Lake Placid Serenade (1944) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Star on skates, but icy actress on screen.
mark.waltz29 April 2015
Warning: Spoilers
Czech born Vera Hruba (Ralston) was a Hollywood inside joke, sort of a poor man's Marian Davies and definitely no rival to 20th Century Fox skating actress Sonja Henie. Even if Ms. Henie was no actress, she was at least somewhat attractive and pleasant to see, while Ms. Hruba (Ralston) photographed strangely and was never even remotely believable even in the simplest of movie situations. I've only seen her in a handful of Republic movies (two with the "Duke") and each time was left rather cold by her. Like Marian Davies and William Randolph Hearst, and Norma Shearer and Irving Thalberg, she married extremely well (Republic head Herbert J. Yates), and love off screen didn't become magic for her on screen with movie audiences, staring in 15 years of critically maligned flops that today range between acceptable cinema and outrageously bad melodramas that would have been great material for the wise-cracking aliens of "Mystery Science Theater", the biggest mystery being why Yates thought he could crack her into the realm of movie star in an era when beauties like Lana Turner, Rita Hayworth and Betty Grable were packing in World War II weary audiences. Even after the war, he kept putting her into his biggest projects. Fortunately, when he made his biggest hit ("The Quiet Man"), he realistically put in a real Irish woman (Maureen O'Hara) in the film instead of her.

This literally is a Cinderella story, with Czechlosovakia's premiere skater discovering as the Nazi's are preparing to take over her homeland that she is the niece of a wealthy American (Eugene Palette). She is welcomed into his home and immediately causes a ruckus between handsome Robert Livingston and her spoiled cousins who are both in love with him. One's bitchy and calculating, while the other is an Eve Arden realistic wisecracker. It's clear that the two sisters hate each other, and at first, Vera's presence causes more conflict, especially when Livingston takes an instant liking to her and two promoters of an upcoming Ice Follies (Walter Catlett and William Frawley) recognize her and try to get Palette to allow her to sign up for their spectacle.

While there are a few elaborate skating numbers (plus the presence of none other than Roy Rogers singing "Winter Wonderland"), the film has a sort of cheap look about it with blury photography and long single shot scenes without any cuts and very few close-ups. The few Ms. Hruba does get are not very flattering, and unlike other actresses who were not great beauties but had on-screen magic, she fails to light up the screen except during her skating sequences, and then that only occurs when the camera isn't right on her. Surround her with great comic talent like Palette, Catlett, Frawley and Barbara Jo Allen (aka Vera Vague, playing a Gracie Allen like countess), and the audiences just might forgive her for not sparkling on screen. Her legacy today is that she had a career based upon true love from a much older movie mogul who saw something in her that unfortunately the movie going public did not.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Country girl makes good in new country
horn-524 March 2007
...or Cinderella goes abroad to meet Prince Charming. But, first, on a peaceful winter in Czechoslonakia, the genial godfather, Jaroslav Haschek (Lloyd Corrigan), of Vera Hascheck (Vera Hruba Ralston), presents the young girl with her first pair of ice skates. Soon, she astonished the warm-hearted people of her village with her skill, and she is acclaimed a marvel-on-ice.

She wins the ice-skating championship of her country and is invited to skate at the fabulous Lake Placid Carnival in the United States. Vera receives an offer of a contract from eager showman, Carlton Webb (Walter Catlett), and his press agent Jiggers (William Fraley) - but she turns them down. The financial back for the two men is a wealthy, gabby, man-chasing woman called "Countess" (Barbara Joe Allen as Vera Vague.) Vera is a sensation at Lake Placid when she learns of Nazi Germany's move on Czechoslovakia, and she immediately attempts to abandon her career and rejoin her people. The trip can not be arranged and, alone in a strange country, she seeks an uncle, Carl Cermack (Eugene Palette), who has become a prosperous American citizen.

The uncle welcomes her to his sumptuous Lond Island home, where he lives with his spoiled débutante daughters Irene (Stephanie Bachelor) and Susan (Ruth Terry.) Vera learns that the two sisters are fighting it out over the same man, Paul Jordan (Robert Livingston), Cermack's junior partner, who isn't overwhelmed by either sister.

Vera invites her uncle and cousins to join her at Lake Placid, where she is to appear in the dazzling New Year's Eve ballet. She is named "Queen" of the ballet, and Roy Rogers (Roy Rogers), a visiting cowboy star is named "King." (This was the period where Republic was pushing Rogers as The King of the Cowboys, and was missing no bets to increase his audience. Trigger was there, also, but didn't get crowned anything) Paul begins to pick up interest in Vera, and she agrees to sign a contract with Webb, provided she can use an assumed name in his shows. Jiggers suggests they call her "Cinderella," because shoe has lost one of her famous skates. When Vera opens at Madison Square Garden, Jiggers plants the story that she refuses to appear until her skate is returned. Aware that Paul has kept her skate as a souvenir, Cermack telephones his partner in Texas. On the night of the opening, Webb and Jiggers are driven to desperation, since Vera has taken their publicity gag in earnest and refuses to go on unless her skate is returned. None of the phony "Prince Charmings" Jiggers has hired has the right skate, of course. The weary Vera doesn't even look at the last applicant - but the skate is hers. She stares down and recognizes her godfather, Jaroslav, who has been brought to American by her uncle. He explains that her skate was given to him by a young man. He beckons into the crowd and Paul emerges. Vera finds herself in the arms of her own Prince Charming.

(Shortly after this film, Vera Hruba Ralston, became what Time Magazine liked to call...a great and good friend and companion...of Republic Pictures Corporation president Herbert J. Yates---you had to know how to read between the lines in those days.) A few years later, after Yates divorced his wife, Vera Hbura Ralston became Mrs. Herbert J. Yates.)
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Dazzling spectacle
jarrodmcdonald-14 September 2016
Warning: Spoilers
It's interesting to see Vera Ralston when she was younger and playing a character modeled more closely on herself. Her ethnicity isn't referenced much if at all in the films she made during the 50s, since I suppose she had become more Americanized. With its Christmas theme and the presence of Robert Livingston and Eugene Palette in both, LAKE PLACID SERENADE and THE CHEATERS would make an excellent double feature on TCM or at a festival. I expected this one to be a bit derivative of Sonja Henie's vehicles, and it certainly is, but that is to its advantage because these types of movies are always charming and most entertaining.

Speaking of derivative, the comic relief done by Barbara Allen (Vera Vague) seems inspired by Gracie Allen. This type of humor seems a little forced in spots and does not hold up well today, but her line deliveries are still good. I am wondering if the Vera Vague character acted similarly on radio. The word 'vague' in her name might suggest she did.

Back to the story-- I especially liked the way the screenplay alluded to Cinderella and had our heroine losing one of ice skates. I kept thinking this business would have worked very well with someone like Judy Canova, though I guess Judy was no skater. Because Vera Ralston winds up with the guy at the end, and even Vera Vague lands a man, I suppose we can assume the two sisters (played by Stephanie Bachelor and Ruth Terry) remain unlucky in love. Considering how ruthless Stephanie Bachelor's character was, it might be poetic justice.

A major highlight of the picture is the guest appearance by Roy Rogers and his rendition of 'Winter Wonderland.' The production notes for the film on the TCM database indicate he and Vera Ralston made a special appearance together in Lake Place, New York where the film premiered in December 1944.

Another thing I like is the way the scenes are lit. John Alton was one of the better cinematographers of the 40s and 50s, and Republic had Alton work on several pictures, including LAKE PLACID SERENADE. HIs skilled use of backlighting creates a sense of warmth which nicely complements the dreamy music on the soundtrack during the skating sequences. And the warm lighting and use of steam (which seems to be a recurring motif), enhance the exterior scenes, to provide a luminous quality amid snowy landscapes and ice. Put a wintertime ballerina in the middle of it, and the audience is treated to a dazzling spectacle.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed