It is loaded to the gunwales with screamingly funny scenes which, in several instances, are visual improvements on the play.
83
The A.V. ClubGwen Ihnat
The A.V. ClubGwen Ihnat
With no battles and a setting that primarily stays on the U.S.S. Reluctant, Mister Roberts still captivates, aided by some shimmering dialogue already polished to perfection by the Broadway version, along with the renegade hijinks of the crew.
80
Chicago Reader
Chicago Reader
The film is still hilarious, though time has dimmed the luster of Lemmon's hamming in favor of James Cagney's superbly psychotic commanding officer.
80
Film ThreatBrad Laidman
Film ThreatBrad Laidman
Mister Roberts is a movie dedicated to anyone with a boring dead end job who wants to be a hero and has to decide whether to live honorably anyway.
80
Village Voice
Village Voice
One of the better farce-comedies. [26 Oct 1955, p.6]
80
Los Angeles Times
Los Angeles Times
A brilliant mixture of laughter and pathos with delightful performances from Fonda, James Cagney, William Powell (in his last role) and Jack Lemmon, who received an Oscar as the enterprising Ensign Pulver. [24 Dec 1998, p.F12]
70
Time Out
Time Out
The fact that the picture is seamlessly anonymous testifies to the power of star performances rather than to any directorial engagement. The acting is the only reason to watch it.
James Cagney is simply great as the captain of the ship. William Powell tackles the role of ship’s doctor with an easy assurance that makes it stand out and Jack Lemmon is a big hit as Ensign Pulver.
50
TV Guide Magazine
TV Guide Magazine
This stodgy film version of the famous Broadway success was one performance too many.
40
The New YorkerPauline Kael
The New YorkerPauline Kael
It's a miserable piece of moviemaking -- poorly paced and tearjerking.