Three Dark Horses (1952) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Three Dopey Delegates
ccthemovieman-127 May 2007
We're at the campaign headquarters for "Hammond Egger," who is running for President. Immediately we see two crooked guys - actors who were regular villains on the Adventures Of Superman TV series (Kenneth MacDonald and Ben Weldon). They are the campaign manager "Bill Wick" and his sidekick "Jim Digger." They are scheming to "make that oil grab" and need Egger to be elected. They know three of their delegates "are smelling a rat....and what we need are three (new) delegates who are too dumb to think and who'll do what we tell 'em."

Any guess who they will find? The answer comes quick as the Stooges, janitors in the place, quickly demonstrate how stupid they are in front of Wick and Digger. "If they are half as dumb as they look, I think we've found our men," says Wick.

The Stooges are so inept they make Weldon look smart in comparison. He always played the dumbest crook on Superman. Here, "Jim" gets his toupee "scalped" when Shemp's vacuum cleaner sucks it off his head. They give it back to him with all the dust and other crud from the vacuum bag and then put glue on his head! It's brutal, but it's a funny scene.

Anyway, the boys are offered money to be delegates at the convention and they accept. They then do a two-minute skit, or parody, of conventioneers which, frankly, was stupid.

The rest of it is the boys back in their hotel room later than night, and the goofy things they do to each other while eating, drinking coffee and soaking their tired feet in a tub of hot water. Poor Shemp's "dogs" are barking, and this is the only time I've ever seen that expression put to literal use on screen! It's funny. So are a few clever remarks such as "Hey, won't Wick burn when he......"

The rest of it is so-so, with a strange ending in which the guys look like murderers!
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Funny can be done with no budget.
maxcellus4610 December 2005
Irony. Sometimes the funniest things are done with minimal resources as in this short. No great staging or special effects, five people in the whole cast including the Stooges themselves, and yet it's not too bad at all. Seems though like it could have been part of something bigger. The sequencing of the first scene on to the second is perfect and so you wish for more but, "That's all there is, there isn't any more." (Quote from L&H'S Sons of the Desert 1933) And that's a pity. Columbia had literally gold in their hands and just would always let it slip through their money grubbing fingers. Irony again. Big shots like Harry Cohn and Louis B. Mayer had all the great comedy talent at their disposal yet in all truth neither guy reportedly had a decent sense of humor. This short is not just some more pokes and gouges by the boys but an actual satire of politics at the time...or any time really, from ancient Rome to now with Clinton, Gore, and Bush. "Hmm! Three guys. That's a coincidence!" Names like Hammond Egger and Able Lamb Stewer, it's too much. Watch this one by all means and laugh at the body politic.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
get on the bandwagon for Stewer
simeon_flake11 December 2004
An amazing little short film, with very little in the way of scenery or sound stages that this was shot on, but to quote Curly "I don't care". The first half is classic stooge mayhem. You know what's coming as soon as Bill Wick utters "What we need are three guys who are too dumb to think and will do what we tell them. Now where will we find such guys". Enter Moe, Larry, Shemp.

The second half of this film is relatively quiet compared to the mayhem caused in Wick's office, yet the film doesn't miss a beat. Love the way Larry overloads his coffee with sugar then pawns it off on Shemp, who adds a few more drops to make it just right. Moe's nomination speech (when our national economy is at stake, and "steak" is 3 dollars a pound), his hilarious exchange with Larry as they clean up confetti, the bird in the turkey, and a nice clobbering of the crooks at the end add up to another grade A comedy.

10/10
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
"How stupid can three guys be?"
angus_dei27 December 2005
So asks Ben Weldon, in the days before he met Superman. Ben's the guy with carpet dirt smeared all over his face and with his toupee, saturated with glue, stuck on top of his head. And the Stooges are stupid? The great Kenneth MacDonald, as "Slick" Bill Wick, lets out a chuckle: he's found his pigeons. But not so fast! The Stooges get wise to Hammond Egger's crooked ways and switch allegiance to Able Lamb Stewer, a byproduct of early cloning experiments carried out with Dolly the Sheep's ancestors (and Stewer's likeness on his campaign posters will bear me out on this). Anyway, Slick Bill is not amused, and extreme violence and mayhem ensues. That's the plot, but as in all Stooges shorts, it's tertiary, not even secondary. The first reel is classic Stooges: they're janitors, and therefore allegoric to the proletariat masses, who, as irony would have it, get screwed by the very politicians they vote into office. But Slick Bill, the campaign manager, needs mindless yes-men to vote as they are told at the upcoming convention. Now, I've already described what happens to Ben Weldon, Slick's assistant. This alone should serve as a warning: do not underestimate the Stooges. Anyway, the second reel of the short starts out in sheer surrealism. The Stooges wreak havoc unto themselves in what can only be described as a political convention of three. I'll just say here that Shemp forever won my heart with his very short "two-hour week" speech, superlative even to Moe's brilliant paean to political bombast. I'll also say that the treatment endured by Slick Bill and Ben Weldon in the Stooges' bathtub is not for the faint of heart. Remember the effect "Psycho" had on shower-takers? Well, I've never again taken a bath since first seeing "Three Dark Horses"! But if you're smart, or politically inclined (mutually exclusive events), this short film is a must-see.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
You can't believe all that stuff, that's a campaign promise!
GrigoryGirl26 December 2022
This is one of the funniest and incisive Stooge shorts. The Stooges weren't known for their satiric takes on politics, but this film brilliantly and hilariously skewers politics and their lies. Moe's "convention" speech, written and performed over 70 years ago, could easily be filmed today without changing a word. Moe promises a 2 hour work week (HAHA), and Shemp says that's for him. Moe responds..."you can't believe all that stuff, that's a campaign promise!".

Many Stooge shorts skewered politics from time to time, like their most famous political short, You Natzy Spy. This one isn't as great as that one, but it's pretty darn good anyway.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Good Three Stooges short!
Movie Nuttball13 October 2004
The Three Stooges has always been some of the many actors that I have loved. I love just about every one of the shorts that they have made. I love all six of the Stooges (Curly, Shemp, Moe, Larry, Joe, and Curly Joe)! All of the shorts are hilarious and also star many other great actors and actresses which a lot of them was in many of the shorts! In My opinion The Three Stooges is some of the greatest actors ever and is the all time funniest comedy team!

This is a hilarious Three Stooges short with Shemp! Kenneth MacDonald and Ben Welden are in this one with Shemp and are very good. There are many funny things here and if you are a Three Stooges fan then I recommend this one!
3 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
"A Chicken in Every Pot with Egger"
slymusic29 October 2007
Warning: Spoilers
"Three Dark Horses" is a very good Shemp-Larry-Moe Three Stooges short directed by Jules White. The boys are three stupid janitors who are hired by crooked campaign manager Bill Wick (Kenneth MacDonald) and his assistant Jim (Ben Welden) to become their manipulated delegates for presidential candidate Hammond Egger. The boys are overly enthusiastic about their new assignment, but once they find out that Egger is a crook, they switch their vote in favor of the other candidate, Abel Lamb Stewer.

Highlights from "Three Dark Horses" include the following. Amidst all the hijinks the janitorial Stooges cause in Wick's office (and some of the slapstick is quite excessive), what really drives it home is when the Stooges' vacuum sucks up Jim's toupee; equally funny are the boys' attempts to pacify Jim and make his dirty toupee look like new. Larry adds a lot of sugar to his coffee, but he finds it way too sweet and offers it to Shemp, who adds a lot more sugar! A parrot winds up inside the Stooges' cooked turkey (a gag the boys used in a few earlier shorts as well), laughing when Shemp rubs its breast and sneezing when Moe adds black pepper; it then stands up and walks away, but not before Shemp unsuccessfully tries to clobber it.

In addition to the wonderfully sinister Kenneth MacDonald, who is a familiar heavy in various Stooge flicks with Shemp as the third Stooge, there is one other supporting actor in "Three Dark Horses" who bears mentioning: William "Bud" Jamison. Jamison's portrait appears on the Hammond Egger posters at the beginning of this short. He was a familiar supporting actor during the first decade of Stooge shorts featuring Curly as the third Stooge, but he unfortunately didn't live long enough to perform in any Stooge shorts featuring Shemp.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed