After the Civil War, a highly decorated Shoshone Indian veteran plans to raise cattle in Wyoming but white farmers plan to grab fertile tribal lands by pitting the whites against the Indians... Read allAfter the Civil War, a highly decorated Shoshone Indian veteran plans to raise cattle in Wyoming but white farmers plan to grab fertile tribal lands by pitting the whites against the Indians.After the Civil War, a highly decorated Shoshone Indian veteran plans to raise cattle in Wyoming but white farmers plan to grab fertile tribal lands by pitting the whites against the Indians.
- Awards
- 2 nominations
- Posse Member
- (uncredited)
- Townsman
- (uncredited)
- Mrs. Campbell
- (uncredited)
- Posse Member
- (uncredited)
- Mary
- (uncredited)
- Director
- Writer
- All cast & crew
- Production, box office & more at IMDbPro
Storyline
Did you know
- TriviaAfter an unsuccessful May 1950 press preview, MGM shelved the film. The grim movie was superbly made, but its uncompromising, downbeat story seemed to spell box-office disaster. After the release of the more mainstream Broken Arrow (1950) the following fall, it did get some bottom-of-the-bill bookings in neighborhood grindhouses but did little business and has remained little seen.
- GoofsDuring a thunderstorm, the lightning and thunder don't always exactly coincide. This only happens when lightning is directly overhead, as light travels faster than sound. Usually, there is some lag time after the occurrence of lightning before you hear the thunder.
- Quotes
Lance Poole: I envy you, ma'am., you being a lawyer.
Orrie Masters: Well, I...
Lance Poole: You got a faith, something to go by... like a religion. With you it's the law.
Orrie Masters: My father wanted me to study law. It means a great deal to me.
Lance Poole: Yes, it must. I've always wanted something like that. Something to tell me what's right or wrong.
Orrie Masters: I'm glad you feel the way you do.
Lance Poole: Because then you don't have to bother about your conscience. It's written out for you to follow... no matter what it does to people. It's the law. And changing the law is something you don't have to worry about.
Robert Taylor is superb as Lance Poole, a Shoshone Indian and returning decorated veteran of the Civil War. Louis Calhern, a very good actor, plays Coolan. Without any apparent personal reason, his dislike of Indians - the native Americans, is clearly a prejudice of hate that blinds reasoning and hardens the heart. Paula Raymond is very good as Orrie Masters, who herself has battled some prejudice and bias of the time and culture that doesn't expect a woman to be able to be a lawyer. Lance himself, has a tinge of such prejudice at first. Spring Byington as Orrie's mother, Edgar Buchanan as Zeke Carmody, and Tom Fadden as the saloon keeper, Bob Trammell, are symbols of many other people - probably a large majority of the human race. They are those who aren't prejudiced by nature, but are subject to the wiles and whims of the culture and time. There are some, of course, who are gullible and easily swayed to violence or destruction by lies, manipulation and subtle coercion.
With filming done around Grand Junction and Aspen, Colorado, the movie has some very good scenery that depicts the area around the Medicine Bow National Forest, from mountainous areas to the grassy valleys and stretches of high plains. But, there are some anomalies about locations and settings in this story and film. While it doesn't alter the plot overall, for some who study and enjoy history and know the U. S. geography quite well, these anomalies are a little puzzling.
The town of Medicine Bow is just north of the Medicine Bow national Forest, where Lance's land was likely located. But the Wind River Range that Zeke mentions having trapped in with Lance's father, starts 150 miles to the Northwest of Medicine Bow. And, when Lance herds his cattle to market, they go all the way to Bozeman, Montana. That would be more than 500 miles over some rough terrain, including mountains. And what would the cattle market be there? He could have gone 100 miles or less to Cheyenne or 180 miles to Denver over much easier terrain. Even Salt Lake City, at 350 miles would have been a much easier cattle drive. And there surely would have been bigger markets for cattle in those places. This is before the transcontinental railroad reached across this territory. Lance tells Zeke that he had seen the U. P. (Union Pacific Railroad) 75 miles East of Old Fr. Kearny. That would have been about 100 miles West of Omaha. So, there were no railroads to ship cattle out of Bozeman or any of the other places, but the bigger towns surely had more sizable markets for beef.
And, who knows what the Indian reservation is that the movie refers to. The Wind River Reservation would be established in 1868 by agreement with the U. S. government and the Eastern Shoshone Nation. It covers 2.2 million acres just about in the middle of Wyoming - more than 3,500 square miles of land and water that includes mountains, grass land and high desert country.
What this film shows is how one man or a few people with strong prejudices can spread their venom among some people. I noted that sheepmen were not riled up or anxious to try to take land from the Shoshone. Calhern's Coolan kept calmly steering them toward a battle. Even then, Rod MacDougall (played by Marshal Thompson) wanted to negotiate with Poole and talk to attorney Masters. Coolan had promoted the sheepmen coming to the area in the first place, obviously to cause a battle and/or drive the Shoshone away. And, but for needing water and grazing land for their sheep, these men had no animus against the Indians. But, with some help from his errant troublemaker, Ike Stapleton (played by James Millican), Coolan finally succeeds in rousing the sheepmen and some town people to confront the Indians.
The story has a poignant ending. Had the Indians been considered American citizens in the first three centuries of the settlement of North America, their plight would surely have been quite different. It wasn't until 1924 that Congress granted citizenship to all native Americans. And, that was spurred on by the high number of American Indians who enlisted in the Armed Forces during World War I. There's some interesting history about this film and it's being held back for release until after the 20th Century Fox film, "Broken Arrow" came out that year. "Devil's Doorway" is a different film and superior to that one in some ways, but has not enjoyed the recognition that the other film has had.
Still, this is a very good film about the plight of native Americans, and especially about prejudice and how good but uninformed and ignorant people can be manipulated and coerced into prejudice, and be led into biased and unjust behavior. It happens still in the 21st century where it can be so easily disguised under false notions of justice, liberty and freedom. Would that everyone become more vigilant so as to respect others and their differences, and not become bigots, hypocrites or promoters of prejudice.
- SimonJack
- Apr 1, 2022
- How long is Devil's Doorway?Powered by Alexa
Details
Box office
- Budget
- $1,373,000 (estimated)
- Runtime1 hour 24 minutes
- Color
- Aspect ratio
- 1.37 : 1