Scattergood Baines (1941) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Surprisingly good...and it makes me want to find the sequels.
planktonrules2 September 2023
Despite the weird title and the film being made on a shoestring budget, "Scattergood Baines" is a pretty enjoyable movie. It stars Guy Kibbee...an actor who often managed to elevate B-movies just by his natural and enjoyable acting.

Scattergood is a salesman who arrives with very little in a small town. Despite this, through hard work and wisdom, he soon creates a small empire--with a store and railroad serving this community that he's made his own. Years pass and a group of shrew investors have decided to offer Scattergood a tempting deal...to sell out and retire. But Scattergood is more than just a man who wants to make a buck...he wants to offer good jobs to his friends in the community and he's loathe to sell out to people who have little regard for anything other than the bottom line. What follows next is an occasionally sad look at human nature at its ugliest....as well as best.

The writing, direction and acting are all much better than B-movie quality. Despite the economy and short running time, the film leaves you wanting more. On the positive side, there are several sequels which also star Kibbee...but on the negative, I cannot find them! This first film is currently on YouTube.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Folksy Humor
boblipton1 March 2006
It's a little startling to see Guy Kibbee in a toupee -- actually two toupees, since the movie begins with a prologue with him as a young man -- but once you grow used to him, he looks perfectly natural.

By the time the main story begins, Kibbee, or Scattergood Baines, the eponym of this movie, is the owner of a hardware store and the leading citizen of Cold River -- good, folksy advice is free. This is the first of a small series done from a series of story by Clarence Buddington Kelland and while it not a great movie, it is very pleasantly directed by underrated old hand Christy Cabanne, who manages to insert the occasional interesting shot when the mood calls for it. All in all, a pleasant second feature.
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Good intentions are the pathways to success.
mark.waltz22 June 2017
Warning: Spoilers
It takes one big mind to turn things around in a small minded town. Guy Kibbee takes on the role of a wise old man who basically took over running the town's big business by outsmarting the town elders when he was a (somwhat) young man and now must face progress of a different sort by avoiding losing what he's gained through his own craftiness. In the process, he becomes matchmaker, surrogate father and psychiatrist while showing the stuffy, prune faced elders a thing or two about life.

'Some day, you'll get your tongue in a knot and choke yourself to death," Kibbee tells stonefaced Fern Emmett, meddling in the hiring of a beautiful young school teacher Carol Hughes while stirring the rest of the town up over his efforts to prevent himself from losing control of the local railroad. Bradley Page adds another snarly villain to his resume as the big city slicker who underestimates the smarts of a supposedly naive hick. Paul White, followed by Willie Best, plays the slow moving but fast dancing black drifter whom Kibbee aids in settling down. Lee "Lasses" White as the train conductor (married to the prune-faced Emmett) is a hoot, not aging at all from the opening scenes through the meat of the story 20 years later.

With Ms. Emmett (resembling the more famous Margaret Hamilton and the lesser known Doro Merande) and other lesser known character actors lining out the cast of provincial stereotypes, this is a passable time filler with a few lessons learned along the way. Emma Dunn, best known as Lew Ayres' mother in the Dr. Kildare series, plays Kibbee's gracious wife. Kibbee would take this character through five more films, but I doubt that the formula stretched much past this one.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed