Harem Girl (1952) Poster

(1952)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Show Us Miss Davis Or Miss Castle!
boblipton19 June 2019
Joan Davis is the traveling companion to princess Peggy Castle, rightful heir to a Middle Eastern Kingdom. There are the usual intrigues, and lots of good guys and bad guys who want to marry Miss Castle, but properly, that's only a sideshow to Joan's clowning. Unfortunately, it's in the hands of Edward Bernds, who learned everything about clowning from the Three Stooges, which in my book is almost nothing. Also, he doesn't bother to match shots and even the sound editing is inconsistent -- and Bernds spent fifteen years as a sound mixer and editor at Columbia.

Fortunately, Miss Davis' physical clowning and her puzzled delivery of her comic lines is excellent. Nevertheless, the movie is a disappointment, and would be her last appearance on the big screen. No worries! She would settle onto the small screen for I MARRIED JOAN, which made much better use of her talents than this mishmosh.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Joan Davis takes over where Maria Montez left off.
mark.waltz3 August 2015
Warning: Spoilers
With Martin and Lewis, Abbott and Costello and the Three Stooges keeping juvenile audiences entertained with their sometimes insipid plot lines that adults either accepted for what they were or groaned at, veteran comic Joan Davis joined that group as a bored American who longs for adventure and heads to the North African coast where she finds romance, excitement, and an Arabic culture that disappeared long before this took place. She is traveling with pretty Peggy Castle whom she has no idea is actually an Arabian princess, and finds more excitement when she is confused with the beautiful young lady and placed inside the current ruler's harem.

Repeats of gags we already saw in "Road to Morocco" and "Abbott and Costello in the Foreign Legion" are moderately funny if you see this film before you do those, but like her T.V. show, Joan is sometimes overly forced. Her earlier films were amusing programmers, but by this time, the old gags were getting tired. A few good lines here and there do not make a classic comedy, and the stereotypical view of Islamic customs and lifestyles just seems trite. Unlike other 50's funny ladies (Lucy, Eve), I can take maybe an hour of Joan's schtick, so this is the perfect length. There's some good slapstick, but unfortunately, this doesn't hold up as well as other farces with comics I mention above. Veteran comic character actress Minerva Urecal has a funny bit as the head mistress of the Harem (think Marjorie Main in a toga), and Joan is certainly likable. It's just too bad that the scripts she took seemed just so rushed so ultimately they end up mediocre and quickly forgettable.
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Joan goes wild
tday-17 March 2005
Funny flick of Joan Davis going to the middle east with exotic princess and then subbing for her in marriage deal with unpleasant sheik. Lots of horseplay and comedy scenes. Joan is quite a comedienne and makes the most of her story. Peggy Castle makes a lovely princess,the rest of the B-cast does well. It has a nice set design from Columbia Pictures. The writers and director were three stooges veterans so the comedy is a sure thing. I especially liked hilarious scene where Joan tries to be dancing girl and end up making a mess as usual. The other funny scene involves Joan in a deserted tomb with rumors of a ghostly presence. I would highly recommend this film and wish more of these type of films made it to DVD.
17 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
I Love Lucy in Arabia!
debo-mills28 July 2008
I had taped this movie off of TCM, and was really enjoying it when my tape ran out halfway through! But the part that I saw was very funny, thanks to the actress playing Susie, who I'd never seen before. I started watching assuming this was going to be a typical corny 1950s Arabian adventure movie, but when Susie started cracking wise with her man-hungry and self-depreciating comments it was a delightful surprise! It was like an episode of "I Love Lucy" in Arabia, as Susie was chased by the villains, danced hilariously with the harem girls, and hid in giant vases and under beds, while helping the princess and her loyal supporters reclaim the throne.

I hope I'll be able to see the entire movie sometime, and others by this hilarious actress!
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed