Given the basically no-star cast and the fact that it came from Universal-International, it's understandable that you might think this would be just another run-of-the-mill "B" oater--and you'd be dead wrong. This first-rate western has several things going for it. The breathtaking Oregon locations have been beautifully captured by Harold Lipstein's expert Technicolor cinematography. The colors are lush, and the photography is so atmospheric you can almost feel the chill in your bones as the troops slog through the rugged mountain country. There are several rousingly staged and exciting action scenes, notably a somewhat lengthy sequence in which a wagon train loaded with troops cuts its way through a mass of charging Indians. The performances by a cast of veteran character actors--Lee Marvin in an early role (although his Irish brogue is a bit much), Keith Andes, Charles Horvath, Alberto Morin and Willis Bouchey, among others--are top-notch, Dorothy Malone is beautiful, Jeff Chandler gives a more authoritative (and animated) performance than he usually did and Ward Bond does an outstanding job as a caring and concerned missionary who doesn't want to see bloodshed on either side. The main thing the film has going for it, though, is the subject matter. Rather than having the usual Apaches or Comanches rampaging through the Southwest, the film is set in the Oregon mountain country, and the Indians are not superstitious savages but have been converted to Christianity by missionary Bond, and many in their religious zeal have given up their "animal" names and taken the names of Biblical figures (to further drive the point home, one soldier complains to Bond that, since he has "Christianized" the Indians, they have no qualms about attacking at night; "uncivilized" Indians never attacked at night for fear that if they were killed, their spirits would roam in the dark forever and never find peace). As far as I know, this particular facet of the Indian wars had never been tackled before or, for that matter, since. The story consistently holds your interest (although the triangle between Chandler, Malone and Andes tends to slow things down somewhat), the action scenes are terrific, the photography, as noted, is superb. A very worthy effort from veteran director George Marshall. Well worth your time.
19 Reviews
The pillars of the sky Doc, they were sacred to the tribes long before you came with the word of God.
hitchcockthelegend10 September 2011
Pillars of the Sky (AKA: The Tomahawk and the Cross) is directed by George Marshall and adapted to screenplay by Sam Rolfe from the novels "Frontier Fury" & "To Follow a Flag" written by Will Henry. It stars Jeff Chandler, Ward Bond, Dorothy Malone, Keith Andes and Lee Marvin. A Technicolor/CinemaScope production, photography is by Harold Lipstein and music is by Joseph Gershenson.
Oregon County 1868, and the Native Indian tribes have been shunted on to government sanctioned reservations. As the U.S. troops arrive to lay the roads through Indian territory for new settlers, the Indian chiefs decide to fight back. Led by Chief Kamiakin (Michael Ansara), the Indians attack leaving the army short on numbers, all that's left is a small band of soldiers and some civilians. Can they survive on guts and religious comfort alone?
It was originally intended to be made with John Ford directing and John Wayne starring, but come 1956 the pair were unable to commit to the production. They had another Western to make that year, The Searchers! Plot is familiar for Pillars of the Sky, but the even handed portrayal of the Indians and a pro-Christian bent in the narrative, lifts it out of the ordinary. Picture is further boosted by some excellent action sequences that are skilfully crafted by director Marshall (Destry Rides Again/How the West Was Won). Indian attacks, via horseback or flaming arrows assault, considerably raise the pulse, while the sight of the army desperately trying to conquer the rocky terrain while under attack is a bona fide piece of Oater grit. With the exteriors actually filmed on location in Oregon at Joseph & La Grande, the backdrop is gorgeous, expertly brought to life in Technicolor "Scope" by Lipstein (No Name on the Bullet/Von Ryan's Express). While Gershenson (Horizons West/The Man from the Alamo) scores it with genre compliant riffs on Cavalry marches and Indian flavouring.
That it isn't better known or thought of higher comes down to a so so set of acting performances and a pointless love triangle that pads the picture out with boorish periods of chat. Malone, looking beautiful as per usual in colour, is basically a token character, who serves only to be a romantic interest that causes friction between Chandler and Andes. In fact her dialogue is minimal. Marvin has only a small role, and he offers up a quite poor Irish accent as well, while Andes fails to convince. Chandler does cut a decent rugged figure, portraying First Sergeant Emmett Bell as a man you would fight alongside, but it's a performance that lacks charisma, something that Duke Wayne no doubt would have brought to the role. It's left to Bond to take the acting honours, where in an unusually restrained role for him as strongly Christian Dr. Joseph Holden, he gives good value for money as he plays it out with stoic nobility.
With a great DVD transfer and the correct aspect ratio used, the film looks absolutely terrific. It has flaws for sure, but it comes easily recommended to the Western fan. 7/10
Oregon County 1868, and the Native Indian tribes have been shunted on to government sanctioned reservations. As the U.S. troops arrive to lay the roads through Indian territory for new settlers, the Indian chiefs decide to fight back. Led by Chief Kamiakin (Michael Ansara), the Indians attack leaving the army short on numbers, all that's left is a small band of soldiers and some civilians. Can they survive on guts and religious comfort alone?
It was originally intended to be made with John Ford directing and John Wayne starring, but come 1956 the pair were unable to commit to the production. They had another Western to make that year, The Searchers! Plot is familiar for Pillars of the Sky, but the even handed portrayal of the Indians and a pro-Christian bent in the narrative, lifts it out of the ordinary. Picture is further boosted by some excellent action sequences that are skilfully crafted by director Marshall (Destry Rides Again/How the West Was Won). Indian attacks, via horseback or flaming arrows assault, considerably raise the pulse, while the sight of the army desperately trying to conquer the rocky terrain while under attack is a bona fide piece of Oater grit. With the exteriors actually filmed on location in Oregon at Joseph & La Grande, the backdrop is gorgeous, expertly brought to life in Technicolor "Scope" by Lipstein (No Name on the Bullet/Von Ryan's Express). While Gershenson (Horizons West/The Man from the Alamo) scores it with genre compliant riffs on Cavalry marches and Indian flavouring.
That it isn't better known or thought of higher comes down to a so so set of acting performances and a pointless love triangle that pads the picture out with boorish periods of chat. Malone, looking beautiful as per usual in colour, is basically a token character, who serves only to be a romantic interest that causes friction between Chandler and Andes. In fact her dialogue is minimal. Marvin has only a small role, and he offers up a quite poor Irish accent as well, while Andes fails to convince. Chandler does cut a decent rugged figure, portraying First Sergeant Emmett Bell as a man you would fight alongside, but it's a performance that lacks charisma, something that Duke Wayne no doubt would have brought to the role. It's left to Bond to take the acting honours, where in an unusually restrained role for him as strongly Christian Dr. Joseph Holden, he gives good value for money as he plays it out with stoic nobility.
With a great DVD transfer and the correct aspect ratio used, the film looks absolutely terrific. It has flaws for sure, but it comes easily recommended to the Western fan. 7/10
"He Gave You His God"
bkoganbing20 August 2006
Pillars of the Sky is an unusual western in that it touches on the role of Christian missionaries in the American West. This film also gives Ward Bond one of the most unusual roles he ever had in his career.
Bond plays a Christian missionary preacher/doctor in the Pacific Northwest region. There is still considerable debate among historians as to what they accomplished. It was thought at the time that the conquered Indian tribes would be more humanely treated under preachers than soldiers. There is no doubt that missionaries, not only in the American west, but in other parts of the world colonized by the west, probably saved indigent peoples from some acts of barbarism.
Whether though, even with the best of intentions, they had the right to destroy a culture is very much open to debate. And Bond is a man with the best of intentions even as he baptizes the Indians giving them names found in the Bible.
One Indian who isn't having any of it is Michael Ansara who's rousing all the tribes to resist the building of a new army post in their territory. But Colonel Willis Bouchey has his orders and Bond is caught in the middle.
Another trio caught in the middle is Captain Keith Andes, his wife Dorothy Malone, and Sergeant Jeff Chandler who Malone was previously engaged to. Malone and Olive Carey are captured by Ansara's bunch and Chandler rescues them. This little romantic subplot is exactly what the cavalry doesn't need as Ansara's band is on the hunt for them.
Pillars of the Sky was filmed on location in the Pacific Northwest and the photography is first rate. And the Indian attacks are well staged by some very smart Indians. Ansara is a cunning and ruthless foe.
It also succeeds in making you admire the courage of our cavalry in carrying out their orders though in fact they are in clear treaty violation. One of the best roles in the film is that of Lee Marvin, an army veteran from the Civil War who is giving the green troops some lessons for survival in a hurry.
I did find it a bit much the end Jeff Chandler has in store for him and I think most viewers will also. As Chandler said, Bond may have given the Indians the priceless gift of his God, but was the cost worth it?
Bond plays a Christian missionary preacher/doctor in the Pacific Northwest region. There is still considerable debate among historians as to what they accomplished. It was thought at the time that the conquered Indian tribes would be more humanely treated under preachers than soldiers. There is no doubt that missionaries, not only in the American west, but in other parts of the world colonized by the west, probably saved indigent peoples from some acts of barbarism.
Whether though, even with the best of intentions, they had the right to destroy a culture is very much open to debate. And Bond is a man with the best of intentions even as he baptizes the Indians giving them names found in the Bible.
One Indian who isn't having any of it is Michael Ansara who's rousing all the tribes to resist the building of a new army post in their territory. But Colonel Willis Bouchey has his orders and Bond is caught in the middle.
Another trio caught in the middle is Captain Keith Andes, his wife Dorothy Malone, and Sergeant Jeff Chandler who Malone was previously engaged to. Malone and Olive Carey are captured by Ansara's bunch and Chandler rescues them. This little romantic subplot is exactly what the cavalry doesn't need as Ansara's band is on the hunt for them.
Pillars of the Sky was filmed on location in the Pacific Northwest and the photography is first rate. And the Indian attacks are well staged by some very smart Indians. Ansara is a cunning and ruthless foe.
It also succeeds in making you admire the courage of our cavalry in carrying out their orders though in fact they are in clear treaty violation. One of the best roles in the film is that of Lee Marvin, an army veteran from the Civil War who is giving the green troops some lessons for survival in a hurry.
I did find it a bit much the end Jeff Chandler has in store for him and I think most viewers will also. As Chandler said, Bond may have given the Indians the priceless gift of his God, but was the cost worth it?
Pretty good western chronicles a strong fight between the Indian tribes and the US cavalry in Oregon territory
ma-cortes23 March 2017
This is the story of Sgt. Emmet Bell (Jeff Chandler) who found his weakness in the arms of another man's woman (Dorothy Malone) and his strength in the power of another man's God . In Oregon Country , 1868 , numerous tribes of Native Americans with Biblic and Evangelist names have been placed on a reservation north of the Snake River . Here a priest called Holden (War Bond) , has constructed a church , and many of the tribes have accepted Christianity and Christian names such as Samuel , Aaron , Abraham , Jacob ; in fact , the three Indian chiefs hold Christian names : Elias , Isaias and Zacarias . But the White Men are building a bridge that across the river to Indian territory to areas north . When the cavalry, under the command of Col. Stedlow (Willis Bouchey) and Capt. Tom Gaxton (Keith Andes) arrive they intend to make peace but the tribal chiefs feel their treaty has been violated . As the cavalry column advances into the reservation , Kamiakin (Michael Ansara) carries out razzias against the US Cavalry and settlements .
A-Universal-International-Picture gets Western action , shootouts , a triangular love story , breathtaking Indian raids on Yankees regiments and results to be quite entertaining . This moving movie is an epic portrait of the thrilling story about several tribal chiefs decide to unite their forces against the trespassing whites who open a road across the reservation and are building a bridge crossing their lands . It's a medium budget film with good actors , technicians , production values and pleasing results . At the ending , when takes place the Indian assault , possesses all the sweep , grandeur and noisy action of the greatest Westerns of an age long past . The picture contains spectacular charges of Indian riders , including an overwhelming final when the US soldiers are besieged at a church turned into a strongly defended fort . Nice acting from a great cast . As Jeff Chandler is good as a honorable and Cristian Sergeant who is in charge of maintaining order and attempts to keep the peace between US cavalry and Indians . Chandler gives stature to the role , providing sincerity and bravura . Chandler was famous , until his early death , for playing Indian chief Cochise , a dignified portrait well shown in : ¨Broken arrow¨ , ¨Battle of Apache Pass¨ and ¨Taza , son of Cochise¨ . Although Chandler also played all kinds of genres , such as : ¨Return to Peyton Place¨(drama) , ¨Flame of Araby¨ (adventure) , ¨Merrill's marauders¨ (wartime , in his last film) , until his early death at 42-year-old . Dorothy Malone as gorgeous and pleasant wife , proves to be a great actress , as usual . And support cast is frankly excellent , such as : Ward Bond , Keith Andes , Lee Marvin , Sydney Chaplin, Olive Carey and special mention for the veteran Willis Bouchey as well as Michael Ansara as violent Indian chief vowing to lead the tribes in battle against the encroaching white men . This exciting and stirring Western was beautifully photographed in Cinemascope , print in Technicolor by Harold Lipstein , Universal's ordinary cameraman. And an original and shining score from William Lava and Heinz Roemheld , though uncredited .
This motion picture was professionally directed by George Marshall in colorful style , though has a few flaws . He realized a great number of films , especially Westerns . His first Western was ¨Wild Gold¨(1934) and he subsequently directed ¨Destry rides again¨ with James Stewart and Marlene Dietrich in which years later he would make a remake titled ¨Frenchie¨ with Audie Murphy and Marie Blanchard . As George Marshal introduces hilarious elements and amusement in his Westerns , such as ¨Texas¨ , ¨Fancy pants¨, ¨Advance to the rear¨, and also directs Musical Westerns as ¨Red Garters¨ and ¨The second greatest sex¨ . Being particularly known for his co-direction of the epic Western ¨How the west was won¨ along with Henry Hathaway and John Ford .
A-Universal-International-Picture gets Western action , shootouts , a triangular love story , breathtaking Indian raids on Yankees regiments and results to be quite entertaining . This moving movie is an epic portrait of the thrilling story about several tribal chiefs decide to unite their forces against the trespassing whites who open a road across the reservation and are building a bridge crossing their lands . It's a medium budget film with good actors , technicians , production values and pleasing results . At the ending , when takes place the Indian assault , possesses all the sweep , grandeur and noisy action of the greatest Westerns of an age long past . The picture contains spectacular charges of Indian riders , including an overwhelming final when the US soldiers are besieged at a church turned into a strongly defended fort . Nice acting from a great cast . As Jeff Chandler is good as a honorable and Cristian Sergeant who is in charge of maintaining order and attempts to keep the peace between US cavalry and Indians . Chandler gives stature to the role , providing sincerity and bravura . Chandler was famous , until his early death , for playing Indian chief Cochise , a dignified portrait well shown in : ¨Broken arrow¨ , ¨Battle of Apache Pass¨ and ¨Taza , son of Cochise¨ . Although Chandler also played all kinds of genres , such as : ¨Return to Peyton Place¨(drama) , ¨Flame of Araby¨ (adventure) , ¨Merrill's marauders¨ (wartime , in his last film) , until his early death at 42-year-old . Dorothy Malone as gorgeous and pleasant wife , proves to be a great actress , as usual . And support cast is frankly excellent , such as : Ward Bond , Keith Andes , Lee Marvin , Sydney Chaplin, Olive Carey and special mention for the veteran Willis Bouchey as well as Michael Ansara as violent Indian chief vowing to lead the tribes in battle against the encroaching white men . This exciting and stirring Western was beautifully photographed in Cinemascope , print in Technicolor by Harold Lipstein , Universal's ordinary cameraman. And an original and shining score from William Lava and Heinz Roemheld , though uncredited .
This motion picture was professionally directed by George Marshall in colorful style , though has a few flaws . He realized a great number of films , especially Westerns . His first Western was ¨Wild Gold¨(1934) and he subsequently directed ¨Destry rides again¨ with James Stewart and Marlene Dietrich in which years later he would make a remake titled ¨Frenchie¨ with Audie Murphy and Marie Blanchard . As George Marshal introduces hilarious elements and amusement in his Westerns , such as ¨Texas¨ , ¨Fancy pants¨, ¨Advance to the rear¨, and also directs Musical Westerns as ¨Red Garters¨ and ¨The second greatest sex¨ . Being particularly known for his co-direction of the epic Western ¨How the west was won¨ along with Henry Hathaway and John Ford .
Manitou's revenge
dbdumonteil2 May 2011
That scene,when the good doctor courts danger ,when he comes towards an army of angry bloodthirsty Indians ,strongly reminds you of that scene in "the war of the worlds" (1953) when Uncle Matthews ,the minister ,faces up to the Martians ,a Bible and a cross in his hands .But those Indians were supposed to be Christians whereas the ETs were not .Which would tend to show that religion does necessarily calm people down !Jeff Chandler is efficient as sergeant Bell but the love affair is totally bland and Dorothy Malone is totally wasted (hardly 10 lines to say in the whole movie)-she would win an AA for her next movie the famous "written on the wind" melodrama -.Some (Indian only) sadism in certain scenes.
Solid western, that is all
bellino-angelo20144 July 2022
I am not a huge fan of westerns but from time to time I don't mind watching some on TV. The problem is that most of the time the plots are all very similar... originality is not a trademark of the genre. Yet PILLARS OF THE SKY was a bit different. Let's see why.
In 1868 Oregon various Indian tribes are confined in a reserve built by Doctor Holden (Ward Bond) and Sergeant Emmet Bell (Jeff Chandler) has to make sure that there is always peace. However, some transfert of US Army Weapons makes chief Kamiakin (Michael Ansara) very suspicious and they attack the Army. Unfortunately appeals for a truce don't work, and after Kamiakin is killed by one of his own the other chiefs and Bell will do whatever is necessary for keeping the peace.
The acting was very good for a Western. Jeff Chandler was very good and believable as an Army Sergeant that is very concerned about keeping the peace between the Army and the Indians. Dorothy Malone gives a great performance other than still looking gorgeous, and the cast is chock full of many familiar faces of those years: Martin Milner, Lee Marvin, Willis Bouchey, Philip Carey and a scene-stealing Michael Ansara are all pretty entertaining. The Oregon scenery was great and makes you want to go on vacation there, and the soundtrack fit the movie's spirit very well.
If you are a die hard western fan don't miss it if you haven't seen it, but for those who watch them from time to time it's solid and entertaining... what more you can ask?
In 1868 Oregon various Indian tribes are confined in a reserve built by Doctor Holden (Ward Bond) and Sergeant Emmet Bell (Jeff Chandler) has to make sure that there is always peace. However, some transfert of US Army Weapons makes chief Kamiakin (Michael Ansara) very suspicious and they attack the Army. Unfortunately appeals for a truce don't work, and after Kamiakin is killed by one of his own the other chiefs and Bell will do whatever is necessary for keeping the peace.
The acting was very good for a Western. Jeff Chandler was very good and believable as an Army Sergeant that is very concerned about keeping the peace between the Army and the Indians. Dorothy Malone gives a great performance other than still looking gorgeous, and the cast is chock full of many familiar faces of those years: Martin Milner, Lee Marvin, Willis Bouchey, Philip Carey and a scene-stealing Michael Ansara are all pretty entertaining. The Oregon scenery was great and makes you want to go on vacation there, and the soundtrack fit the movie's spirit very well.
If you are a die hard western fan don't miss it if you haven't seen it, but for those who watch them from time to time it's solid and entertaining... what more you can ask?
Gripping Cavalry Western!
bsmith555223 August 2019
Warning: Spoilers
"Pillars of the Sky" is an entertaining cavalry vs. the Indians western. First Sgt. Emmett Bell (Jeff Chandler) is in charge of a group of Indian Scouts who provide policing at a settlement run by Dr. Joseph Holden (Ward Bond), a missionary who has been converting the local tribes to Christianity. One day Col. Stedlow (Willis Bouchey) arrives with columns of raw rookies. His orders are to build a road through Indian lands and erect a fort along the way.
The Indians see this as a violation of their treaty with the white man. One of their chiefs, Kamiakin (Michael Ansara) is prepared to go to war over the matter. Gradually he convinces the other chiefs to join him. Bell meanwhile, has rescued two white women from the Indian camp. One is Calla Gaxton (Dorothy Malone) who is married to Captain Tom Gaxton (Keith Andes). Calla and Bell have a past and she has come west to join him. The other woman is Mrs. Avery (Olive Carey) whose prospector husband was killed by the Indians.
As the column proceeds through Indian lands, Kamiakin leads attacks on the troopers. Multiple casualties occur on both sides but the tide is turning in favor of the Indians. Holden sneaks away to talk to the Chiefs but is shot by Kamiakin. And then...........................................................................................
There are several familiar faces playing various roles in the story. First there are whiskey swilling Sergeants Carracart (Lee Marvin) and Dutch Williams (Charles Horvath), Chief Indian Scout Timothy (Sydney Chaplin in a surprisingly good performance), Kamiakin's son Malachi (Orlando Rodriguez) who remains with the settlement, Walter Coy as Major Donahue and Paul Smith Martin Milner and Robert Ellis as raw recruits. Richard Hale and Frank DeKova play two of the Indian Chiefs who have been converted to Christianity.
Jeff Chandler plays Bell as a tough hard drinking veteran who has the respect of the Indians. The love triangle between him, Malone and Andes is distracting. Bond is good as the preacher but I was impressed by the performance of Willis Bouchey as the commander in a type of role he seldom was given.
The ending after Bond's character has been brought to the little church is a little hokey given the character of Emmett Bell.
The Indians see this as a violation of their treaty with the white man. One of their chiefs, Kamiakin (Michael Ansara) is prepared to go to war over the matter. Gradually he convinces the other chiefs to join him. Bell meanwhile, has rescued two white women from the Indian camp. One is Calla Gaxton (Dorothy Malone) who is married to Captain Tom Gaxton (Keith Andes). Calla and Bell have a past and she has come west to join him. The other woman is Mrs. Avery (Olive Carey) whose prospector husband was killed by the Indians.
As the column proceeds through Indian lands, Kamiakin leads attacks on the troopers. Multiple casualties occur on both sides but the tide is turning in favor of the Indians. Holden sneaks away to talk to the Chiefs but is shot by Kamiakin. And then...........................................................................................
There are several familiar faces playing various roles in the story. First there are whiskey swilling Sergeants Carracart (Lee Marvin) and Dutch Williams (Charles Horvath), Chief Indian Scout Timothy (Sydney Chaplin in a surprisingly good performance), Kamiakin's son Malachi (Orlando Rodriguez) who remains with the settlement, Walter Coy as Major Donahue and Paul Smith Martin Milner and Robert Ellis as raw recruits. Richard Hale and Frank DeKova play two of the Indian Chiefs who have been converted to Christianity.
Jeff Chandler plays Bell as a tough hard drinking veteran who has the respect of the Indians. The love triangle between him, Malone and Andes is distracting. Bond is good as the preacher but I was impressed by the performance of Willis Bouchey as the commander in a type of role he seldom was given.
The ending after Bond's character has been brought to the little church is a little hokey given the character of Emmett Bell.
Thoughtful Cavalry Western
richardchatten6 December 2021
A rather sombre film for veteran director George Marshall, set in Oregon in 1868.
In a well-acted film, Ward Bond is particularly good in a sympathetic role as a preacher; and even Lee Marvin is permitted a touching scene as one of the troop.
In a well-acted film, Ward Bond is particularly good in a sympathetic role as a preacher; and even Lee Marvin is permitted a touching scene as one of the troop.
Routine cavalry vs. Indians fighting over broken treaty...
Doylenf20 August 2006
Slow-paced story gets off to a ponderous start with too much talk and too little action, with only some gorgeous scenery for eye comfort. The fault seems to be George Marshall's sluggish direction of a uniformly bland cast.
All of the actors go through their paces in rather standard roles, including JEFF CHANDLER, KEITH ANDES, WARD BOND and LEE MARVIN and for a western that promises some action when the plot thickens, it's a good half-hour before the conflict between cavalry and Indians provides any thrills.
DOROTHY MALONE has the only substantial female role, as a woman no longer in love with her husband. In make-up and hairstyle, she looks and acts more as though she's a woman of modern times rather than frontier days. The romantic triangle (Malone, Chandler, Andes) is a weak one.
The big set piece is the Indian attack that occurs an hour into the film and wipes out most of the command. It's well staged and vigorously mounted for western action. But it comes too late to alter the slow pacing of most of the story which is either Marshall's or the scriptwriter's fault.
A minor quibble: All of the night scenes have a soundstage look to them, in sharp contrast to all the daytime locations.
Summing up: Lackluster western needed the John Ford touch from George Marshall, with Lee Marvin and his Irish accent less than credible in the sort of supporting role Victor McLaglen usually played. Nothing more than average.
All of the actors go through their paces in rather standard roles, including JEFF CHANDLER, KEITH ANDES, WARD BOND and LEE MARVIN and for a western that promises some action when the plot thickens, it's a good half-hour before the conflict between cavalry and Indians provides any thrills.
DOROTHY MALONE has the only substantial female role, as a woman no longer in love with her husband. In make-up and hairstyle, she looks and acts more as though she's a woman of modern times rather than frontier days. The romantic triangle (Malone, Chandler, Andes) is a weak one.
The big set piece is the Indian attack that occurs an hour into the film and wipes out most of the command. It's well staged and vigorously mounted for western action. But it comes too late to alter the slow pacing of most of the story which is either Marshall's or the scriptwriter's fault.
A minor quibble: All of the night scenes have a soundstage look to them, in sharp contrast to all the daytime locations.
Summing up: Lackluster western needed the John Ford touch from George Marshall, with Lee Marvin and his Irish accent less than credible in the sort of supporting role Victor McLaglen usually played. Nothing more than average.
Fairly Good Western Marred by Insipid Romantic Triangle
dglink20 April 2021
The U. S. cavalry violates a treaty with Native American tribes and incites the wrath of tribal chiefs in "Pillars of the Sky," a fair western that benefits from scenic Oregon locations lensed in Cinemascope and Technicolor. Director George Marshall makes good use of the wide screen and stretches the action across the horizon in some exciting, eye-filling scenes. Producer Robert Arthur assembled a solid cast of actors that include Jeff Chandler, Ward Bond, Keith Andes, Lee Marvin, Martin Milner, Sydney Chaplin, and Michael Ansara. Adapted from a 1956 novel by Will Henry, the screenplay unfortunately wanders from the core confrontation between cavalry and tribes and introduces a sappy romantic triangle that brings actress Dorothy Malone unnecessarily into the mix.
While Chandler, Bond, Andes, and Marvin confront Native American chiefs and warriors, Malone emerges from tribal captivity with her hair, make-up, and clothing intact. Losing no time, Malone as Calla Gaxton, wife of Cavalry Captain Tom Gaxton, played by Keith Andes, is intent on re-igniting her passionate affair with First Sergeant Emmett Bell, Jeff Chandler. Malone's character is a distraction to both viewers and soldiers throughout; she emotes, recites purple prose, and demands attention, while the soldiers are faced with death, injury, and worse.
Consistent with 1950's Hollywood, the Native Americans are portrayed by a Lebanese, a Latino, a Tennesseean, a New Yorker, and, gasp, one genuine Kickapoo. Supposedly, the tribes were converted to Christianity, and some of the film's moralizing will make eyes roll; burning a church; bad; violating a treaty; good; divorce and adultery; no problem. At times the situation and dialog are laughable, although when the film adheres to the action, "Pillars of the Sky" is quite entertaining. With the exception of hot-blooded Malone of the heaving bosoms and languid looks, the cast of veterans perform well under Marshall's assured direction and the fine cinematography of Harold Lipstein. Unfortunately, the story's unevenness will tire viewers, and the film will quickly fade from memory.
While Chandler, Bond, Andes, and Marvin confront Native American chiefs and warriors, Malone emerges from tribal captivity with her hair, make-up, and clothing intact. Losing no time, Malone as Calla Gaxton, wife of Cavalry Captain Tom Gaxton, played by Keith Andes, is intent on re-igniting her passionate affair with First Sergeant Emmett Bell, Jeff Chandler. Malone's character is a distraction to both viewers and soldiers throughout; she emotes, recites purple prose, and demands attention, while the soldiers are faced with death, injury, and worse.
Consistent with 1950's Hollywood, the Native Americans are portrayed by a Lebanese, a Latino, a Tennesseean, a New Yorker, and, gasp, one genuine Kickapoo. Supposedly, the tribes were converted to Christianity, and some of the film's moralizing will make eyes roll; burning a church; bad; violating a treaty; good; divorce and adultery; no problem. At times the situation and dialog are laughable, although when the film adheres to the action, "Pillars of the Sky" is quite entertaining. With the exception of hot-blooded Malone of the heaving bosoms and languid looks, the cast of veterans perform well under Marshall's assured direction and the fine cinematography of Harold Lipstein. Unfortunately, the story's unevenness will tire viewers, and the film will quickly fade from memory.
You Have To Grab The Audience Faster And Better Than This
ccthemovieman-19 May 2007
Since I love westerns, and usually have no problems watching actors like Jeff Chandler, Dorothy Malone, Ward Bond and Lee Marvin, I thought for sure I would enjoy this movie.
Wrong. The lead, "1st Sgt. Emmetr Bell" (Chandler) was a unlikeable, bitter guy who gets a quick slam in about "having no use for the Bible" and appearing as a bitter guy. My major complaint, however, was that - especially in a western - you better grab the audience's attention early on, if you want to hold. Nothing happens in this movie for at least the first half hour. By then I was bored, and I couldn't have been the only one. If memory serves me, the big calvary-vs. Indians battle doesn't happen for at least an hour.
Malone also did not look the part at all. Marvin with an Irish accent? Puh-leeze! They and some of the others either had no credibility or they sounded like they just mailed in their performances.
At least they were good enough to film this on location, in the Pacific Northwest, which always looks impressive on film. This might have been an interesting had they punched it up in the first half, but you can't expect to hold audiences with something this lackluster.
Wrong. The lead, "1st Sgt. Emmetr Bell" (Chandler) was a unlikeable, bitter guy who gets a quick slam in about "having no use for the Bible" and appearing as a bitter guy. My major complaint, however, was that - especially in a western - you better grab the audience's attention early on, if you want to hold. Nothing happens in this movie for at least the first half hour. By then I was bored, and I couldn't have been the only one. If memory serves me, the big calvary-vs. Indians battle doesn't happen for at least an hour.
Malone also did not look the part at all. Marvin with an Irish accent? Puh-leeze! They and some of the others either had no credibility or they sounded like they just mailed in their performances.
At least they were good enough to film this on location, in the Pacific Northwest, which always looks impressive on film. This might have been an interesting had they punched it up in the first half, but you can't expect to hold audiences with something this lackluster.
A solid action western
NewEnglandPat23 May 2005
This fine western is a cavalry-Indian affair that has the usual treaty-breaking by the government as it builds a road and fort on Indian land that causes an uproar and leads to war. The military's action sets in motion cavalry-Indian hostilities and the tribes gather for an attack on the fort. Many of the Indians have been baptised and converted to Christianity by a white missionary and live in peace with the soldiers, many serving as scouts under a sergeant played by Jeff Chandler. Complicating matters are two white women the Indians hold as hostages who are at great risk should war break out. Chandler did some his best work in westerns and is the lieutenant whom the Indian soldiers respect and follow faithfully. Chandler's flirtation with a married woman, played by Dorothy Malone, doesn't have much to do with the story other than to give the leading man a romantic interest. Ward Bond, Michael Ansara and Keith Andes are good in supporting roles. Oregon's scenic beauty is on display in this CinemaScope film.
Mediocre 50's western
Maverick196216 June 2022
I cannot understand some of the glowing reviews on here for this standard 50's western. The best thing about it are some stirring action scenes but it is an hour into the film before we see the first one. The army have broken a treaty and the Indians are on the warpath, understandably, but as usual, they are played by white actors in make-up. The script is lousy with a ridiculous love triangle between the stars, Jeff Chandler, Dorothy Malone and Keith Andes that goes nowhere. There is a Christian conversion theme going through this but not all of the tribes are open to this and one chief played by Michael Ansara is out for revenge. Ward Bond is the Christian missionary who does this work and rather causes the film to drag. After all, we want to see action scenes in westerns, not preaching. Lee Marvin in another early role steals most of his scenes and you have to ask, why did it take so long for producers to recognise his star quality. A lot of the supporting actors give very wooden performances and there is a really irksome situation where the Colonel, played by Willis Bouchey, is constantly out maneuvered by his first Sargent, Chandler. Only Chandler seems to know the best thing to do and you have to wonder how did the colonel ever achieve that rank in the first place as he acts clueless throughout. Three stars for some nice photography when we are not studio bound and some effective action scenes.
Too much political
dhilyard13 June 2021
Absolutely awful.
majrobtrogers24 April 2022
My title says it all. It's painful to watch. A terrible script leads an awful story. The acting is poor but l attribute that to a poor script and a complete lack of direction. The score is typical with the usual "Indian" music. After watching a movie like Dances With Wolves where they use actual natives as real people it's impossible to watch these old 50's movies.
a pillar of a western: historically-based, but little known.
weezeralfalfa29 May 2014
Warning: Spoilers
Directed by veteran George Marshall, this generally excellent western was partially based on the novel "Frontier Fury", by the noted writer of Western novels: Will Henry, in turn, largely based on a historic battle, given various names, between a confederacy of various tribes of Eastern Oregon and Washington and a US army unit, commanded by Colonel Steptoe(Stedlow in the film). This was seen as a defeat by the greatly outnumbered army unit, although hardly the semi-massacre suggested in the film. The official stats suggest only abut 10% of the soldiers were killed or wounded, which about equals the rough estimate for the Indians.
The prominent characters played by Ward Bond(Holden) and Jeff Chandler(Sgt. Bell)are fictional, as relates to the main battle. However, Bond's missionary pastor/doctor clearly is mostly based on Marcus Whitman, who was long before invited by the Indians to establish a mission near present Walla Walla. He was murdered, as part of a general massacre and abduction of Europeans, after the Indians noticed that his European patients were much more likely to survive a measles outbreak than his Indian patients. This incident, which occurred a decade before the 1858 battle featured in the film, is represented by the Indian attack on the mission complex, in which Bond(Holden) is shot dead by the chief of the hostile Indians: Kamiakin. Thus, the film blends these two chronologically disconnected historical themes into a single story. Why was this story characterized as happening in 1868 instead of the actual '58? to justify the advanced firearms used? Although the outspoken chief Kamiakin dies in the film, in fact, like Chief Crazy Horse, this long important belligerent never died in battle. He was well played by Michael Ansara, who makes several impressive speeches in councils.
I only wish that the film had spent some time dramatizing the remarkable escape of the army group, being surrounded by a much larger number of Indians, much like Custer. It only alludes to such in a discussion of plans, then suddenly we are back at the mission. The film very well dramatizes their difficult flight to relocate on a chunk of ancient earth crust elevated 1000 feet above the rolling Palouse Hills, while being pursued by Indians. However, after 10 hours of fighting, their ammunition and water was about exhausted. If the Indians had known this, they could have pretty well finished them off with a concerted night attack. instead, as discussed in the film, an army scout located a weak spot in the Indian's siege, revealed by a campfire count. Thus, a nocturnal escape attempt through this area was decided upon, with rain as an additional obscuring factor. Amazingly, it worked, and they marched an incredible 90 miles in 24 hours to safety, while the Indians concentrated on gathering the equipment they left behind, once their escape was discovered. As in the film, the main Indian allies of the Europeans were the Nez Perce, who greeted the retreating army. The army and Nez Perce would, in time, become adversaries, as dramatized in "I Will Fight No More".
The outdoor scenes were filmed mostly in the NE corner of Oregon, rather close to where the historical action took place. Incidentally, 'Pillars of the Sky' refers to the mountain ranges in this region, we presumably getting an occasional look at the Wallowa range. At this time(1858), the Indians were being besieged by gold prospectors and homesteaders, as suggested in the film.
Chandler(Bell) begins with very adversarial relationships with the elderly Stedlow(Willis Bouchey) and his subordinate officer captain Gaxton. These relationships morphed into mostly mutual respects during and after the big battle. Gaxton and Bell were at odds over Caxton's estranged wife Calla(Dorothy Malone), who shows up as a survivor of an Indian attack on a wagon. This fickle woman claims she never loved Gaxton and has long loved the hard-drinking Bell. Then, during and after the big battle, she changes her mind, admitting that it was mostly her fault that she and Gaston didn't get along well in the past.
Several reviewers complain that the big action scene comes too late to maintain interest in the film to that point. However, in reality, battles were very often preceded by attempts to settle issues by negotiations, which is what the first 45 min of the film is mostly about, along with working out the differences between various army officers. When I think of other Westerns of this era, many had only one big battle, and it occurred late in the film. Thus, I don't see this film as being out of line in that respect. Besides, this was quite a lengthy battle scene, the real battle lasting 10 hours, until darkness. Thus, the reported casualties were actually remarkably few, with this consideration. It was pointed out at this web site that the Indians actually rode bareback or on blankets, in contrast to most westerns, where a saddle was often hidden under a blanket.
I don't have any major complaints about the many players, except perhaps Dorothy. Instead of playing an actual Indian chief, as he did in several other films, Chandler plays an army officer quite sympathetic to the plight of the Indians, rather like John Wayne's character in "Fort Apache", for example. I thought he was quite adequate for his role, as was Bouchey as Stedlow. Ward Bond has one of his best roles. I also liked him in "Wagon Masters". There were actually too many characters for me to keep them all straight.
Presently available at YouTube, as well as an expensive DVD. Amazingly, I rated this higher than "The Searchers" I'll stick with that.
The prominent characters played by Ward Bond(Holden) and Jeff Chandler(Sgt. Bell)are fictional, as relates to the main battle. However, Bond's missionary pastor/doctor clearly is mostly based on Marcus Whitman, who was long before invited by the Indians to establish a mission near present Walla Walla. He was murdered, as part of a general massacre and abduction of Europeans, after the Indians noticed that his European patients were much more likely to survive a measles outbreak than his Indian patients. This incident, which occurred a decade before the 1858 battle featured in the film, is represented by the Indian attack on the mission complex, in which Bond(Holden) is shot dead by the chief of the hostile Indians: Kamiakin. Thus, the film blends these two chronologically disconnected historical themes into a single story. Why was this story characterized as happening in 1868 instead of the actual '58? to justify the advanced firearms used? Although the outspoken chief Kamiakin dies in the film, in fact, like Chief Crazy Horse, this long important belligerent never died in battle. He was well played by Michael Ansara, who makes several impressive speeches in councils.
I only wish that the film had spent some time dramatizing the remarkable escape of the army group, being surrounded by a much larger number of Indians, much like Custer. It only alludes to such in a discussion of plans, then suddenly we are back at the mission. The film very well dramatizes their difficult flight to relocate on a chunk of ancient earth crust elevated 1000 feet above the rolling Palouse Hills, while being pursued by Indians. However, after 10 hours of fighting, their ammunition and water was about exhausted. If the Indians had known this, they could have pretty well finished them off with a concerted night attack. instead, as discussed in the film, an army scout located a weak spot in the Indian's siege, revealed by a campfire count. Thus, a nocturnal escape attempt through this area was decided upon, with rain as an additional obscuring factor. Amazingly, it worked, and they marched an incredible 90 miles in 24 hours to safety, while the Indians concentrated on gathering the equipment they left behind, once their escape was discovered. As in the film, the main Indian allies of the Europeans were the Nez Perce, who greeted the retreating army. The army and Nez Perce would, in time, become adversaries, as dramatized in "I Will Fight No More".
The outdoor scenes were filmed mostly in the NE corner of Oregon, rather close to where the historical action took place. Incidentally, 'Pillars of the Sky' refers to the mountain ranges in this region, we presumably getting an occasional look at the Wallowa range. At this time(1858), the Indians were being besieged by gold prospectors and homesteaders, as suggested in the film.
Chandler(Bell) begins with very adversarial relationships with the elderly Stedlow(Willis Bouchey) and his subordinate officer captain Gaxton. These relationships morphed into mostly mutual respects during and after the big battle. Gaxton and Bell were at odds over Caxton's estranged wife Calla(Dorothy Malone), who shows up as a survivor of an Indian attack on a wagon. This fickle woman claims she never loved Gaxton and has long loved the hard-drinking Bell. Then, during and after the big battle, she changes her mind, admitting that it was mostly her fault that she and Gaston didn't get along well in the past.
Several reviewers complain that the big action scene comes too late to maintain interest in the film to that point. However, in reality, battles were very often preceded by attempts to settle issues by negotiations, which is what the first 45 min of the film is mostly about, along with working out the differences between various army officers. When I think of other Westerns of this era, many had only one big battle, and it occurred late in the film. Thus, I don't see this film as being out of line in that respect. Besides, this was quite a lengthy battle scene, the real battle lasting 10 hours, until darkness. Thus, the reported casualties were actually remarkably few, with this consideration. It was pointed out at this web site that the Indians actually rode bareback or on blankets, in contrast to most westerns, where a saddle was often hidden under a blanket.
I don't have any major complaints about the many players, except perhaps Dorothy. Instead of playing an actual Indian chief, as he did in several other films, Chandler plays an army officer quite sympathetic to the plight of the Indians, rather like John Wayne's character in "Fort Apache", for example. I thought he was quite adequate for his role, as was Bouchey as Stedlow. Ward Bond has one of his best roles. I also liked him in "Wagon Masters". There were actually too many characters for me to keep them all straight.
Presently available at YouTube, as well as an expensive DVD. Amazingly, I rated this higher than "The Searchers" I'll stick with that.
Jeff Chandler and Ward Bond are great
starwoodyorkies4 July 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Chandler 's voice range and his facial expressions were perfect for this movie as always. Ward Bond was great also as a minister and Doctor that tthe Indians respect. Army decided to build a fort making a battle that kills the doctor and many soldiers. The scouts are great especially Timothy. Each viewing will
be enjoyed. Even soundtrack awesome. A few Individuals playing Indians are actually Indians.
be enjoyed. Even soundtrack awesome. A few Individuals playing Indians are actually Indians.
When you talk of all the great westerns,you will talk of Pillars of the sky
TankGuy26 December 2012
Warning: Spoilers
You're always in for a treat when you watch a Universal made B western or B movie even,there's a lot to be said for films like THE BATTLE AT APACHE PASS,TOMAHAWK,WAR ARROW,WINCHESTER 73 and THE CREATURE FROM THE BLACK LAGOON,but Pillars of the sky(also known as The Tomahawk and the cross)is different from all the rest.
Let me begin by saying it is one fantastic western,it has a brilliant storyline,wonderfully filmed scenes and brilliant action sequences,but what makes it unique is it's Christian undertones,which is a good thing as this works very well,George Marshall did an great job at directing some of the scenes,but i will talk about these later.
But first,the plot. In Oregon in 1868,all the native American tribes living in that area have been moved onto reservations and are learning to live in peace with the white man,a preacher played by Ward Bond(whom some of you may remember as Burt the cop from It's a wonderful life)has converted many of the indians to Christianity and baptises them giving them biblical names,all is going well but Chief Kamiakin and some Indian braves want to return to ways of war and seize their chance when the army decides to build a road through the reservation for white settlers,breaking the treaty.Kamiakin persuades the other indians to renounce their Christian faith and fight alongside him against the white man and when they do,so beings killing and misery,Sergeant Emmet Bell(JEFF CHANDLER)is sent out to stop the bloodshed and prevent a war.
So i'll come back to what i was saying earlier,some of the scenes are magnificently done,like the scene when Sgt Bell confronts the Indian chiefs and angrily berates them for renouncing their faith and killing needlessly and the final scene when he reads from the bible before praying is so powerful and moving and very well directed.Now you can see why this is different from all the other B westerns.
But a B western wouldn't be a B western without a couple of excellent action scenes,and Pillars of the sky really does deliver in the action department,there are a few small shootouts but it's the epic battle scene in the middle of the film which is the highlight.It's stands out from a lot of the other battle scenes that i have seen,it's fantastic,the indians charge the soldiers but are in turn blasted into oblivion by a couple of Cannons,then all of the soldiers and their wagons race up a hill whilst being chased and shot at but the wagons tumble over and crash in the process and at the same time the soldiers engage the indians in swordfights and shootouts.Its one epic battle scene which must have taken great dedication and care to film.
All in all one gem of a western,highly recommended,thanks to Pegasus it has been released onto DVD but it's extremely rare so if you ever see it buy it,but when you talk of all the great westerns,you will talk of Pillars of the sky.10/10.
Let me begin by saying it is one fantastic western,it has a brilliant storyline,wonderfully filmed scenes and brilliant action sequences,but what makes it unique is it's Christian undertones,which is a good thing as this works very well,George Marshall did an great job at directing some of the scenes,but i will talk about these later.
But first,the plot. In Oregon in 1868,all the native American tribes living in that area have been moved onto reservations and are learning to live in peace with the white man,a preacher played by Ward Bond(whom some of you may remember as Burt the cop from It's a wonderful life)has converted many of the indians to Christianity and baptises them giving them biblical names,all is going well but Chief Kamiakin and some Indian braves want to return to ways of war and seize their chance when the army decides to build a road through the reservation for white settlers,breaking the treaty.Kamiakin persuades the other indians to renounce their Christian faith and fight alongside him against the white man and when they do,so beings killing and misery,Sergeant Emmet Bell(JEFF CHANDLER)is sent out to stop the bloodshed and prevent a war.
So i'll come back to what i was saying earlier,some of the scenes are magnificently done,like the scene when Sgt Bell confronts the Indian chiefs and angrily berates them for renouncing their faith and killing needlessly and the final scene when he reads from the bible before praying is so powerful and moving and very well directed.Now you can see why this is different from all the other B westerns.
But a B western wouldn't be a B western without a couple of excellent action scenes,and Pillars of the sky really does deliver in the action department,there are a few small shootouts but it's the epic battle scene in the middle of the film which is the highlight.It's stands out from a lot of the other battle scenes that i have seen,it's fantastic,the indians charge the soldiers but are in turn blasted into oblivion by a couple of Cannons,then all of the soldiers and their wagons race up a hill whilst being chased and shot at but the wagons tumble over and crash in the process and at the same time the soldiers engage the indians in swordfights and shootouts.Its one epic battle scene which must have taken great dedication and care to film.
All in all one gem of a western,highly recommended,thanks to Pegasus it has been released onto DVD but it's extremely rare so if you ever see it buy it,but when you talk of all the great westerns,you will talk of Pillars of the sky.10/10.
Excellent western from a non western specialist
searchanddestroy-120 January 2023
Never forget that George Marchal was a very prolific director, as Richard Thorpe, Joe Kane, George Sherman, but him, Marchal, was not specialized in westerns. No, not at all, more, however in comedies. But his rare westerns: WHEN THE DALTON RODE, GUNS FOR FORT PETTICOAT, THE SAVAGE, PILLARS OF THE SKY, DESTRY, THE SHEEPMAN, were pretty good, if not great. Not comedy oriented, or a little, not Burt Kennedy's sixties ones. Only solid westerns, though not at the scale of John Sturges, Delmer Daves or John Ford. So this very one, produced by Universal Studios, is a worth watching Jeff Chandler's vehicle, Chandler at his peak, shining, powerful, with a solid script.
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
