Eadie Was a Lady (1945) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Another Ann Miller Film From Columbia
timothymcclenaghan10 November 2012
This film is another entry in the "B" movie group of movies starring Ann Miller produced by Columbia Pictures. Despite that status, there were very talented members of the crew who became prominent later on in Hollywood. Choreographer Jack Cole makes an early career appearance showing his distinctive, original style in the film's production numbers. Cole went on to do choreography for A pictures at both Columbia and 20th Century Fox, notably Gentlemen Prefer Blondes with Marilyn Monroe. Also, Sammy Cahn and Jule Styne provide original music. They were evidently staff composers for Columbia, also composing original music for many other films at that studio. Cahn became one of Frank Sinatra's favorite composers.

LIke most of the other Columbia Miller films, the flimsy plot is just an excuse to sing and dance. Miller fans will be pleased to see the tap dancing production numbers, as well as her song performances. Joe Besser provides comedy, which may have been funny in the day, but now seems very dated. Jeff Donnell plays the airhead girlfriend, the same type of role she played in many other films. So even though it's formulaic, it has enough pleasant moments to make watching it worthwhile. It's not the best Ann Miller film, but not the worst either.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
And Annie is a wonder!
mark.waltz28 December 2018
Warning: Spoilers
This B musical mixes several different genres, combining the college musical with a backstage musical, combining them into the premise of young heiress Ann Miller going from burlesque chorus to burlesque queen all the while attending college under the nose and thumb of snooty aunt Katherine Howard. She is initially seeing dancing in the chorus of a cheaper less show with star Marion Martin actually getting booze andthen moved up to a featured spot where she literally eats cake while dressed as Marie Antoinette. When the young talented Martin leaves the show for another gig, Miller takes over but fears of her true identity being revealed keep her cautious, especially in public. When the vindictive Martin has the show rated, all comes out and Miller has to face both her aunt and the college board with threats of expulsion.

One of her last musicals at Columbia, this features her dancing a lot more than all but the last one ("The Thrill of Brazil") in numbers choreographed by veteran dance director Robert Alton. While Miller does her traditional fast tapping turns, she is surrounded by very ordinary-looking sets that makes the big musical numbers a bit boring. Considering what she would do at MGM just a few years later, that makes this look rather cheap and quickly put together.

In support of Annie are funny fat man Joe Besser, the dingy Jeff Donnell (longtime "General Hospital" maid Stella Fields), and Will Wright as the scheming producer. Besser, a poor man's Lou Costello, has one funny sketch involving a spit-take, but as amusing as he is, I can see him only being tolerable in small doses. This is not bad for a second string movie musical but had it done something about the set design for the numbers Annie works hard in, I might have ranked it a bit higher for my rating.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed