Carnival in Costa Rica (1947) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Parental vs. self choice of a marital partner, during carnival time
estherwalker-3471018 August 2021
Warning: Spoilers
A Technicolor feast! Poor Cesar Romero! He seemingly had it all to be a top leading man. Tall, classically handsome, charismatic, adept at comedy, and with a name he was born with that exuded prominence. This 'Latin from Manhattan' did become a star in quite a few '40s Fox musicals and romantic comedies. But, while he often romanced the leading lady for a while, he almost never ended up with her at film's ending. No doubt, his Latin heritage relegated him to being the perennial supporting male lead, as he is here, where this 40y.o is playing a school boy freshly returned to Costa Rico from studies in the US. He's at least 10 years older than the 3 other romantic leads, but you wouldn't really know it. He had a flair for comedy, as shown in some of his films, including a bit in this one, when he put on dark glasses and pretended he had a bad cough, and was otherwise debilitated, when he met Vera-Ellen, his wife-to-be, according to their fathers. He had found a girlfriend(played by Celeste Holms) in the US, who had accompanied him to Costa Rico..............Dick Haymes was firstly known for his mellow singing. But, he sometimes served as the leading man or second lead in mid-'40s Fox musicals, being rather handsome, if sometimes rather wooden. Unfortunately, all of these films, including this one, are among the most obscure of Fox '40s musicals, although some have a fairly high IMDB mean rating. This film is available for free at YouTube, and, unlike some, has a DVD out for sale. Here, he plays an American coffee buyer, Costa Rica being most famous at this time, for growing coffee. He singled out Vera-Ellen, playing a Costa Rican, in a parade, and established a romantic relationship with her. Periodically, he sings, alone or with another..............Vera-Ellen was known firstly for her slim figure and athletic dancing, which she somewhat displays here, although her long Costa Rican dress largely hid her famous legs. She has 2 productions where her dancing is featured: one early on, at a fiesta, where she spends part of the time dancing with famous Russian and international dancer and choreographer Leonide Massine, who choreographed the whole production. Her second dance production occurred rather late in the film, during her supposed dream of marrying Dick Haymes' character. At 26, this was one of her early films, after being included in 2 Danny Kay films. She looked and seemed younger than her age, with a 'little girl' smiley face. She also looked rather fragile, with the smallest waist in Hollywood, due, in part, to her anorexia, which wasn't even recognized as a psychological problem at this time. She 'sings' several times, but her singing was always dubbed. Here, she plays the daughter of an American mother and Costa Rican father, with a presumed dark wig covering her normally light brown hair. However, it's still difficult to explain her obviously very fair skin. Like Cesar, she is characterized as having recently returned from studying in the US, and marked by her father to marry Cesar's character. However, she soon develops her own idea of whom she wants to marry..............Celeste Holm is the 4th lead, ending up as Cesar's American wife whom Cesar met while studying in the US. She was a good-looking extrovert blond, and seemed to have a good singing voice. This was only her 2nd film. She would receive an Oscar in her next film. However, her Hollywood career was rather brief, she preferring the stage and, later, TV series work, NYC being her preferred home...............J. Carrol Naish, playing Vera-Ellen's father , usually played ethnics, often Latinos. With his dark Latin looks I was shocked to discover that he had Irish ancestry! .............. The famous Cuban composer Ernesto Lecuona is listed in the credits as a bandleader. I may have seen him very briefly, but not sure. However, all the songs were adaptations of his music. Unfortunately, his 2 most famous compositions: Malaguena, and Siboney, were not included............. The screenplay focuses on the conflict between the fathers and their children, played by Cesar and Vera Ellen, as to whom they will marry. Also, there is a bit of switching around among the 4 romantic stars, as was typical of musicals of that period. The uncertainty extends to the finale............. Otherwise, there is much Latin gaiety to be experienced. If you like that sort of thing, I can recommend another very obscure film: the 1941 "Fiesta", produced by Hal Roach, and available at You Tube. I have yet to see the 1947 Esther Williams film also titled "Fiesta", and confused with the '41 film at YouTube.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Hats Off for William H. Reynolds!
JohnHowardReid18 October 2016
Warning: Spoilers
Here's another of those colorful yet mindless set-in-Latin-America musicals where flashily costumed principals and extras burst into high-spirited songs and dances at the drop of an embroidered serape. The story is as slight as passione con amore on ice – and played with as much expression as rigor mortis by pedestrian second-players like J. Carroll Naish and Pedro de Cordoba. Watching this movie is like drinking root beer with chili sauce, although the rest of the cast is pleasant enough. Even Cesar Romero is only half as ridiculous as he usually appears as he spends half of the film hiding his overwrought smile and vacuous face behind dark glasses. Dick Haymes is somewhat wooden as usual, but he doesn't come on for over half an hour. Fritz Feld is usually a pain, but he feeds some good lines here and makes an agreeable comic. Ratoff's direction is extremely skillful for once. My guess is the film editor stood as his side, as the editing is incredibly smooth. And the editor is no less than William H. Reynolds, regarded by both his peers and producers as one of the best three film editors of all time! Leonide Massine's choreography, for instance, particularly in the fiesta sequence, is quite dazzlingly colorful, and notice how brilliantly it is edited!
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Funny, not flattering
Marcelacf27 July 2007
I found the movie humorous, fun and enjoyable but I can easily understand why my grandparents found it offensive. Being Costa Rican I have heard how the sections of the movie that were filmed in Costa Rica caused great commotion at the time even though none of the main actors came to the country (at least for filming). When the movie finally opened in Costa Rica people were upset of how the people and the country had been misrepresented. Even though the movie exerts attitudes and prejudices towards Latin America, as well as ignorance over the social and cultural differences between Latin American countries and Spain it reflects the ignorance (or innocence?) of the 1940s. At the end, for all the cultural improprieties doesn't make "Carnival in Costa Rica" any less enjoyable.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Worth seeing because of the great dancer Leonide Massine.
Petrushka11 August 2003
I saw this movie in 1947 when it first was released. Mainly because I was a young dance student at that time and I wanted to see the great Leonide Massine, famous because of his discovery by Serge Diaghilev and the Ballet Russe. He replaced the great Vaslav Nijinsky. He appeared in this film during his latter years, but even so you can see what a great dancer he was.

Unfortunately, the producers of this film did not really understand or appreciate his fame and greatness, or give him proper credit. He could have been just another studio dancer. Vera Ellen had a hard time keeping up with him during their only dance sequence.

Interesting that Massine, who came from Moscow and was a Russian trained in the Russina ballet, became such a wonderful Spanish dancer.

This seems to have been his forte and shows well in this film. A pity that I was too young to ever have seen him on the stage. But his choreography is continually revived by ballet companies the world over.
9 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Cesar a bit long in the tooth
jgrant391914 January 2007
Cesar was 40 when this movie was made, at least a decade and a half older than the character should be for an arranged marriage. It appears they tried to hide his age via makeup and hair dye, but these ruses are as convincing as happy, dirt-free coffee-pickers singing their way through a day of hot drudgery. Having said that, this movie, seen in January 2007 on the Fox Movie Channel, is surprisingly watchable. The costumes and dancing and songs are easy on the eyes. Cesar may be too old to play a young buck dealing with parents trying to arrange a marriage, but he is still the great Cesar Romero, of later fame as "The Joker" on Batman.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Not very good
HotToastyRag20 May 2021
This 20th Century Fox musical really isn't very good, but if you like the cast, you can give it a try like I did. I love Vera-Ellen and always try her movies since she didn't make very many. Her talents really aren't utilized in this movie, though. Her dancing is down-played, her famous legs are hidden, she's given a dishwater-colored wig to make her look Costa Rican -What?- and for some unknown reason she's scrubbed clean of all her makeup. Without her eye makeup, she looks like Shirley Temple's homelier sister, instead of the made-up glamourous lady she usually plays.

The plot is funny, though. Vera-Ellen and Cesar Romero's families have arranged their marriage. They've never met, and she wants to be free to fall in love. Cesar already has a girlfriend, Celeste Holm, so he doesn't want to get married either. To thwart the engagement, he sets a plan to make himself repulsive to her so she'll call off the engagement. He wears dark glasses to take care of his watering eyes, stoops over, coughs incessantly due to an infected trachea, shuffles little steps because it's difficult for him to stand for long periods of time without getting tired, and asks for her help in taking his various pills because he's color-blind. It's very funny, but since Vera-Ellen's polite, she doesn't call things off.

At the carnival, though, she meets Dick Haymes and falls in love. She a ridiculous pick-up line and doesn't care about anything except his supposed pretty face. But what about Cesar Romero's pretty face? And what's wrong with these studios putting talented people in musicals and not letting them participate? In State Fair, trained opera singer Dana Andrews wasn't allowed to sing; and in Carnival in Costa Rica, trained ballroom dancer Cesar Romero wasn't allowed to dance. I didn't enjoy this one, but you can try it out and see if you like it.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
vera ellen is always worth watching
ceva19 April 2002
This 20th Century Fox musical has several problems, including an uneven script and uninspired choreography. However, the flaws are countered with some strengths. The color photography and costumes are lovely. And the cast is good, especially leading lady Vera-Ellen and Celeste Holm.
6 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Fiesta! South America! ... Anne Revere??
moonspinner5521 May 2009
Mixture of the new Latin appreciation with the old Hollywood guard results in stilted musical from Fox. Vera-Ellen, who ricochets around the dance floor while never losing her smile, plays a young lass down South American way who changes her mind about an arranged marriage to Cesar Romero. She loves creepy, corn-fed Dick Haymes instead, while Cesar is currently squiring New York gal Celeste Holm around Costa Rica. The weirdest casting must be rigid-backed Anne Revere as Vera-Ellen's mother, who hovers over her daughter like a clucking goose yet doesn't even recognize her own child when she sees her on a parade float. The production is well-dressed--and blessedly gets outside of the studio on several occasions--but the music score seems built around one monotonously cheerful tune, and Romero comes off like a Latin Don Ameche: whipped and all wet. *1/2 from ****
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Worth watching
martex344 August 2002
This is good to watch if only for Vera-Ellen, Celeste Holme, Ceasar Romero, J. Carrol Naish, Anne Revere, and especially, the great crooner Dick Haymes who had a marvelous voice and wasn't a bad actor either.....only the material was schlocky in this one. I would recommend Costa Rica use this for tourism!
3 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed