La finestra sul Luna Park (1957) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
A boy chooses a father. A father chooses a son.
ItalianGerry29 April 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Although this movie is not as well known as most of Luigi Comencini's other films, I believe it to be one of his best. It deals with the love of a young boy, Mario, for his surrogate father, Righetto, who along with the boy's mother Ada, takes care of the child while the husband Aldo is separated from his wife and son as he works in Africa for long stretches of time and barely ever sees his family.

After the mother dies in a street accident, Aldo returns to Rome where his family lives, but only with the intention of putting the boy in an orphanage so that he can return to his job. Mario is indifferent to this father that he barely knows, but is deeply devoted to the affectionate and caring Righetto. Righetto works at odd jobs and has not had much in the way of financial stability, and yet the boy wants to become like him when he grows up. He does poorly in school.

A rivalry develops between real father and de-facto father Righetto. The boy runs away to be with Righetto, until the father retrieves him. Righetto is a kind and meek man and very patient with the boy but also honest is confronting the boy's father about his relationship in the past with Ada when Aldo hints they were lovers. Always the gentleman, in fact nearly a saint, Righetto reassures the man that nothing had ever taken place, except his genuine affection for the boy.

Righetto urges the father to remain, fulfill his parental duties, get to know his son, and not abandon him. By the end of the film, in a reversal, it is Righetto who goes off to work on a farm, and it is Aldo who, at Righetto's urging, will remain. Righetto has a last meeting with the boy at the nearby amusement park of the film's title and urges the lad to walk toward his dad, which he does. In the last few moments of the movie we see the father carrying the boy on his back to a carnival ride, which they will go on together, though he claims "fear" and though the boy doubts it. It is the birth of a new relationship, a boy with his true father, finally capable of the love he needs to give his son. And it is heartfelt and really a moving episode.

The movie is beautifully acted by Gastone Renzelli as Aldo, a magnificent Pierre Trabaud as Righetto, Giulia Rubini as Ada (mostly in flashbacks)and wonderful trouper Giancarlo Damiani as the sensitive eight-year-old Mario. Luigi Comencini has given us many films dealing with the lives of children. Some of the ones that come to mind are his "Proibito rubare," "Voltati Eugenio," "Cuore," "Incompreso," "Un ragazzo di Calabria," even "Pinocchio." My own personal favorite is this one, "The Window Overlooking Luna Park."
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Suffer the little children.
dbdumonteil17 December 2019
Only one review for this Comencini gem,but fortunately ,one which does the great director justice. With the exception of a documentary ("Bambini in Citta") It was the first time Luigi Comencini had tackled childhood (and it would not be the last):"Incompreso" was very moving and unforgettable;"Pinocchio" was very different from Disney's cartoon;later in the eighties he would transfer to the screen,with great talent,De Amicis's "Cuore",then redo "Marcellino pan y vino".Comencini is THE poet of childhood ,whose reputation is at least as great in France as in his native Italy.Here all the movies I mention above plus "lo Scopone Scientifico" and his "Casanova" are considered art house cinema .

And the stand out in this wonderful movie is French !Pierre Trabaud was never given in his native country the parts he deserved:he had to be content with Leo Joannon's religious extravaganzas in which appalling screenplays turned him into a saint.

In "La finestra" ,Trabaud is really a saint;directed by a first-class artist ,his hangdog looks work wonders; in the deeply moving flashback -which comes at the end of the movie, which is very rare - Comencini shows -what we already knew- that Righetto gave it all and kept nothing for himself ;the scenes with Alda and her son show what a true father should be (the clown makes no mistake):an uneducated man,he goes as far as to study again to help his protégé whose school report was bad; when he unbuckles his belt ,we already know that he will not beat him; corporal punishment is unthinkable :Righetto is Comencini 's voice.And Righetto will be mistreated,beaten ,falsely accused of being adulterous .

How could Mario be good at school when his dad is always away? The mother thinks that he needs a father's hard way ;the father thinks that a boarding-school is the solution ; but children from wealthy families ("incompreso", where the father , a consul,leaves his children to a governess, or Eugenio ("Voltati Eugenio ") whose bourgeois parents sent him to his grandparents' care in the country suffer as much as Mario, a boy from the working class.

A working class which is not shown in a flattering light: under the pretext of taking in the brat,they want to get the father's big house .And the pair of lovers are not better.

Only Righetto ,a simple man ,asks for nothing in return ; alone in a word of selfish adults (a subject Comencini would often treat),he shows the straight and narrow.And thanks to him ,the window on Luna Park is wide open and the amusement ride restores faith in humanity.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed