On the Melody Trail". Also starring are: Timothy Thomas, Al Bridge, Gertrude Messinger and Marie Quillen.
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
"If he can ride like he can sing... oh baby"!
classicsoncall3 April 2011
Warning: Spoilers
Not to be confused with Gene Autry's 1940 picture "Melody Ranch", this one came at the very start of his career just a couple of pictures after "The Phantom Empire" serial. Much of the opening sequence appears to be utilizing stock footage of rodeo events complete with an announcer's corny attempts at cowboy humor. As in why the bucking bulls have bells on their horns - to keep the riders from falling asleep.

After Gene's contest money of a thousand dollars is stolen by a member of a gypsy band, he and Frog (Smilley Burnette) seek work on a local cattle ranch where cowgirls have replaced the regular ranch hands. This might have given rise to all sorts of romantic entanglements, but the story didn't go very far in that direction, until the final scene (you'll just have to see it). The boys get to investigate a spate of cattle rustling along with a baby kidnapping, while hosting a handful of musical numbers including the title song.

I always love watching these early films for their take on life in simpler times. Back then, eggs were priced at twenty eight cents a dozen, and can you believe it - they were offered for sale on the sidewalk outside the store - without refrigeration!

Gene's horse Champion has a canine rival for your attention in this one, as a Saint Bernard by the name of Souvenir gets a lot of screen time with his mischief. He snatched the baby basket in the first place early on, and I kept wondering when the gypsy camp would go manic over the loss of the little guy, but that never happened. Instead, the father Frantz simply showed up at the Thomas Ranch because he heard the baby might have been there. That just left me completely puzzled. By the way, the role of Souvenir was played by Buck and he got his own credit at the start of the picture - go figure.

It's not unusual to pick up on continuity goofs in these early pictures, and if you stay attentive you'll catch one here. In the scene when Frantz the Gypsy comes to claim the baby from the Thomases, Mr. Thomas (Wade Boteler) calls his daughter Nancy. Her name was Millicent.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Cowgirls Versus Cowboys
hines-20002 August 2020
There's much entertainment in this wonderful Joseph Kane directed western. For Autry, It's love at first sight gazing at the most beautiful and versatile actress Ann Rutherford. But Gypsy Frantz (Willy Castello) gets the jump on him and steals his rodeo prize money. But scene stealing wonder dog Buck gets the jump on Frantz and steals his baby. Wade Boteler fires his cowhands and Fern Emmett and the ladies take over in glorious fashion. The fired foreman, Al Bridge is not to be denied as the flamboyant cattle rustler. Gene and Frog have some great tunes and one even the baby enjoys. Gertrude Messinger and Marie Quillan play great supporting roles and Champion is always there when you need him.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Can't Find the Right Mix
dougdoepke14 April 2014
Looks like this is Gene's third movie and second for Republic. Unfortunately, it's not a very good one, at least in my little book. Follow the story if you can. It's something about hired hands rustling cattle from their owner. But the narrative's so spotty, it's hard to tell. Then there's the Gypsy baby, stolen by a friendly dog (Buck). The baby's carrier gets handled like a bundle of sticks, so we know it's really empty. Gene has to sort all this out, with the help of an all girl posse (!) and, of course, Frog.

The action finally picks up toward the end, with lots of hard riding. No flying fists, however, nor any fast shooting. Even Gene's songs are not very tuneful. Maybe the only memorable part is the Gypsy hoedown that's not exactly a Western staple. Then too, Ann Rutherford does make a winsome young woman. All in all, my advice is to catch the same year's Tumbling Tumbleweeds, which manages just the right Autry mix.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed