Electra, My Love (1974) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
11 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Theatrical Cinema/Cinematic Theatricality
vorkapich20 January 2007
Those viewers who are familiar with director Miklos Jansco's better-known films ("The Round-Up," "The Red and the White," "Winter Wind") may find this adaptation of Euripides' Electra takes a bit of getting used to at first. Jansco's earlier films were noted for very long takes and fluid staging in a realistic mise en scene. Here the long takes and fluid staging are used, but the production is more "theatrical," i.e., the costuming is simple, and instead of a bare stage there is a vast steppe in Eastern Europe, with only a few spare structures as sets. It is as if a stage production using contemporary techniques were opened up and presented on an estate, complete with throngs of extras (many of them sans clothing), horsemen riding about, and a roving minstrel. However odd the initial effect may be in terms of conventional expectations, it makes for a mostly intriguing treatment of a classic text.

In fact, this production probably conveys more of a sense of the impact of the ancient Greek plays than stripped-down stage presentations: the Greeks used music, dance and mass movement of the chorus in their staging, after all.

Jansco adds to this with the camera's ability to move in and out of the action, so that within a single long take there are sequences of grandeur and swirling action and then moments of intimate exchanges. The whole experience is one of a theatrical presentation aiming for universality in its approach being complemented and enriched by the versatility of cinematic techniques.

The cinematography is a marvel of technique; the color is pleasantly muted

That being said, the screenwriter appends some contemporary political musings that may strike viewers as either appropriately idyllic (and idealistic) or jarringly naive.

For those who are familiar with the play and/or the director's other work, this film ought to be a pleasure to behold, whatever one may make of the artistic kneadings the material has been subjected to.
13 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A choreography tour de force
rasecz16 February 2007
The Euripides drama is played here on an expansive flat field. Hundreds of participants, a couple dozen horses, pheasants and pigeons move and dance over that terrain while the camera tracks through the crowd. It's a choreography tour de force, especially considering the film is made of about a dozen long takes.

Keeping in mind this was done during the communist regime, the story plays as political metaphor. This is particularly obvious as a modern encumbrance accompanied by a modern text closes the play.

The film I saw had washed out colors. I suspect this may not be in the original, but a sign of an aging reel. Nonetheless, the resulting sepia-ish tinge doesn't diminish the viewer's enjoyment.
12 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Fascinating and highly original.
magus-917 February 2003
If you don't know Jancso's work, I'd recommend starting with either this film, or with the masterpiece THE ROUND UP. Whereas THE ROUND UP combines Jancso's unique and impressive shooting style with a compelling narrative, ELEKTRA is more impressionistic... like a strange, continuously flowing film-ballet, it comes across like a sombre musical, an ancient Greek play transformed into an unusual ritual on the Hungarian plain. At 75 minutes, it is a distillation of Jansco's style, a brief, inspiring introduction to this unique artist.
14 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Classic, Modern, Ageless...
wim-vorster11 December 2003
In December 1975 I saw this film, together with two of South Africa's leading actors, in Paris. A Hungarian film with French subtitles! A great deal of the nuance of dialogue therefore escaped me. Yet, the mastery was unmistakable. This was my first trip to Europe (unlike my friends with whom I teamed up in Paris and who had been around several times before.) I had just experienced Pier Poalo Passolini's Oedipe Re in Zurich and a Mauro Bolognini film, Per le Antiche Scale (Down The Ancient Staircase) in Milan. Great stuff.

But Jancso's Elektreia (or Electra, my Love) just begged for another viewing and I expressed the wish that the film would be showing in London (our next stop.) Lo and behold! It was on in London with English subtitles. After two more visits I realised I will never get enough of the film. It is a classic,modern in its portrayal and ageless in its storytelling. It defies description, because it is dance drama, classic theatre, melodrama and modern politics all wrapped into one. The pain it brings the viewer is frightening. It is one of those films where every shot is a painting that belongs in a gallery, without the camera work becoming pretentious. And the acting is brilliant. Thank you master Jancso! This is available on DVD and although perhaps not Jancso's greatest work, a must for the collector of serious cinema.
19 out of 28 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Not your average movie
kaibab-229 August 2003
More like a play filmed on a barren plain, this movie is marked by long takes and constant motion of people and horses in the background. A nice re-telling of the wait for Orestes' homecoming blending anachronistic props and ancient rituals seeming to come from "Le Sacre du Printemps." Constant dancing and mass movement of horses with the the drumming of the hoofbeats and the gunshot cracks of whips makes sound a character itself and adds tension to the whole movie. Avoid this unless you like art films and the unusual.
13 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A woman scorned
tieman6415 September 2010
Warning: Spoilers
"I was born to disturb men's peace." – Electra

Reminiscent of the latter works of Bela Tarr, Miklos Jancso's "Beloved Electra" is comprised of a series of extremely slow and extremely long takes (there are just eight principal shots, each lasting an entire reel of film). More contemplative music video than conventional film, "Beloved Electra" is based on "Oresteia", a Greek myth written by Aeschylus, an ancient tragedian. The film stars Mari Toriocsik as Electra, a tortured woman who serves as a kind of metaphor for the people of Hungary and their historic suffering. She roams Jancso's landscape with a melancholic face, angry at Aegisztosz for conspiring with her mother to kill Agamemnon, her father.

"I do not forget," Electra mumbles. She is a past in search of justice, symbolized by one sequence in which a line of corpses, in sync, rolls out of sight. The dead have disappeared, but not from her historic memory.

Using several symbolic sequences, Electra bemoans the fact that her nation is slowly forgetting the tyrannies of yesterday, and so waits for Oresztesz's return. Oresztesz being a warrior who will incite the local populace into rebelling against the Stalinist, tyrannical terror of Aegisztosz.

Like Jancso's "Red Psalm", the film has a pessimistic view of revolution; it merely corrects centuries of exploitation by the ruling classes and is likely to spill into unnecessary bloodshed. The film thus ends with Electra as a militant revolutionary, her seemingly irrational lust for blood and justice echoing the ethnic cleansings of Rwanda, Bosnia and Iraq.

The film belongs to a style of film which is typically called "confrontational cinema". It is likely only to appeal to those familiar with Hungary's history and those sympathetic to ritual theatre. Like most of Jancso's films, the camera is always moving, always slowly zooming, slowly roaming its landscape. The story is not conventionally told, but told by dancers, singers and the intricately choreographed motions of their often naked bodies. The physical interplay between the moving bodies and moving camera is Jancso's chief form of communication here, and so unless one is willing to read meaning into these gestures and arrangements, it is impossible to view the film.

7.5/10 – Worth one viewing. Will tick off those expecting conventional storytelling methods. The film is as powerful or as hokey as you make it.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Quiet and Cold as Revenge
rotildao17 July 2008
Warning: Spoilers
Beautiful work done by Miklos Jancso and probably one of his best. The director style is unique and therefore is an opinion divider. And that proves his artistic talent, for good or worse.

Here we are injected with outdoor theatric style with great live nature scenario working in tempo the synchronized choreography of actors and camera. The dialogs are great but occasionally lack in depth and consequently some scenes feel vague and empty.

Still, this is a true work of art, caring for all elements of originality and maintaining enough of a good pace of livelihood. The acting is suspended in air (and time) keeping the notion of time and space loose and freeing actors and audience from dates, and specifics of Historical events and transcends it all with lightness.

Nearly a masterpiece. Mythology and theater fans should see it.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Awful
abhro_00710 June 2005
Warning: Spoilers
This is a very very awful movie.

Actually it deserves actually negative impact. Just analyze the plot and the matters. This movie has no significant value. I've seen couple of guys written that this movie is classic movie but I didn't find anything except the CAMERA PAN from one place to another place. And what about the story? It's not interesting either.

If I would be given a chance to negative rating then I should give it the least negative number.

But unfortunately I have to give it 1 out of 10.

My rating is 1/10.
7 out of 40 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
The revolution lives.
moviesknight22 August 2022
I am particularly not fond of plays adapted into films. It is always tricky the screenplay for a play and film is inherently different. But I like this one as I related it to my homeland. The dialogues are so deep and real, it tears you apart. Perfeftly done the long shots execution plus the visuals are great. I enjoyed it but this is certainly not for everyone. Perhaps there is hope after all. The background actors are there for a purpose, you see their presence everytime. You can feel the story unravelling with itself as it moves forward.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Boring Hippy Art Piece
Oslo_Jargo10 March 2004
Warning: Spoilers
This is a boring film, namely because it spends its entire devotion to Hungarian dancers.

If your cup of tea and plate of toast is watching people dance, then perhaps some of the audience will like it. Myself, I'd pick another movie any day of the week.

I can't say that I was enthralled, it's rather dated, from the 1970's, and attempts to merge Marxist dialectics with modern drama, and it fails miserably.

Although it is truly commendable only for its art leanings, nothing else.
6 out of 46 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Artsy Fartsy movie with too much fart and not enough art
Matt-4419 July 2004
This movie lacks originality. The script is poor, the budget is probably less than that of a high school play, the costumes look horrendous, the performers are stiff as nails, the dialog is numb, the landscape is barren, the cinematography is amateur, the props look like they are about to fall apart, and the pace is slower than drying paint. It was made in 1974, but seems as though it was made in the 1940's and in someone's backyard.

Artsy Fartsy movie with too much fart and not enough art. If you are in the mood for an artsy fartsy movie, look elsewhere.

2/10 stars
7 out of 60 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed