Escort West (1959) Poster

(1959)

User Reviews

Review this title
19 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Unpretentious Western Offers Authenticity, Solid Family Entertainment
oldblackandwhite29 September 2010
Escort West is an unpretentious little Western starring that unpretentious actor Victor Mature. Vic was the original muscle man. Before there was an Arnold Schwarzeneger, even before there was a Steve Reeves, there was Victor Mature. Yet unlike those two aforementioned massive hulks, Vic was graceful and athletic enough to look good in a suit, at least the loose fitting types worn in the 'forties and 'fifties, which constituted his flourishing period. In My Darling Clementine they even managed to pass him off as a consumptive Doc Holliday by keeping him in a grossly over-sized coat and using extra shadow under his eyes. Vic apparently never took himself very seriously as an actor, nor did most film critics. One wag quipped that in a certain movie Victor Mature used all of his muscles except the ones in his face. Okay, he wasn't an Olivier, but in Escort West he turned in a solid, sensitive, charming and effective lead performance.

And he did it with out letting the dreaded presence of a child actress steal the show. Vic plays an ex-Confederate Captain, recently widowed and on his way to start a new life in Oregon with his young daughter (Reba Waters) soon after the Civil War. I must confess that as a life-long old grouch, I usually don't like movies where a cutesy kid plays a major part, but little Reba charmed the socks off of me in the first scene and continued to do it for 75 minutes. Seldom does a child actor or actress turn in such an understated and dignified, yet charming performance. The tender yet never syrupy relationship between the father and daughter amidst the adversity of war, losing their wife/mother and their home, and now hostile Indian attack is one of the elements that gives this story a slight edge over the average B oater.

Not that Escort West doesn't have other good points. The script, co-authored by Bruce Gordon, who also plays one of his typical brutish heavy parts in the movie, is conventional but lucid and entertaining. Francis D. Lyon's direction and smooth editing keeps the action-packed story tense and exciting. Good use is made of the black and white Cinemascope format in both action sequences and panoramic views of the scenery. Characterization is a strong point helped along by a platoon of veteran western character actors the like of Noah Beery, Jr., Slim Pickens, Rex Ingram, and Harry Carry, Jr. The female lead and second lead Elaine Stewart and Faith Domegue also make competent contributions.

This little B programmer displays an unusual authenticity for a western of this era. It was particularly impressive that the cavalry uniforms were true to the Civil War era and not the usual stock 1870's Indian Wars uniforms, which are quite different. The Sharps breech loading carbines used by the cavalry and the Indians were likewise accurate to the 1860's. The Remmington revolvers, though actually later cartridge models, did good service showing profiles that look like period cap and ball revolvers. The holsters looked like Civil War types, and the gun belts were lacking cartridge loops (cap and ball revolvers used delicate paper cartridges which couldn't be carried in loops). The renegade Modoc Indians, who were the principal menace, dressed as most Indians of the period would have -- not naked savages who had only just come into contact with civilization, but wearing mostly the same clothes the whites did with a few Indian flourishes like gaudy belts and leather leggings. Like any acculturated Indian criminals, they used rifles and pistols, instead of bow and arrow and spear, and they fired from behind cover instead of throwing themselves away in dervish-like rushes as we see in so many clichéd westerns.

Admittedly not in a class with Red River or even one of Randolph Scott's better numbers, Escort West nevertheless delivers exciting family entertainment for an hour and fifteen minutes. In many ways it was better than any number of more sumptuously turned out westerns, and for this old, weathered oat-burner fancier at least, better than all but the very best of those whistling, ricocheting spaghetti-burners.
24 out of 25 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Another Trek Through Hostile Indian Country
bkoganbing23 March 2007
Escort West finds Victor Mature as a former Confederate escorting his young daughter out to Oregon territory. They meet up with a troop of cavalry at a stagecoach station, some of whom are hostile. Not nearly as hostile as Faith Domergue who lost a fiancé during the Civil War who is accompanying her sister Elaine Stewart out west to marry cavalry captain William Ching.

After Mature and daughter Reba Waters meet some hostile Modocs and find what they did to part of the cavalry troop they go back to the station where all they find alive are the two women and the sutler, Rex Ingram. Ingram's been wounded and left for dead with a broken leg.

At this point the group sets out to find help and safety, whichever comes first.

Escort West bares a similarity to the Richard Widmark western of the previous year, The Last Wagon. If you've seen that you might figure out how it all turns out. Or just if you've watched a whole lot of westerns.

Escort West barely runs 75 minutes, it played at the bottom of double features in the Fifties. It was produced by John Wayne and folks like Ken Curtis, Leo Gordon, and Noah Beery, Jr., all of whom worked with the Duke before are in the cast. Best in the cast is Leo Gordon who also wrote the script and is one nasty deserting cavalry trooper.

It's a nice action western with some adult themes mixed in with enough action for the kids.
29 out of 31 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
They thought the war was over...
hitchcockthelegend6 September 2013
Escort West is directed by Francis D. Lyon and adapted to screenplay by Leo Gordon and Fred Hartsook from a story by Steven Hayes. It stars Victor Mature, Elaine Stewart, Faith Domergue, Reba Waters, Noah Beery Jr., Leo Gordon, Rex Ingram, John Hubbard, Harry Carey Jr. and Slim Pickens. Music is by Henry Vars and CinemaScope cinematography by William H. Clothier.

Set in Nevada 1865 at the end of The Civil War, Escort West follows ex- Confederate soldier Ben Lassiter (Mature) as he travels West with his young daughter Abbey (Waters). Still meeting hostile reactions from Union cavalry officers and supporters in the area, things take a dramatic turn when Ben and Abbey happen upon the aftermath of a Modoc Indian attack that has left a troop of Union cavalrymen dead. However, there are three survivors, sisters Beth (Stewart) and Martha (Domergue), and injured Nelson Walker (Ingram). The Lassiter's try to escort the survivors to safety, but with the Modocs and rouge Union cavalrymen interested in a payroll in Ben's possession a constant threat out in the terrain, it's going to be tough.

It's pretty predictable in formula, complete with an uninteresting burgeoning romance, but it's a film that's never dull and it's always compelling as a character driven travelogue. The left over attitudes born out by the war add some spice into the narrative, with Domergue portraying a bile strewn bitch from hell and Mature a contemplative father of substance, and there are a good number of action sequences that are thrillingly executed. Cast performances are strong enough for the material, where it's nice to see Mature and Waters' father and daughter relationship play out as tender and believable, and ace cinematographer Clothier's Scope photography is beautiful and keeps the picture consistently airy. 6.5/10
13 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Entertaining Western.
Hey_Sweden14 March 2015
"Escort West" takes place in Nevada, a few years after the Civil War has ended. Victor Mature plays Ben Lassiter, a widowed ex-Confederate soldier travelling West with his 10 year old daughter Abbey (Reba Waters). Deadly Indian warriors named the Modocs are on the prowl, and Ben realizes that they have caused death and destruction in a way station that he had very recently visited. He gathers together the survivors: the bitchy, grudge carrying Martha Drury (Faith Domergue) and her much nicer sister, Beth (Elaine Stewart), and amiable old sutler Nelson Walker (Rex Ingram). He promises to stay with them as they make their dangerous trek through hostile territory.

There's nothing particularly distinguished about "Escort West", but it's still a solid and engaging movie of this type. An uncredited John Wayne was one of the producers. Director Francis D. Lyon creates some scenes of genuine suspense, and the action is likewise decently executed. This is all photographed in atmospheric, black & white widescreen by William H. Clothier. The antagonists are not exactly a faceless bunch, but they're a fairly scary group of men: relentless, unspeaking, unemotional, one-dimensional killers. The lovely music score is courtesy of composer Henry Vars.

The cast is full of familiar faces and excellent right down the line. Mature is just the kind of hero you want in this sort of thing: kind, compassionate, but tough and dependable. Beautiful women Stewart and Domergue are effective, although some might find Domergues' character a bit tough to take. Noah Beery Jr., John Hubbard, Harry Carey Jr., Slim Pickens, William Ching, Ken Curtis, Claire Du Brey, and Syd Saylor co-star. Also in the supporting cast is the great screen heavy Leo Gordon, who co-wrote the screenplay with Fred Hartsook. Child actress Waters is appealing without becoming overly saccharine.

This is a good, diverting story told in fairly trim fashion and running a very reasonable 77 minutes long.

Seven out of 10.
10 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Satisfying
FightingWesterner23 May 2014
In the days following the Civil War, ex-Confederate Victor Mature (Italian accent intact!) and daughter travel west, where they're insulted by and then have to rescue two northeastern sisters from a group of marauding Indians, following a massacre of their military escort.

This is an entertaining enough western, though fairly by-the-numbers and low-budget. However, a short running time, some good suspense, great location photography (in Cinemascope), some sharp gun-play and a neat, rocky climax all help keep things moving along nicely.

Familiar western stars help out too, including Harry Carey, Noah Beery, and slim Pickens, as well as co-writer Leo Gordon and Gunsmoke's Ken Curtis, who play a couple of low-life Army deserters.
9 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Interesting Low Budget Western
bsmith555217 May 2014
Warning: Spoilers
"Escort West" is interesting little low budget Black and White western about the efforts of an ex-confederate soldier Ben Lassiter (Victor Mature) and his daughter Abbey (Reba Waters) to reach Oregon and a new life.

Set in 1865 just after the Civil War, Lassiter finds that not all of the old wounds have healed. At a way station he meets two sisters Beth Drury (Elaine Stewart) and her sister Martha (Faith Domergue) who are in the company of a cavalry detachment. Martha bears a resentment of Lassiter because of the war.

Later on the trail Lassiter finds the cavalry detachment massacred except for quartermaster Nelson Walker (Rex Ingram) and the two ladies whom he had hidden away. The unlikely party then proceeds toward another army group who unbeknownst to them is pinned down under fire from the Indian renegade Tago (X. Brands) who is also in pursuit of the Lassiter group.

Director Francis D. Lyon had the luxury of a seasoned cast of veterans although in some cases he doesn't take advantage of them often under utilizing their talents. Also in the cast are Noah Beery Jr., Leo Gordon (who co-wrote the story), Ken Curtis, William Ching, John Hubbard, Harry Carey Jr., Slim Pickens and Roy Barcroft as various soldiers.

Victor Mature was always an under rated actor. He was usually better than his material as is the case here. Acting kudos in this film go to the veteran actor Rex Ingram who gives a sympathetic performance as the doomed Walker. Faith Domergue is one who never quite made it but is probably best remembered for her dalliance with Howard Hughes. Ken Curtis went on to portray "Festus Hagen" in the long running TV series "Gunsmoke".
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Thought-provoking western
jarrodmcdonald-113 January 2015
Warning: Spoilers
This is a UA release, one of two that Victor Mature co-produced with John Wayne's Batjac company. It has a modest budget and plays like a TV movie or extended episode of TV's Wagon Train. But the ideas presented are grand in scope, and it's a shame there wasn't a larger budget to take advantage of all its cinematic possibilities.

The film offers Mature as a no-holds barred widowed father trying to take his young daughter west to start a new life in Oregon. Along the way, they meet two sisters doing the same after one lost her fiancé in the Civil War. The backgrounds of the main characters are very well explained.

Soon there is an attack by Modoc natives. We never get to see the natives as individuals; instead, we see them intermittently as a hostile element our little traveling group must occasionally fight off. After the initial attack, we are introduced to a black Union soldier, played by Rex Ingram. He's in no shape to travel, but Mature's character insists on taking him along. Of course, there is the eventual realization the old soldier is dead weight. The scene where Ingram threatens suicide to force the others to go on without him is a highpoint of the film.

I liked the way the plot smartly progressed, and there was one action sequence after another, with just enough resting time in between, for us to continue getting to know the characters better. Naturally, it all culminates in a standoff involving more Union soldiers versus the Modoc. The soldiers are not all incorruptible (in a short sequence two try to steal the payroll). Adding to the complications is the fact that Mature, to protect his daughter and the one surviving sister, must join forces with the Union, though he himself had been a rebel Confederate.

So there is a lot being said in ESCORT WEST, and while it is somewhat formulaic and predictable, we care about the people in the story and their relationships. As I said, this could have been expanded more cinematically if the budget had been greater. We could have seen flashbacks of what the leads experienced during and immediately after the war. We also could have seen some more of the attack involving the natives, which mostly happens off-camera. Plus I think a better denouement where they finally arrive in Oregon could have been filmed.

But it's still a very effective thought-provoking independent western picture.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Nothing Special As Westerns Go, but Tolerable.
zardoz-1323 May 2008
Warning: Spoilers
"Gunsight Ridge" director Francis D. Lyon's "Escort West" ranks as an average, occasionally tense, but thoroughly predictable black & white, 76-minute, B-movie cavalry versus the redskins western with few surprises. Victor Mature of John Ford's classic "My Darling Clementine" and a number of other seasoned western stalwarts, among them Noah Beery, Jr., Slim Pickens, Harry Carey, Jr., Ken Curtis, and Leo Gordon, flesh out a solid cast that includes Elaine Stewart of "Night Passage" and Faith Domergue of "This Island Earth." The Indians on the rampage in this oater are renegade Modocs that have been outlawed by their own tribe. This United Artists release benefits from the widescreen cinematography of William Clothier who lensed many John Wayne horse operas, among them "Big Jake," "The Horse Soldiers," "The Train Robbers," "Chism," "Rio Lobo," "The Undefeated," "McClintock!," "The Comancheros," "The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance," "Cheyenne Autumn," and "The Alamo." When Clothier wasn't photographing John Wayne in the saddle, he was shooting James Stewart in "Bandolero!," "Firecreek," "The Rare Breed," "The Cheyenne Social Club," and "Shenandoah." Why the "Escort West" producers—particularly an uncredited John Wayne--did not see fit to shoot this adventure yarn in color is a mystery because it would have enhanced the colorful scenery and made the gray uniform that Mature sports stand out against the blue uniforms that the cavalrymen wear.

The action takes place in Nevada in 1865, not long after the American Civil War. A former Confederate officer, Captain Ben Lassiter (Victor Mature sans a southern accent), and his young daughter, Abbey (TV actress Reba Waters), are riding to Oregon to live with his late wife's sister when they encounter a U.S. Cavalry patrol at the way station. The cavalry are taking two sisters, Beth Drury (Elaine Stewart) and Martha Drury (Faith Domergue), to meet an army escort. Beth plans to marry U.S. Cavalry Captain Howard Poole (William Ching of "The Sea Hornet") while Martha plans to head to the more civilized environs of San Francisco. Martha is snobbish, selfish, and when he sees Lassiter's gray uniform, she drips with venom, because the man that she was supposed to wed died in the Civil War. One character expresses his amazement that Beth and Martha are sisters. The cavalry patrol pulls out while Ben and Abbey hang around to dine.

Later, when Ben and Abbey catch up with the cavalry patrol at the next way station, they discover that the savage, bloodthirsty Modocs have massacred everybody. Two troopers, Vogel (Leo Gordon of "Tobruk") and Birch (Ken Curtis of "Gunsmoke"), were out scouting when the Indians struck the way station. Ben comes across a old African-American, Nelson (Rex Ingram of "Cabin in the Sky"), who has been shot in the lower leg and has been faking that he is dead. Nelson tells Ben about the two Drury sisters hidden in a cellar. The entire way station has been burnt to a crisp, but the Modocs haven't touched the Army Payroll. Ben fixes up a litter to carry Nelson on and they strike out. While all of this is happening, Captain Poole and his men are pinned down by several Modoc marksmen, led by Tago (X Brands of "Gunmen from Laredo"), and they are gradually whittling down the cavalrymen.

Eventually, Ben and company come upon Vogel and Birch. Abbey lets slip that they saved the payroll and Vogel pulls a gun on an unsuspecting Ben, and then Birch and he seize the money. Vogel doesn't have a qualm about killing the two women, Abbey, and Ben, until Birch complains.

Perennial villain Leo Gordon penned the screenplay with Fred Hartsook and Steve Hayes of "Time After Time," and most of the action is cat and mouse stuff with our white heroes trying to outwit the redskins. "Escort West" looks and sounds like your typical western. It isn't bad, but it isn't anything to remember beyond the presence of Mature who looks out of place as a southerner.
9 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
As good as a "B" western gets!
JohnHowardReid12 July 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Copyright 1958 by Batjac-Romina. No New York opening. U.S. release: January 1959. U.K. release: 2 November 1958 (sic). Australian release: 23 April 1959. 6,856 feet. 76 minutes.

SYNOPSIS: Soon after the end of the Civil War, an ex-Confederate captain and his young daughter make a perilous journey through Indian country as they seek a new future in the north-west.

VIEWERS' GUIDE: Lots of action, but the British Board of Film Censors didn't cut so much as a foot and they awarded the film a Universal Exhibition certificate way back in 1958. So who are we to argue?

COMMENT: A taut and exciting little western, with more than enough action to satisfy the most demanding fans. In fact there's enough plot twists to keep any audience involved. True, the characters are much the usual stereotypes, but the players put them all across with commendable force and vitality. Even Victor Mature paints a likable portrait. It must be admitted that neither Elaine Stewart nor Faith Domergue are overly well-groomed or super attractively made up. This lack of superficial beauty may disappoint some of their followers, though I thought it made their presence in the picture more realistic.

CinemaScope is engagingly utilized in the capable hands of director Francis D. Lyon. Not only is the action presented with maximum impact, but the frame arrangements — especially during early dialogue scenes — often make strikingly effective use of the full width of the anamorphic screen.

Speaking of dialogue, it's indisputable that many "B" westerns fall down badly in this respect. But not "Escort West". No doubt actor Leo Gordon who co-wrote the screenplay, saw to it that the talk was much more natural and far less clichéd than the norm.

Production values are well above average. Executive producer John Wayne has not stinted on funds for location filming and has engaged a most competent team of technicians to support the first-rate cast. If you don't like "Escort West", better give all "B" westerns a miss. This is as good as they get.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Taut and exciting
coltras359 January 2022
An ex-Confederate officer and his young daughter, traveling West, rescue two women survivors of an Indian attack in a familiar yet taut and exciting little western. The typical hero escorts survivor through Indian territory story is given a shot in the arm by Victor Mature as the confederate officer, some good characters especially Faith Domergue's character who is a pretty horribly bitter person, some nifty action scenes and superb location of boulders, all set in stark black and white photography. These things lift it from its ordinariness. The end shootout is exciting and the hero's use of the rattler to overcome his enemy is well realised.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Good cast but an ordinary western
NewEnglandPat24 July 2003
An ex-Confederate captain heads west with his young daughter and is caught up in the skirmishes between soldiers and Indians. Victor Mature is the hero of the proceedings as he rescues two women, fights off Indian attacks and saves an army payroll from the hands of renegade soldiers. The two sisters are at odds over the resolution of the Civil War and snipe at each other through the picture. The film has very little pace and spotty action and an awkward romantic plot is thrown in for good measure. Faith Domergue, a B actress who never quite made it to the first rank, is Mature's love interest. Leo Gordon appears as a bad soldier and contributes his talents as a screenwriter for this film.
11 out of 25 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Former Confederate soldier is taking his young daughter to the Oregon Territory just after the Civil War to begin again.
snicewanger12 August 2015
Not much going on here. Made on the cheap by John Wayne's Batjac Productions. Veteran director Francis D Lyon moves the story along without much in the way of character development or a great deal of real western action. Black and white cinematography gives it the look of a television western episode. To it's credit,the film boast a very capable cast led by Victor Mature.Mature seems a bit out of place as a widowed former Confederate soldier taking his young daughter to the Oregon Territory to begin a new life. Leo Gordon,who gets credit as one the screen writers, is his usual intimidating self as one of the cavalry troopers who is up to no good. Ken Curtis, Harry Carey Jr,, Slim Pickens, and Noah Berry Jr are in the cast but are kind of wasted in nothing roles. Faith Domergue and Elaine Stewart portray sisters who are also heading to Oregon to start new lives and you just know one of them will wind up in Vics arms. Domergue is over the top as she hates Mature because her fiancé was killed in the Civil War by the Confederates Rex Ingram turns in a nice performance as the black cavalry quartermaster who is critically wounded in an attack by renegade Modoc Indians.

Most of the action is off screen, so we get a lot of Mature and his daughter bonding and Domergue whining and griping.The outcome is fairly predictable. This isn't the worst Western ever made but considering the talent that was available and wasted it's pretty disappointing.Mature once said of his career" I'm no actor and I got 52 movies to prove it!"
3 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
One character pretty much ruined this movie.
planktonrules30 May 2021
I rarely have seen a film where nearly everything about it is good but one character simply ruins the film. It's that bad with Martha (Faith Domergue)...as her character is tough to believe and is unbelievably annoying and abrasive.

When the story begins, Ben Lassiter (Victor Mature) is taking his daughter out west to live. After all, the Civil War just ended and he wants to raise the child in the wilderness. But when the pair stop to get a bite to eat, a group sitting nearby make it hard for the Lassiters. As they're eating, Martha keeps talking about 'them dirty Rebs' and the like. This is rude...but not too surprising considering the war just ended.

Later, the Lassiters are attacked by renegade Modoc tribesmen*. After escaping, they soon meet up with what's left of a group who was attacked by the Modoc...and only a black soldier (played very well by Rex Ingram) and two sisters.... Beth (Elaine Stewart) and, you guessed it, Martha!

Now you'd think after Ben rescues and helps them that Martha would be a bit nicer. Well, you'd be wrong. Throughout most of the rest of the film, Martha whines, cries, shouts and pretty much behaves like a wolverine with a toothache! After a while, it becomes tiresome....not just because it's hard to believe anyone would be this nasty and ungrateful but also because you just get tired of watching her. Yes, it's THAT bad.

What makes this even more awful is that the film is generally pretty good...and if they'd totally eliminated Martha from the film, it would have worked very well. The acting (aside from Domergue) is excellent and the story interesting (aside from when Martha is in it). Rarely have I ever seen a film that could have been so good simply ruined because a character is so difficult to believe and it so annoying to watch.

*Apparently, Modoc did attack various groups of settlers during this time. Considering their land was being invaded, you could understand why....but according to one source I read, they accounted for about 400 deaths.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Okay western
Wizard-831 August 2015
Made during the height of the western film genre's popularity, "Escort West" overall isn't terribly exceptional, but it does provide an easygoing hour and a quarter of entertainment if you are not in a terribly fussy mood. Even under those circumstances, some minor flaws do arise. It was obviously shot quickly and fairly cheaply - there's nothing really in the way of eye candy on display here. The character of Victor Mature's daughter could easily have been edited out without having to rewrite the rest of the movie. And Victor Mature himself only gives an adequate performance. But the movie does move along fairly swiftly and does not overstay its welcome, and there are a few fairly tense moments here and there. This movie won't make western haters into converts, but if you are a fan of the genre it's an okay way to kill some time.
3 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Slightly Anove Average Western
januszlvii10 January 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Escort Wrst is a good solid western. Certainly not The Big Country or Shane but not bad either. The key to the movie is what you think of Victor Mature ( Ben Lassiter). If you like him you will like the movie, if you do not you will not. Why? He is in about 80% of the movie. Mature actually plays a Gary Cooper, Alan Ladd, Randolph Scott type action hero and equates himself well. He plays a Confederate Captain heading to Oregon with his daughter to live with his late wife's relatives. He gets involved with victims of an Indian attack including two sisters: Beth and. Martha Drury.played by. Elaine Stewart and Faith. Domergue respectively. Beth is the good sister and Martha the not so nice one. Spoilers ahead: Care to guess which one ends up with Ben and his daughter and which one is killed by the Indians? I usually like Faith but not here. Martha is a miserable and unpleasant woman and her beauty is hidden most of the film and it takes away from the film. Anyway I give the movie 6/10 stars. Slightly above average.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A good movie
twridge10 December 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Victor Mature was very good and believably honest when dealing with Children as part of the story - Here he is the loving , protective , worried widowed Father ( as a confederate civil war veteran ) to his young daughter going West to Oregon through hostile Modic Indian country - He was also good with his kids in Kiss of Death and Violent Saturday as well . The other character actors are well done , including his daughter , the injured teamster , the women , and the recognized cavalry soldiers -some good , some bad - The threatening Indians are not overdone and realistically portrayed for that brutal era . Good locations and interesting story line as it develops and well done believable action scenes -Funny part - Spoiler -wonder if it was ad lib from Victor Mature - at end he comes back to worried daughter and others after saving the day and with daughter's beloved missing mule , Gus , she thought was lost - she is overjoyed to see them and says "Daddy , you found Gus !" and happily hugs and kisses Gus , the mule , and then hugs and kisses her safe/hero Father and Mature says with a smile " Did you have to kiss the mule first ? " a funny throwaway line .
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Watchable Western with great Civil War theme
doug-balch29 May 2010
Warning: Spoilers
This is a low budget Western that is a little corny, but highly watchable.

Here are its good points:

  • Excellent Civil War theme.


  • Victor Mature is pretty good in the lead


  • Very nice supporting cast with Slim Pickens, Harry Carey Jr., Leo Gordon and Ken Curtis.


  • Story moves along nicely and holds interest. Only a couple of plot holes/inconsistencies


  • filmed on location, although only in greater L.A. area, not "Nevada".


Here's what dragged it down

  • Little girl is horribly corny and almost ruins movie


  • Female lead characters are weak and the actresses are lousy.


  • Whole plot is on the thin side i.e. not that much really happens in this.


  • Indians are not characterized.
6 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Sly Stallone's dad
bobbobwhite2 July 2010
Film was not much more than a watchable western, but see it for a look at Sly's real dad and mom.........Victor Mature and Faith Dommergue. Check closely the contributions each made to Sly's features, you will see what I mean.

Oh, yeah, story was formula hero western and nothing special other than for the long list of western legends like Slim Pickens and Harry Carrey, Jr. and the drama queen antics of Ms. Dommergue. She was surely the film world's best pouter.

Just kidding on the Sly thing, but they sure look like his parents. Maybe I'm wrong about the kidding.
2 out of 31 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
More nasty Apaches to tend with...and a really nasty female.
mark.waltz4 March 2022
Warning: Spoilers
This is a predictable B Western, done in widescreen but unfortunately in black and white, starring Victor Mature as a former Confederate officer who ends up leading a group of women, including his daughter Reba Waters, through Apache territory, and is accused of stealing payroll which he claims he was returning. Elaine Stewart and Faith Domergue are sisters as different as night and day, with Domergue completely disagreeable and over the top in her nastiness. Mature does the best he can to keep the peace, but with Domergue threatening to give away their location with her every squawk, that won't be easy.

The best moment in this film comes with the character of a wounded former slave (Rex Ingram), knowing that he's going to slow them down, making a drastic decision to save the rest of the group. Of course Domergue isn't at all in favor of him going, so it's easy to hope she'll be victim to an Apache arrow. On the other hand, Stewart is willing to risk it to save a life, even if hers is at risk, so the black and whiteness of these two women becomes rather annoying to watch. There's a large cast of familiar western character actors including Noah Beery Jr., Slim Pickens and William Ching. Coming rather late in the B Western genre, this is nothing spectacular, and Mature is obviously there to do his work and collect his paycheck. You'll pretty much forget about this one as soon as it's over.
0 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed