Dokter Pulder zaait papavers (1975) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Good movie that deserves to have English translation added
P-Permafrost17 January 2013
Warning: Spoilers
This is a beautiful movie that deals with addiction (morphine-abuse and alcoholism) and existential crisis in the form of a small-town family Physician ('Dr. Pulder') who discovers that his life has been floating by without him noticing anything of the 'real' life, or other, exciting worlds that can be seen or experienced.

Story

Due to the space restraints I have omitted the summary of the story, but I will add it in the message-board for this movie.

Review

In a sense this is a 'Leaving Las Vegas' in the Dutch countryside, although not as grim or brutal. Yet, the theme of someone drinking himself to death, or in this case, finishing it off with an overdose, stays the same. It can also be seen as an expose about addiction in the higher class. The drug that is abused here is, relatively, not often seen in movies. However, morphine addiction has traditionally been higher among members of the medical class, maybe since they have such easy access to the substance and know how to uphold the signs of a steady life, while being addicted under the surface. Alcoholism, though, is something that occurs at every level of society and it is shown here in all its ugliness and destructiveness, yet we are spared the vomiting scenes, or violence that accompanied the LLV story. Still it is a powerful imaginary that captures the essence of alcoholism: sitting, doing nothing, and drinking your life away, very well.

The movie also captures the social differences that existed in the times that the movie was shot between the higher class and the ordinary or common citizen. While, the medical establishment, in the form of Dr Pulder and Hans, the morphine addicted surgeon, uses difficult words and often speaks in prosaic sentences (a polished and overly polite form of Dutch, as one would read in an old novel) the real life crops up in the form of a local farmer, or a butcher using vernacular language. It does this well, and together with the scenes in which the doctor's wife and son (of which I can't help to think whether he hasn't something better to do, and join the youth-movement of sex, drugs and rock and roll that was common in the Dutch society of the Seventies) try to talk him into behaving 'normal' again ,shows how different classes tragically try to hold upon their position in society.

The acting is superb. The doctors strange journey, and his mannerisms are well articulated and the alcoholic afternoons are played with enthusiasm and verve. One would not be able to differentiate between real drunks and that what is played on the screen. Even a scene in a Belgian restaurant, that slightly borders on the absurd or slap-stick is pulled off with an easiness that makes it nice to watch. A lesser actor could have ruined that scene.

Finally, the cinematic qualities are good. The pacing is slow, especially in the beginning, as was usual in those times, but this doesn't stop you from watching. Shots are well done, the opening scene in which we arrive by boat in the little harbor, is a gem to watch if you like Dutch 16th century architecture and style and the little effects (shots of curtains, water flowing, the poppy seeds, Vodka bottles) are pleasant to watch and stay in your memory.

It's a shame this movie hasn't had any English subtitles added with the DVD version, since I feel it would be an interesting movie to see for an international audience. This movie is just as good, if not better than other Dutch movies, that have received prizes and critical acclaim. The movie, also, can withstand the passing of time much better than a lot of other Dutch movies that were made in the same era.

If you happen to understand Dutch, you should see this movie and if you don't understand Dutch you should still put it on your to-watch list and wait till you find a person that can interpret the film for you.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
visually interesting
satsuma3 November 1998
I saw this movie dubbed from Dutch into Italian (I don't speak Italian or lipread Dutch) so I was pretty lost. I'm not sure whether anything was cut on Italian TV. But it must have been interesting, because I watched it all the way through and I still remember those endless fluttering curtains.
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A must see...
Jaap_Zuurkool28 September 2001
It's about a doctor who lives and works in a quiet village in Holland. One day an old friend from university (medicine) calls and visits him. They are recalling old memories and have a laugh. His friend Hans spends the night in his house. When doctor Pulder awakes he notices something strange...Hans is gone. He wants to find out what happened and he discovers something terrible but paradoxical it is also liberating. It is a great movie with brilliant acting and a very nice story.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
dutch movie about drugs and alcohol
l-meijer1415 September 2007
Warning: Spoilers
It has been a long time since i've seen the movie but it is a real classic dutch movie about being a junkie. One day doctor Pulder gets a surprise visit from his old friend from university Hans van Inge (great role from Ton Lensink!!). They go out for dinner and get really drunk. The next day Pulder discovers that opium has been stolen from his medical practice. After this he finds out Hans died of an OD. Doctor Pulder now gets involved in Hans his life and meets his girlfriend Lies (who is an almost aggressive alcoholic and a classic role from Belgiums Dora van der Groen). He is intrigued with her and her way of life. Pulder starts doubting about his own life. He losses touch with reality. He even starts growing weed (papaver) with Lies. The man has become a junkie himself. The rest you should see for yourself because the film has finally been released on DVD (september 2007). You will not regret it.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Probably Bert Haanstra's worst movie
oszy515023 October 2021
Sadly but probably the worst movie of the best Dutch documantery maker. Maybe the acting is good but the fraternity characters are way too snobbish for this day and age. Enough masterpieces from Haanstra to choose from.
0 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed