Mr. Reckless (1948) Poster

(1948)

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
4/10
Well oiled melodrama
bkoganbing31 July 2014
The world of the oilfields and the grand opera are about as disparate as you can get. But this Pine-Thomas production from Paramount has some similar plot lines as MGM's Maytime.

William Eythe has come home, he's an oil field roustabout traveling any place at anytime when a new oil field opens up with jobs. All that has made him Mr. Reckless, Eythe will do just about anything on a dare. But one thing he won't do is settle down and girl friend Barbara Britton is tired of waiting. She's decided to marry Nestor Paiva who owns a traveling eatery that caters to the oil field workers. You can imagine how Eythe takes the news, especially since he's friends with Paiva as well.

Mr. Reckless is one well oiled melodrama ending with the inevitable clash between Eythe and Paiva. Some nice location shots of the work at the oil drills and a patriotic coda as to how oil will save the world. In the 66 years between this film and now that's certainly been the case.

NOT.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
They Knew What They Didn't Want
boblipton29 October 2019
Oil worker William Eythe blows back into town. His pal Nestor Pavia prepares to shut down his restaurant, start up a food service at the oil field where Eythe will be working, and marry Barbara Britton. Pavia doesn't know the Miss Britton is about to marry him because Eythe dumped her for further fields, nor does he suspect that they still have yens for each other.

Like most Pine-Thomas productions, this has a very derivative plot, half straight out of THEY KNEW WHAT THEY WANTED, and half out of every other Edward G. Robinson movie in which he didn't play a gangster. Director Frank MacDonald starts things off with a humorous sequence in which Eythe and a taxicab crash into Pavia's diner on its last night of operation, but after that it settles into its predictable plot, with MacDonald and his cast unable to breathe much life into the story. There is some pretty good comic relief provided by Walter Catlett, Lloyd Corrigan, and Minna Gombell. The movie as a whole never surprises.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Mr. Reckless
CinemaSerf5 January 2023
William Eythe heads the cast in the pretty unremarkable little drama as "Lundy". He is a bit of a cock-sure oil worker who returns home to find that his erstwhile girlfriend "Betty" (Barbara Britton) has gone and gotten herself engaged to his older friend "Gus" (Nestor Paiva). Determined to win her back, he demonstrates how he earned his eponymous nickname with almost catastrophic results for just about everyone! At times it is quite a light-hearted affair, with a decent enough supporting cast working hard to keep the derivative storyline just a little bit interesting, but largely this is a standard afternoon feature that I doubt I will remember this time next week.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
You know what is going to happen at the end....it's just HOW it gets there is unknown until near the end.
planktonrules23 January 2014
Warning: Spoilers
Jeff Lundy (William Eythe) is in the oil drilling business. He's been away from his hometown for a long time and when he returns, he finds that his old girlfriend, Betty (Barbara Britton) is now engaged to a much older guy, Gus (yes, it IS Gus--Nestor Paiva). Anyone who knows old films knows that it's inevitable that Jeff and Betty will eventually get together, you have a lot of film in between.

In between this, there are lots of problems--such as a crazy guy who is vicious and dangerous (nearly killing Betty's father and Jeff) and the wedding. However, as the wedding cannot take place since Jeff and Betty are destined to be together, the same man manages to hurt Gus very badly. Unfortunately, when Gus recovers, he thinks Jeff and Betty are going to run off together and ends up getting himself killed when he attacks Jeff.

I cannot stress enough that you know what will happen and the surprises in between are slight. Because of that and the lack of charisma of the two leads, it's a film you could easily skip. Not terrible but it could have been a lot better--especially the ending which was way too abrupt and difficult to believe.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
"I love you until my heart chokes my wind pipes..."
mark.waltz10 April 2013
Warning: Spoilers
This is another film noir (abliet one on a $1.99 budget) where a few familiar faces go down territory already done in "Double Indemnity" and "The Postman Always Rings Twice". It all surrounds the old lover (William Eythe) of Barbara Britton's who returns to discover that she's about to wed aging Nestor Paiva, a really old pal of his, the stereotypical Italian restaurant owner who talks and when he's not eating...and eating . Quite a bit of comedy is thrown in involving Britton's father Lloyd Corrigan (who has a gambling problem) and the nagging by mama Minna Gombell, wife of Walter Catlett who runs a boarding house near the oil fields where all of the workers stay, including Eythe. "Don't tell me to mind my own business because that's something I never do", Gombell says, indicating that she, not Catlett, wears the pants in the family. Even with Eythe constantly around, Britton pledges allegiance to Paiva until the day of the wedding, and, well, you know..

When you first start watching this movie, it comes off as a comedy, and Eythe is written to be a bit of a handsome buffoon, so it's easy to see why he's taken in by Britton. Paiva, Corrigan, Frank Jenks as the drunken cab driver (who passes out in the backseat when Eythe takes over) and Catlett add far too much forced buffoonery which gives this film the feeling of having a split personality. This has the feeling of a quick writing job of an early television anthology series episode with unbelievable characters and a situation as ridiculous as the wind pipe line which Corrigan actually tells his bride-to-be (or not to be). Is that the question? It's obvious that the writers were bored so they decided to mix comedy and noir.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
okay story of competition for pretty girl....
ksf-25 July 2018
Star William Eythe only made two more films after this, and died of hepatits at the age of 38. Eythe is "Jeff", oil field worker, who checks up on his old girl friend, and decides to try to get her back. Co-stars the awesome Walter Catlett and Barbara Britton. This one fell into public doman, but the version i saw on Moonlight Movies was actually pretty good condition. It's a Paramount short shortie, at 66 minutes, but they pack a lot into that time. Jeff is determined to show off in the oil fields to win his girlfriend back. It's okay, and since it's a B short film, it's on Moonlight Movies channel. Another Pine Thomas Production, for Paramount. Directed by Frank McDonald, king of the westerns, about half way through his directing career. Pretty solid story, if a little slow-moving.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Mediocre, At Best
dougdoepke8 July 2018
Spotty 1948 programmer. On the whole, the mix of humor and oil well theatrics fails to achieve much impact. Events simply follow one another without really building. Too bad, for example, that Hugo's slow drowning from being trapped in an oil tank is not played up. The tension in that sort of setup is maximo to say the least. Then too Corrigan's comedic antics as Hugo are too often overdone and don't blend that well. I suspect the overall results were aimed at a mostly youthful audience. Also, it looks like the plot of blue-collar workers vying for the same girl is borrowed from such betters as Flowing Gold (1940) and Manpower (1941). But those were studio produced with much bigger budgets and stars than this indie production. Frankly, I tuned in to catch the sparkly Barbara Britton of TV's Mr. & Mrs. North in movie form. Trouble is her tag-along character Betty is pretty grim-faced throughout. In fact, I hardly recognized her. Anyway, there's a few good oil field scenes, while the few process shots are not obvious. Nonetheless, the 70-minutes amounts to a standard programmer and little more. Maybe for a slow evening, at best.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed