Hotel Haywire (1937) Poster

(1937)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
A zippy comedy that Zippe's right by.
mark.waltz26 December 2016
Warning: Spoilers
Sometimes, comedy makes house calls, and there was a medical emergency that required immediate treatment, making this the proper diagnosis. With broken English that would raise Lupe Velez's eyebrows, Leo Carrillo gives a hysterical performance as a quack doctor with the oddest ideas of treatment. In this totally off the wall farce, he separately counsels separated couple Spring Byington and Lynne Overman, obviously taking over for the unavailable Mary Boland and Charlie Ruggles. Byington is a bit befuddled ("He's the daughter of my father, I mean the father of my daughter"), consumed by astrology, and certain that her husband has been philandering, while Overman is a bit of a dipsomaniac and a gambler. Misunderstandings and wacky characters make this a real nuthouse, ending up in a hotel where more confusion ensues.

An early film of rising screenwriter and future legendary Preston Sturges, this was definitely overshadowed by his later A films, and lost among the B films of the 1930's. Overman seems to be emulating Ruggles every chance he gets and Byington seems to be imitating Boland's speech patterns, so their pairing is practically identical to the dozen films that Boland and Ruggles appeared in together. Some of the regular cast members later associated with Sturges appear in comical supporting roles, and often, this does appear like an overlong two reel short. Still, it's fluffy and fast, frantic and funny, so it is definitely worthy of being discovered.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Very zany plot is low on laughs and with a weak script
SimonJack16 December 2020
"Hotel Haywire" is a comedy with a zany plot but not many laughs. As all other directors, writers and movie makers, Preston Sturges sometimes had films that weren't top quality. This is one. The quality of this Paramount film hints that it's a B-level picture. That, and the cast signal that it may not be much more than fair. While it has a couple of well-known supporting actors in Spring Byington and Leo Carrillo, the lead role is played by Lynne Overman. He had just a few lead roles in the mid-1930s before becoming a supporting actor until he died in 1943 of a heart attack at age 55.

Overman was fair at comedy, as was Byington. Most of the rest of the cast in this film weren't even well known in that time. It's a zany plot, but the screenplay is choppy and has holes here and there. If the script had some comedy or witty dialog, it would lift this film considerably. But, it's just fair as is - and a long-shot on audience enjoyment. Most likely of interest only to those who enjoy the old black and white films.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
1937 Preston Sturges Comedy
theangryburgher17 March 2015
Warning: Spoilers
Before watching the Paramount 1937 Comedy "Hotel Haywire" I read several average to below average reviews of it. To my surprise, it was far better than expected. A hard to find Preston Sturges comedy, it was originally written for Burns and Allen. It is a madcap movie with enjoyable, wacky characters in the Sturges' mold. Lots of quick jokes, witty screwball dialogue surrounded by slapstick. Certainly not on par with his more famous early 1940s gems, it is still a fun romp. Lynne Overman and Spring Byington both shine as the lead characters, husband and wife, with great performances by Paramount's Porter Hall and Franklin Pangborn character actors. The frantic ending where everyone converges in adjoining hotel rooms is a gem. Not on par with "Libeled Lady" or "Palm Beach Story" but any fan of Sturges or Screwball comedies will enjoy it.
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed