Legion of the Lawless (1940) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
The Closing of the West
boblipton5 June 2013
This is a typically excellent George O'Brien western from RKO -- he made just shy of twenty of them from 1937 through 1940. Although a B picture, you'd never guess it, thanks in no small part to DP Harry Wild's camera-work -- his two-shots are like portraits, there are some nice Dutch angles and he manages to fit some nice traveling shots into the budget.

The story, about how lawyer O'Brien comes to town and takes on the vigilantes has some serious things to say, but they are reserved for the subtext. The story is so good it was remade a couple of years later as PIRATES OF THE PRAIRIE with Tim Holt.

If you think that B westerns are brainless shoot-em-ups shot on six-day schedules, this one can make a good corrective to the image.
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A simple, no-nonsense B-western.
planktonrules3 April 2022
Jeff Toland (George O'Brien) is a lawyer about to move to a town out west. However, the town is run by a 'vigilante committee'...a group that enforces what they THINK should be the law. If that isn't bad enough, many folks within the committee don't realize that one of the leaders is scum...and he's using the committee to add legitimacy to his very illegetimate work. What is this work? Chasing innocent folks out of the neighboring town in order to get their land, as the railroad is soon coming and will promise to make him rich. So, it's up to Jeff to try to stop them...by exposing their leader and getting all the 'sheep' in town to stand together against the committee.

George O'Brien is an odd looking sort of B-cowboy, as he doesn't look anything like the big stars of the day, such as Gene Autry. In fact, O'Brien doesn't sing nor act like most cowboys of the day...and that's okay by me. It's a nice change of pace and O'Brien was a good actor.

As for the film, it's much better than most B-westerns. Although the subject matter is rather familiar, it is well done and exciting...and a step or so better than most films in the genre.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A Creek Runs Through Them!
bsmith555219 July 2018
Warning: Spoilers
"Legion of the Lawless" is about a group of vigilantes in this entry in the George O' Brien RKO western series.

O'Brien plays a lawyer Jeff Toland who arrives all duded up at the dividing line between a split town...Ivestown and East Ivestown separated by a creek. The division as I understand it was that Ivestown would be set up for the so-called pioneers and would have the best land in the area whereas East Ivestown contained a group of nesters and farmers who got the worst of the available lands. Ivestown is run by a vigilante committee headed by Henry Ives (Hugh Sothern) but run behind the scenes by Les Harper (Norman Willis).

Toland sets up shop much to the dismay of Harper and his cronies which include Holmes (Bud Osborne), Borden (Monte Montegue and Ben (Slim Whitaker) who don't like strangers in their midst. Toland meets Ives daughter Ellen (Virginia Vale) but she doesn't want Toland to stay on either. Toland befriends a drunken Doc Denton (Herbert Heywood) and somehow reforms him. Young Eddie (Billy Benedict) hangs around as Toland's helper.

Believing that the railroad is coming through Ivestown, Harper begins bullying property owners buying their properties on the cheap in order to profit from the coming of the railroad. The rail road surveyor presents his report to Toland to be notarized and reveals that the railroad will be going through East Ivestown instead.

Borden overhears a part of the conversation and reports back to Harper. Harper decides that since Doc was present at the meeting, to have Holmes and Ben lure Doc into the saloon and fill him full of drinks. Doc unwittingly spills the beans and Harper and his masked gang begin to bully the residents of East Ivestown including the Blacksmith (Martin Garralaga) and the storekeeper Rafe Barton (Eddy Waller), giving them 48 hrs to get out of town.

Henry Ives meanwhile, has been convinced by Toland to call a meeting to disband the vigilante committee and select a sheriff. Harper sends his boys after Ives and murder him before he can preside at the meeting. Toland treis to reassure the East Ivestowners and goes to confront Harper and his gang and...........................................................................

Oh yes, Toland and the lovely Ellen resolve their differences and...................................
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
One of O'Brien's best!
JohnHowardReid17 June 2014
Warning: Spoilers
Long-time extra and very occasional character player Herbert Heywood has his only featured role here as Doctor Denton, and the movie is well worth seeing on his account only. But it also has lots of other features to recommend it, including an involving script that grabs attention right from the start and then proceeds to come to a great climax, plus top-of- the-mark direction by David Howard and splendid acting from all concerned, but especially George O'Brien, Virginia Vale and Norman Willis. As usual in O'Brien westerns, production values are remarkably high by "B"-feature standards. Available on an excellent Grapevine "George O'Brien" DVD, coupled with "Hollywood Cowboy".
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Legion of the Lawless
coltras3524 March 2024
Lawyer Jeff Toland hangs out his shingle in Ivestown, but is ordered out by a vigilante group headed by Les Harper. The vigilantes are merely a cloak under which the band of outlaws headed by Harper operate to terrorize and control the town. When it is learned that the new railroad survey takes the tracks through East Ivestown instead of Ivestown, the gang plans to drive out the homesteaders and ranchers along the right-of-way and file on the land themselves. Jeff leads the fight for the intended victims against the gang.

Legion of the Lawless (great title) is another lively western starring George O' Brien who is on top form as a lawyer. He gets tangled with lawlessness and vigilantism and Virginia Vale who plays the daughter of a vigilante leader - the good one. There's a bad vigilante played by Norman Willis who leads other bad apples in the vigilante group.

This RKO western is engaging, has some snappy and witty dialogue and a good chemistry from O' Brien and Virginia Vale - there's an intelligence to the plot, but also a little action to keep things ticking.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed