Mister Gardenia Jones (1942) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
The Closest Reagan Came To An Oscar
bkoganbing7 November 2009
For no appreciable reason other than some name players acted in it, Mister Gardenia Jones was nominated for Best Short Subject in 1941. It's a nice, but not terribly exciting promotion for the United Service Organization. Our men in uniform need a place to go and things to do when they're stationed far away at military posts is the message and the USO provides same.

Fay Bainter and Charles Winninger are the parents of a soldier who has been drafted and Laraine Day his girlfriend from next door and he writes of the loneliness and boredom when he's off duty.

But what really makes this short unique and historical is the presence of two US Presidents. One of course was Franklin D. Roosevelt present via some newsreel footage. The second was a guy who probably never dreamed he'd be president at that point in time. Ronald Reagan is in the title role and while he took top prize in politics, the Oscar this short was nominated for was the closest he'd come to one in his other profession. Ironic ain't it.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
MGM wartime promotional short for the USO...
Doylenf7 November 2009
A good curiosity piece is this wartime promotional short from MGM starring RONALD REAGAN in the title role. Why Reagan is doing this for MGM (rather than his home studio, Warner Brothers) is questionable. The fact that it's a pitch for people giving to the USO (so servicemen won't be bored with nothing to do) is probably the reason Reagan volunteered his services to another studio.

LARAINE DAY is his pretty hometown girlfriend, FAY BAINTER is his doting mother and CHARLES WINNINGER is Reagan's jovial father. For good measure, CHILL WILLS has a featured role.

This is a typical short feature shown as a part of double feature programs during the '40s. It's well-intentioned but comes across as rather weak stuff today.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
"I'm going to join up!"
classicsoncall7 November 2009
Warning: Spoilers
I probably wouldn't have stuck around for this short following today's presentation of "The Big Wheel" on TCM, but seeing Ronald Reagan's name in the credits prompted me to give it a go. Apparently filmed as a promotional vehicle for the USO, the story ends with a request for donations to help fund the cause. I was actually taken aback somewhat by a reference to the anger soldiers felt with the boredom of stateside life, as if the horrors of war might have offered a better alternative.

Reagan fans might be surprised to see the future President providing a beefcake tease in a scene where he gets to take a much desired hot shower. Striking in a military uniform, he also gets to mix it up in mid-air against Japanese kamikaze pilots, taking out three Zero's in the process. That scene would have been the filmmaker's response to repeated references about December 7th, 1941, a day 'marked for black vengeance' by U.S. fighting forces.

The picture left me wondering how Reagan ever consented to portraying a character named Gardenia, reinforced by a couple of home town scenes with Ma and Pa Jones and sweetheart Joanne (Laraine Day) huddled around a gardenia plant in bloom. The bigger surprise for me though was how this short managed to get nominated for a Best Documentary Oscar. Though generally OK given the nature of it's message, I can't imagine what the competition might have been like.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Reagan's in Hot Water
wes-connors21 June 2009
On December 7, 1941 - according to President Franklin D. Roosevelt, "A date which will live in infamy!" - Lieutenant Ronald Reagan (as John "Mister Gardenia" Jones Jr.) finds himself stationed in Hawaii. His pretty sweetheart Laraine Day (as Joanne) helps mother Fay Bainter (as Emmy Jones) and father Charles Winninger (as John Jones Sr.) keep the home fires burning. They have a typical American home. Writer/narrator Carey Wilson explains how Mr. Reagan came to be called "Deany" (shortened from Gardenia). Reagan and his parents survive faltering patriotism, due to boredom; but, they rally 'round the flag when the Japanese attack. The USO (United Service Organizations) want you to support them by sending money for the war cause.

*** Mister Gardenia Jones (5/29/42) Carey Wilson ~ Ronald Reagan, Fay Bainter, Charles Winninger
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Mostly a promo for the USO -- and that's not bad
morrisonhimself28 June 2009
There is not really a lot of substance to "Mister Gardenia Jones." In fact, it seems to be an excerpt, or perhaps a trailer for a feature film, one that apparently didn't get produced.

As a stand-alone film, it is lacking; as a promo or advertisement for the U.S.O., it is very ... well, I guess one could say "subtle." As a flag-waver or patriotic recruiter, it doesn't say much, either.

There are four major performers and one more who became one, Chill Wills, so whatever was intended, there were some good people involved.

Now, though, it seems to be almost a novelty, or a vignette of how Hollywood, and especially Warner Brothers, treated the war, and for that reason alone "Mister Gardenia Jones" is a must-see.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Reagan WW2 short
Michael_Elliott4 April 2009
Mister Gardenia Jones (1942)

** 1/2 (out of 4)

Ronald Reagan stars in this Oscar-nominated short from writer/narrator Carey Wilson. In the film Reagan plays the title character, a young man who joins the Army in early 1941 hoping for something to do. He soon realizes that all he and thousands of other soldiers can do is sit around waiting for something to happen and it does when Pearl Harbor is attacked. This film is certainly adventurous as it tries to do a lot in its 13-minute running time. On one level it tries to be a documentary while on another level it wants to tell a simple story. Then, on yet another level, the movie wants to be a fund raiser asking for people to dip into their pockets and give money. All in all the film is fairly entertaining with the young Reagan taking the lead and giving a decent performance. Getting to see Reagan is the main reason to watch this film as there were countless WW2 films made during this period and several of them are better than this one.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed