Annie Hall (1977) Poster

(1977)

User Reviews

Review this title
589 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
A perfect romantic comedy
FilmOtaku16 May 2004
`Annie Hall', long thought to be Woody Allen's opus, is perhaps a perfect romantic comedy because it not only shows the happy, touching moments of relationships, but also displays the reality of coupling – the occasional waning of interest in one another, the hypercritical moments, etc. It is absolutely brilliantly written; Woody Allen exhibits his usual dry humor and self-deprecation, but also his sensitive, passionate and romantic side. It was because of this film that I fell in love with Woody Allen at the age of twelve (take your cheap shot here) and almost twenty years later he still is that intellectual, bookish and humorous ideal. Diane Keaton was his muse and co-star for this film, and they are perfect counterparts – so much so that their interaction onscreen doesn't seem like viewing two actors in a film, but is a much more voyeuristic experience. Watching `Annie Hall' is like sitting at a bistro table and observing another couple a few tables away, and that is just one of the elements that make this film so endearing. Most people can relate to at least some aspects of Alvy and Annie's relationship, which helps make this film a timeless one.

However, `Annie Hall' is not just a good romantic comedy; it is a film that engages some unusual storytelling techniques. Actors speak directly to the audience, characters interact with strangers on the street who just happen to know the answers to the personal questions posed, there is a brief animation scene, etc. While none of these approaches were new in 1977, their execution was inspired. `Annie Hall' is like a fond memory, or a favorite old song – anytime I have discussed this film with others their smiling expressions are usually tinged with a hint of nostalgia, because one can look back on either their past or current relationship and do what precious few films allow us to do – relate on a personal level.

--Shelly
193 out of 244 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
I Forgot My Mantra....
WriterDave12 February 2006
Woody Allen's seminal 1977 romantic comedy "Annie Hall" is not only laugh-out-loud funny (with some of the most quotable dialogue ever written for the screen...this is the "Casablanca" of comedies, folks) but also sweet and charming (due in large part because of Diane Keaton's smashing performance as the title character, the flighty singer from Wisconsin with a quirky fashion sense and "neat" outlook on life) without ever turning trite or sappy like so many romantic comedies tend to do. Allen wisely deconstructed the genre with his non-linear story-line (something that was later done to even greater effect with a more recent and profound look at relationships, "Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind") and charming little theatrical tricks like talking to the audience or pulling extras into the scene for their opinions on what's been going on. It keeps the viewer off guard and allows for a free flow of comedic and philosophical ideas that might otherwise not have found their way into a more traditional film.

In his latter years, Allen's best work has been when he is not part of the cast (my personal favorites being "Bulletts over Broadway," "Sweet and Lowdown," and the recent "Match Point"). "Annie Hall" was made in his heyday when he could still pull off playing a neurotic New York Jewish comedienne with charm and panache. There's something innocent and benign about his obsessions here, as this was long before the Woody/Soon-Yi fiasco and the days of grossly miscasting himself against younger female co-stars. Yes, Mr. Allen has been artsier (witness "Manhattan") and more satirical (witness "Zelig") but here, with Diane Keaton as his muse, he was never more charming or funnier.
84 out of 108 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
"That was the most fun I've ever had without laughing"
ackstasis7 June 2008
Alvy Singer (Woody Allen) is something of a hopeless romantic. A cynical, death-obsessed New York Jewish comedian, Singer has never been able to maintain a steady relationship with a woman. He has been married twice, and divorced twice. He broke up with one woman because of their disagreements over the "second shooter" conspiracy of John F. Kennedy's assassination, or perhaps that was just his excuse. To paraphrase Freud, possibly Groucho Marx, he simply "would never want to belong to any club that would accept someone like him for a member." He doesn't drive because he is paranoid about driving; he has been seeing a psychiatrist for the past fifteen years, though these appointments were long ago reduced to simple "whining" sessions. There is an inherent uncertainty in everything that Singer says – as though he really knows what he's talking about, but he can't convince himself that he's got it right.

When he accompanies a friend (Tony Roberts) to a tennis game, Singer's first and foremost concern is that the club will deny him entry because he's a Jew. However, that fateful game serves forth something so much more significant and life-changing – he comes to meet the ditsy and exuberant Annie Hall (Diane Keaton). Despite clearly having very little in common, something clicks between the two eligibles, and they embark on a tumultuous years-long relationship that will inevitably fail to materialise into anything further. Erupting with clever dialogue and witty cultural references, 'Annie Hall's' script is one of the best you'll ever see. Not only is the conversation entertaining to listen to, but – even with all the talking to the camera and interacting with random extras – it actually manages to seem startlingly realistic. This is no small thanks, of course, to the main actors, who embody their characters so perfectly that we're unsure if they are acting or merely playing themselves.

Though he had previously released a few well-received, light-hearted affairs, it was 'Annie Hall' that blasted writer/actor/director Woody Allen into the realms of super-stardom. In an uncharacteristic move for the Academy, Allen's film won four 1978 Oscars, including Best Actress (Keaton), Best Original Screenplay (Allen, Marshall Brickman), Best Director (Allen) and Best Picture – not undeservedly, though millions of 'Star Wars' fans would, I'm sure, disagree. Having revisited 'Annie Hall' for the first time in a year, having since enjoyed many of Allen's other films, I am genuinely amazed at his transition from silly comedian to insightful observer on human relationships. Of course, a noticeable evolution in his film-making style is evident in both the science-fiction 'Sleeper (1973)' and the Russian historical spoof 'Love and Death (1975),' but neither boasts the the intelligence nor the sophistication of this film, which wholly discards the Chaplin-like slapstick of Allen's previous films and adopts the Tracy-Hepburn screwball comedy of a decade later.

Originally slated – and filmed, in fact – as a New York murder mystery with a romantic sub-plot, 'Annie Hall' was taken by editor Ralph Rosenbaum and cut down (massacred, if you will) into the modern, witty 1970s screwball comedy that we still enjoy today. It is truly amazing that such an extensive post-production reshaping had no obvious ill effects upon the general flow of the film, though the structure in itself is so hectic that we probably wouldn't notice it, anyway: Allen frequently cuts forwards and backwards in time, his modern characters are able to revisit and discuss the past, characters in split screens interact, Allen regularly breaks the "fourth wall" and addresses the audience directly. Some of the discarded murder mystery elements from 'Annie Hall' were later incorporated into another Allen film, 'Manhattan Murder Mystery (1993),' which also co-starred Keaton.

Aside from Allen and Keaton, numerous smaller roles provide a crucial framework for the overall structure of the film. Tony Roberts is Rob, Singer's old friend and confidant. Paul Simon (of Simon and Garfunkel) plays a record producer who takes a keen interest in both Annie and her singing. Shelley Duvall is a reporter for 'The Rolling Stone' magazine, and a one-time girlfriend of Singer. There are also tiny early roles for Christopher Walken (as Annie's somewhat disturbed brother), Jeff Goldblum (who speaks one memorable line at a party – "Hello? I forgot my mantra") and Sigourney Weaver (who can be briefly glimpsed as Singer's date outside a theatre). Two slightly more unusual cameos come from Truman Capote (as a Truman Capote-lookalike, no less) and scholar Marshall McLuhan (whom Singer suddenly procures from behind a movie poster to declare to a talkative film-goer that "you know nothing of my work!").

Easily the most innovative and energetic of the films I've so far seen from Woody Allen, 'Annie Hall' is a spirited glimpse at the incompatibility of human beings, and a cynical yet bittersweet meditation on the falsity of the perfect romantic Hollywood ending. It is also a considerable comedic achievement, and Allen would repeatedly recycle his trademark neurotic New Yorker screen persona, most notably in 'Manhattan (1979),' but never with more success than this premium outing in excellence. The engagingly-convoluted storyline moves with such briskness that you don't realise just how very little happens, and that, by the film's end, our characters are exactly where they were at the beginning. Nevertheless, Allen manages to say something significant about human relationships – they're totally irrational, crazy and absurd, but we keep attempting them because of what they give us in return. Or, at least, what we think they give us.
58 out of 77 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Allen's best, and one of the best films ever.
polystyreneman6417 March 2003
The film that bested Star Wars for the 1977 Best Picture Oscar, Annie Hall is a remarkable achievement in filmmaking that transcends its simple, romantic premise to create a stunning portrait of not only 70's pop culture, but of human nature cumulative. Directed and co-written by Woody Allen, who has since directed other gems such as Hannah and Her Sisters and The Purple Rose of Cairo, Annie Hall also stars Allen as Alvy Singer, a neurotic, death-obsessed comedian who seems unlucky in love and life. That is until he meets Annie, brilliantly played by Diane Keaton, who is beautiful, fashion-savvy, carefree (she likes using expressions like `la di da'), and a terrible driver.

Annie and Alvy's relationship is an unlikely one. She's a Midwestern girl, straight out of white-bread Wisconsin; he's a life-long New York Jew who grew up (literally) under the Coney Island roller coaster. He's been seeing a therapist for the past 16 years; she only `needs' one once she meets him. She's an extroverted aspiring singer; he's an introverted, world-despising imp. Yet Allen and Keaton are so perfect in their roles, they improbably make this couple one of the most memorable ever.

The plot revolves around Alvy's chronicles of loves lost and a retrospective on his relationship with Annie, with whom he has since parted ways. At the end of the film, we see Alvy try his hand at stage-writing-he writes a play about his relationship with Annie, but gives it a happy ending. Yes, Annie and Alvy don't have a fairy tale ending to their relationship, but Alvy certainly wishes they had, even though he learns to live with the acknowledgment it has failed.

The best part of Annie Hall is its incredible screenplay-the best ever to be written. Not a word is wasted nor a line unquotable. Except here, while Allen's early films had thrived on streams of one-liners, Allen doesn't go for cheap laughs-each line is simultaneously hilarious and poignant. Everything is part of a greater whole. We laugh because it's funny, but there's a greater dynamic at work in Annie Hall. This is a story not exclusively about a relationship between two people, but also a musing on 70's politics, drugs, East Coast/West Coast rivalry, narcissism, religion, celebrity, and several other topics with which Allen deals with extraordinary ease.

Yet Annie Hall would not be among my favorite films of all-time if it were just Woody Allen ranting and raving about what he likes and dislikes. There are other Allen films that serve that purpose, i.e. Deconstructing Harry, and they're not nearly as good. What separates Annie Hall is its grace, the believable chemistry between Keaton and Allen, the unique direction (ranging from split-screens to cartoon imagery to on-screen subtitles of what the actors are thinking), but mostly because it's the rare film to find a perfect balance between sheer entertainment, humor, and poignancy.

When the dust had settled, Diane Keaton deservedly won an Academy Award for her performance, Allen took home Oscars for direction and writing, and the film beat out Star Wars for Best Picture, which most people consider a complete sham. Evidently, those people didn't see Annie Hall, for if they had, they'd recognize that the acting, writing, and even the direction in Star Wars can't hold a candle to Annie Hall, one of the best films ever made.

10/10
285 out of 363 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Landmark Storytelling from Allen's Creative Mind
nycritic23 January 2006
Warning: Spoilers
At the time, no one had done this: tell a story in the manner that Woody Allen did. Even though many films up until then were talky, with minimal action, with the exception of CITIZEN KANE, nothing of the sort prepared the audience at the time for what they were witnessing: scenes that introduced dialog between two actors much before they actually showed on screen. Scenes in which actors interacted with the past as if it were the present. Scenes in which actors who aren't in the same frame even when they are on screen talk to each other. Scenes in which what the characters are saying does not match their thought bubbles and we are privy to their thoughts. The discussion of an intellectual's work which suddenly produces the said individual, among many more.

ANNIE HALL is a unique film that still looks fresh, even when the style in itself is very 70s. This is a story of a breakup told in a non-linear pattern, showing how these two disparate yet similar people -- Alvy Singer and Annie Hall -- came together, shared their neuroses, went through hilarious times and then went into the slow plateau that became their eventual separation. This is not the kind of story that Hollywood likes to tell and it's quite admirable that Allen was able to not only get away with it but to walk away with the major awards (as well as give then girlfriend Diane Keaton her own Best Actress award) because this being such an intellectual film and not one where the actors all look glamorous, it broke new grounds for a novel way of presenting a film.

Groundbreaking is the definite term here. Had there been no ANNIE HALL, there would have never been ALLY MACBEAL or SEX AND THE CITY, two successful sitcoms that features inner dialog, people talking directly to the camera (and therefore winking at the audience), fantasy sequences, and modern views of how people react to each other. Balancing slapstick with drama, it is also one of the saddest comedies to ever been made and anyone who has seen the final sequence -- which plays out what the film has mentioned all along, that this is their breakup -- knows the heartbreak that unfolds over Diane Keaton's haunting vocals. One of the ten most influential movies of all time.
90 out of 119 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A masterpiece, when you think about it
IkuharaKunihiko27 December 2005
Warning: Spoilers
Sometimes I wish Woody Allen was cool and self confident, and not always nervous, unsure and geeky all the time. But you can't deny that he's a very intelligent person. His best film, the quiet and understated masterpiece "Annie Hall", is so full of jokes and inventive style it can make your head spin. Actually, this is one film I wish I had a script of so I could slowly read all those dialogs which are being said too fast. In 1978 "Annie Hall" beat "Star Wars" and won 4 Oscars ( Best picture, director, screenplay, actress Diane Keaton ) and one Golden Globe ( Best actress Diane Keaton ).

--------

The simple comedy about a romance between the New York comedian Alvy and Annie is enriched by tons of emotions and inventive film techniques which even Jean-Luc Godard would be jealous of. In one scene Alvy is talking to Annie about art while the subtitles are presenting his *real* words, about how he wants to take her out! In the other they are having intercourse in bed while Annie's ghost/mind is absent and sitting on a chair! Alvy is walking down the street and saying how he watched the animated movie "Snow White and the seven dwarfs" and fell in love with the witch and presto, in the next scene he is drawn in animation in the middle of that film, having an argument with his lover, the witch. The list goes on and on.

I remember that I couldn't watch this film when I was a kid. I found it to be too boring. But today I completely understand it. You just have to think about it. Like when Alvy is so happy he says to Annie that he doesn't just love her, but that he "luurves her, loaves her and luuf's her." Also, some of the gags are simply quietly hilarious, like when the hero is narrating his society as a child, commenting on everything ( "Those who don't know nothing, teach. Those who don't know how to teach, teach gym. And those don't know even that, teach at our school." ).

Grade: 10/10
71 out of 96 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A wonderfully modern romance
BratBoy-222 February 2000
Woody Allen's masterpiece will always be "Annie Hall." What is most remarkable today about this film is the way Allen presents it. It's a movie about a relationship. But rather than taking a linear approach, Allen plays with time. We see the middle, the begining, and the end. And not always in that order. Allen also breaks the fourth wall a lot and has many dream sequences and asides which add to the complexity of the characters. This is a highly autobiographical film and Allen pulls no punches. This movie is not about romance in the way that "Breakfast at Tiffany's" is. Rather, "Annie Hall" is a deconstruction of a romance. At times it is funny and heartbreaking and always classic. "Love fades," indeed.
109 out of 155 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Witty and Charming, one of Allen's greatest achievements.
boycebrown-114 May 2004
Annie Hall is a movie about life. In recent films, there are fairly predictable endings. (i.e. guy gets girl after chase scene in Manhattan). Annie Hall goes against the grain of movies. There is definite chemistry between Allen and Keaton. That is one of the main reasons this movie is successful. Alvy and Annie do not have high wage jobs, they do not go clubbing, nor are they incredibly attractive. Why does a movie character relationship have to be so extreme it's unconvincing? These days movie producers create plots that are unbelievable. They don't have any depth and usually have shallow intentions. You can sense that the two leads care for each other. The situations in this movie resemble real life and that is why it is so critically acclaimed and remembered. Sure Woody talked into the camera, but that, in a sense is real life as well. It reminds me of my usual thought process and how when I think; I feel as though I'm presenting my thoughts to myself. Only he is, presenting it to us. This movie is clever and thought provoking. If you're looking for the opposite of a yearly run of the mill movie, this is for you.
82 out of 121 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
The Horrible & The Miserable...
Xstal7 November 2020
Another world according to Woody, with some especially acute observations and witticisms about almost everything, but always with an exceptionally pessimistic pass. Flows fluently from beginning to end, seldom comes up for air and leaves us with an overflowing half full glass of confusion, misery and despair but always with perspective and a few chuckles.
16 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Classic and still timely
MarieGabrielle7 February 2006
Warning: Spoilers
I had forgotten about how hilarious this film was, even though I had seen it as a teenager many times. Since Marshall Brickman wrote the script, it is brilliant; like the part where Diane Keaton orders a pastrami on white bread with mayonnaise, in a NY deli.

Woody Allen's expressions and character studies are priceless, and at this point he was at the top of his game. Some of his films now are redundant "The Curse of the Jade Scorpion" seemed too contrived. But this film was a realistic comedy between him and Keaton, their analysis (no New Yorker in the 70's should be without an analyst!), and their eventual break-up when she relocates to L.A.

Paul Simon and Jeff Goldblum portray other L.A. characters, and there is a bit part with Christopher Walken as Keaton's suicidal brother (excellent). Rent this film again if you haven't seen it in awhile; some scenes are classic, and one of the best is Christmas in L.A. as Tony Roberts drives Allen through Beverly Hills: Keaton: "Wow. It's so clean out here" Allen: "Yeah that's because they never throw out their garbage they just put it on TV".

Great...Woody Allen we need your humor again, please write something decent for American audiences with a brain.
41 out of 60 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Woody Allen Just Doesn't Do It For Me.
meddlecore28 July 2022
If this is considered Allen's magnum opus...I'm just not sure where to go from here...because whereas I can dig this style of anti-romantic comedy...it's his particular brand of humour that just doesn't do it for me.

With that being said, I fully appreciate the structure of the film.

The connection and transitions between vignettes, the breaking of the the fourth wall (by addressing the audience through the camera), the creative use of subtitles (that provide us a glimpse into the underlying thoughts of the characters while they have a conversation where they otherwise pander to each other's expectations)...all very clever.

I also love all the movie and literary references he manages to weave in.

And all the locations- from both New York and LA- that he incorporates into the film.

But his brand of humour just doesn't swing it for me.

It just comes off as bland and unrewarding, and leaves me unfulfilled.

But, perhaps, that is what he was going for...awkward humour, from an awkward man, making an awkward picture, about his awkward relationships.

Am i just missing the brilliance?

Probably.

But I can't help but feel how I feel about it.

I will admit, I was entertained by the film itself, even if the characters- and their sense of humour- turned me off.

So maybe I shouldn't throw Allen under the bus (despite the criticisms that society has directed at him since), without giving some of his other films a shot.

I will probably, at least, watch Bananas, Sleeper, and Manhattan going forward.

But I will certainly be going into those with much lower expectations than I had here.

Because, despite it's reputation as "the best New York based romantic comedy ever made" (Breakfast At Tiffany's is better, in my opinion)...I don't understand how it won 4 oscars (perhaps it was a slow year...).

It's certainly not a bad film, by any metric...it's just not my kind of film.

But maybe it's one of those things that has to grow on you, over time (despite Allen clearly having the opposite effect on every woman he's ever met).

6 out of 10.
10 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
New York angst on the romance couch.
jnaradzay28 December 2005
Warning: Spoilers
Annie Hall shows us the love story between Alvy Singer (Woody Allen) and Annie Hall (Diane Keaton). We watch Alvy as he matures and moves through several relationships set against the true love of his life: Annie Hall.

Alvy helps Annie grow and come out of her shell as evinced by the growth of Annies blossoming singing career. Even the songs are a metaphor for their relationship. Her first song "It had to be you" when their relationship starts. Later she sings in a mature, sultry voice "Seems like old times." Set against snapshots of their romance.

Keep your eye out for these young actors: Christopher Walken pre-Deer Hunter, as Annie's psycho brother "I dream of turning the wheel into the on coming lights." Alvy interrupts him "I have to get back to the planet earth." Jeff Goldblum pre-Big Chill, Jurassic Park, The Fly, In Tony Lacey's house calling his guru: "I forgot my mantra." Paul Simon as Tony Lacey a Californian music star. Carol Kane as Alvy's first wife whose relationship is influenced by Alvy's obsession with JFK's assassination conspiracy theories. Colleen Dewhurst, Annie's WASP mother, talking through the split screen to Alvy's mother. See if you can spot Sigourney Weaver as Alvy's date standing in front of the movie theater when Alvy meets Annie in NY at the end of the movie. Watch Gary Mule Deer in full afro when Alvy meets Annie in California. Now Gary tours with Johnny Mathis. Shelly Duvall as the transcendent Rolling Stone reporter. In a few years she will become Olive Oyl then Wendy of the famous "Here's Johnny" scene from the shining. My, how this movie hasn't aged at all. And that really is Truman Capote walking through the park when Alvy says, "And this guy gets the Truman Capote look-alike award."

You have got to like Tony Robbins, a square jawed ladies man in many of Woody Allen's movies (Radio Days, A midsummer nights sex comedy, Play it again Sam). You don't mind seeing Robbins type cast because you instantly know that he is going to be the perfect opposite of Allen's angst filled Alvy.

Another Woody Allen directing feature that I happen to like is his use of the split screen and the fixed screen. In both, the camera doesn't move thereby forcing you to get involved in the dialogue. These techniques work because Woody Allen has strong, tight dialogue and truly dramatic actors.

Many of the scenes from the late 70's and early 80's are wonderful to watch because they reflect the matter of fact mores and fads of the time: Snorting cocaine was cool, the veggie-burger-tofu California scene, the liberal Columbia college satire.

Listen carefully to the background chatter during the California scene at Tony Lacey's house with swinging' hip background music. Hysterical lines that you can use in your office today: "Right now it is only a notion, but I think I can get the money to make it into a concept then later turn it into an idea." Woody Allen has satirized and captured the language and mind set of the entire movie/music industries.

A memorable scene is when Alvy pulls Marshall McLuhan out from behind a movie placard to refute some bombastic guy pontificating about McLuhan's poetry. You wish you could do the same.

Truly a great movie that ages well and has a sweet message about romance.
20 out of 29 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Annie, Are You Okay?
NoDakTatum3 December 2023
Yep, this is it. The film that beat "Star Wars" for the Best Picture Oscar for the year 1977. After seeing all five Best Picture nominees (the others were "Julia," "The Goodbye Girl," and "The Turning Point") for that year, "Annie Hall" is the worst of them. Alvy Singer (Woody Allen) lives in New York and falls in love with Annie Hall (Diane Keaton). Their romance affects his friendships, his life, and his career as a comedian. Alvy begins looking for parallels between Annie and his two ex-wives, waiting to see what will go wrong here as well. The couple never seem right for each other, as Annie comes into her own.

While Allen can certainly write and direct a film, his screenplay here is a disappointment. Allen jumps back and forth in time, but without a reason. Maybe the flash and whistles were to cover the fact that the basic romance between Annie and Alvy is as compelling as watching paint dry. I did not care about these two people because Allen did not give me any reason to. The cast is certainly funny and charming, but that is a credit to the actors more than the material. The film plays like a series of Allen's best ideas, full of gut wrenching laughs. Come on, his grandmother never gave him anything because she was too busy getting raped by the Cossacks? Annie's family's reaction to the Jewish Alvy is also classic. The film is full of "classic moments" that are wonderful when taken separately, but fail in the overall feel of the film- my identical reaction to "There's Something About Mary." I kept getting this odd feeling that "Annie Hall" was trying to deceive me, like a bait and switch. You go in expecting at least a classic romantic comedy, instead you get the comedy and no desire to see these two people together in the end. "Annie Hall" is one of the more average films in the Woody Allen filmography. You can spot themes that he will revisit time and time again. My two favorite films of his at the point I saw this were "Take the Money and Run" and "Radio Days." My two least favorite films of his were "September" and "Alice." "Annie Hall" falls right in the middle- simply average.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
I didn't get the hype.
studioAT12 September 2016
People love 'Annie Hall'. They rave about it and regularly claim it's the most influential film on their lives.

So I watched it. And I can't say it did much for me. Sorry.

I think it's mainly down to the fact that I found Woody Allen's character annoying. Yes, it was endearing for a bit, but over the course of the film I lost patience with him and his neurotic behaviour.

At times it felt more like a collection of sketches rather than a film, with some being funny, and others not.

My review is largely pointless, I know. Those that love 'Annie Hall' will continue to watch it and get others to do so too. But for me 'Annie Hall' is a tad overrated.
65 out of 102 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The Story about the Story
tedg28 June 2002
Woody is an intelligent man who worries about the issues of film-making. The primary concern, the very first problem, is always to decide what the relationships are among the audience, the camera, the narrator if any, and the characters.

Woody was on his way to making a murder mystery, which is the purest form of messing about with these relationships. In a much studied decision, they decided to cut out all the mystery and just focus on the context. In this case, that context is a richly layered evocation of a relationship. I really wish I could see the original film to discover the mysteries Woody intended to hide in the folds.

And the folds are as numerous and complex as they can get. We have a framing device where Woody speaks to us partly as a conversation which blends into a standup, which is mirrored as a part of the story. We have timeshifting where we move back and forth in time in a simple 'Tarantino' way; but we go way past: characters from the 'present' enter the past as Dickensian ghosts, then they talk to characters in the past. we have characters in different pasts talking to each other via split screen. We have a layering of Woody and Diane's relationship in real life, then the film, then TWO films within: a play which is part of the action and a cartoon which is the action itself.

More: we have Woody talking to the audience as if we were shifted into the play -- early in that play we are introduced to Bergman and Fellini: in both cases while they are waiting outside. These are the two inventors of folded narrative. Even more: while some bozo perfessor spouts off about Fellini and McLuhan, Woody enlists the audience to challenge him and drags out McLuhan himself! The joke of course is that McLuhan himself was a vapid weaver of lowbrow theories.

And more and more with the constant weaving of 'analysis' and other film-like activities: singers, photographers, TeeVee stars, models...

This period was when he was first exposed to Wallace Shawn who was hanging out with Terrence Malick, two other innovators in narrative folding. All the 'New Yorker' stuff means more when you know Shawn's father was the long-time editor of that publication and defined the self-absorbed reflection that characterizes the city and this film.

Keaton's manner was essential to pulling this off, someone who could pull off the story about her uncle dying while waiting for a Turkey. Watch her.. she is clued in to simultaneously being in herself (Keaton), herself (Hall), inside the story she is telling and inside the story Woody is telling. She shifts and guffaws just as if she were stoned and moving among realities, just as her character.

Just amazing and intelligent. Will we ever see this the way it was written and shot? Or is that mystery too intelligent for us, who prefer to think of this as a funny, endearing love story.
83 out of 122 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
One of Woody's best!
Sylviastel10 October 2008
Okay, Woody Allen could be annoying sometimes and is heavily neurotic even in this film which he wrote and directed. The film is somewhat autobiographical about his relationships with a WASP woman named Annie Hall played by Diane Keaton in her Oscar winning role. Woody plays himself in the film even with a different name. Even though it's a short film, the story moves quickly and you have to be alert for some of the humor about the relationship between men and women. The supporting cast includes Tony Roberts, Paul Simon, Carol Kane and others. Woody's hatred of Los Angeles and all things Californian is well-known and documented. He is out of touch when he is away from New York City where he is equally neurotic. As a couple at first, Woody and Annie get along great but slowly Woody's own negativity creeps into the relationship. Annie starts seeing a therapist and their relationship unravels. When Annie's promising career as a cabaret singer rises, Woody becomes threatened and goes to Los Angeles to bring her back.
17 out of 25 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The film where Woody Allen found his own voice, and one of his best ever films
TheLittleSongbird9 February 2014
Not everybody will love Woody Allen's humour, some will find him interesting and sharply insightful while others will find him self-indulgent. With me, it veers very largely towards the former with some occasions where the latter does creep in. Annie Hall is one of his best films, a masterpiece and one of the better Best Picture winners of the 70s with only the two Godfather films even better. The best assets are the script and the chemistry between the two leads. The script is enormously witty, with cracking dialogue that induces one and at times more laughs a minute, and full of insightful observations. People have deemed it one of the best screenplays of all time, and from personal perspective there is no reason to argue. The chemistry between the two leads, running somewhat on a parallel between the relationship of Woody Allen and Diane Keaton itself, and the actors in general actually is throughout very believable. It is often adorable and often dynamic. It helps that Diane Keaton gives one of her best and most endearing performances, and while Alvy is not a particularly likable or sympathetic character Woody Allen is similarly great, his looking into the camera and breaking the fourth wall moments were funny. The supporting cast all give spirited performances, especially Tony Roberts, Paul Simon, Carol Kane and Christopher Walken, Jeff Goldblum is memorable as well for one of the film's best and most quotable lines. The romance is sweet and relateable, the ending for me was really moving, but the story doesn't depend on that alone, Allen also muses over topics that were relevant then and that we can see as relevant today as well, he does so in a very thoughtful way. Allen directs with assurance, and while there have been more visually audacious Woody Allen films since Annie Hall it is still cleverly made with the way it's shot, the cartoon images and how we're shown visually what the characters are thinking. There is no music score and in this case that was a good idea, there was more leeway for the relationship between the two lead characters and observations to speak, and that's the same for the deliberate but never tedious pacing. Overall, an outstanding film, one of Allen's best and one of the greatest films of the 70s. People may dislike it for it winning Best Picture over Star Wars(this viewers and many others however think it fully deserved the win), as much as I'll have a fondness for the Star Wars original trilogy and consider it a milestone of its genre it is easy to see out of Star Wars and Annie Hall which is the superior film. 10/10 Bethany Cox
15 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Woody Allen is a genius.
randyhndrsn21 January 2006
Woody Allen is one of the greatest film maker's of all time, his movies are written perfect and he does comedy perfect.This is not my favorite Woody Allen movie, but i do like it a lot and i love how he does this movie.It is drama with comedy, and scenes in new york and the same music in all his movies, Woody Allen dosen't like to change.But i think he has something perfect, i wouldn't change it either and one thing good about Annie hall is woody.Him acting the way he does and talking to the camera is perfect, this man makes the movie with Dian Keaton doing a great job as well.Her roles in a lot of his movies are always excellent, this was Woody Allen's first big Oscar winning movie and is still considered his best work.If you like Woody Allen, then this film is just for you and i think it is a good couple movie that you can watch with a wife and girlfriend.The great Woody does it again with Annie Hall.
34 out of 63 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A Benchmark
Hairy_Lime26 November 2003
Who hasn't stood in line in front of a foolishly pontificating ill-informed blow hard and wished for a large sock with manure in it? Who hasn't fallen in love with someone only to wonder why that person would fall in love with the likes of you? Who hasn't loved someone so much, just as they are, that you wanted to change them to make them perfect? Who hasn't - as an analogy - treated the end of love like a coward treats a machine gun nest, rushing into the line of fire just to get it over with?

Yes, this is Allen's best film, because it is Allen's most universal. You do not have to be a New York Jewish intellectual undergoing psychoanalysis three times a day for this movie to resonate with you. You simply need to do what we all do: love not wisely, but too well. This movie is a benchmark for Allen; moving away from his earlier, "funny" movies to his more serious stuff. It hasn't always been a smooth transition, and many of his later movies ignore that what Allen does best is be funny - only Crimes and Misdemeanors, of his later films, works without being consistently funny. But here, as in Hannah and Her Sisters and Manhattan, Woody Allen mixes his seriousness of purpose and humor expertly.
12 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Alvy and Annie
bkoganbing8 February 2020
Woody Allen's masterpiece with favorite co-star Diane Keaton has Allen casting himself as New York born comedian Alvy Singer and his relationship with Keaton in the title role. Annie Hall is one of those films you can watch four or five times and pick up a bit of humor and/or philosophy that you missed the first time.

Allen is playing himself in Annie Hall, a successful comedian who spends most of his time psychoanalyzing himself and all around him. He can't make any relationship permanent.

Along comes Keaton and it looks like this is the one, but there's always pitfalls when you deal with a walking neurosis like Allen.

Both Woody and Diane fit so naturally in their parts you think you are peeking in on a home movie. Annie Hall won for Best Picture, Best Actress for Diane Keaton, and Best Director and Best Original Screenplay for Woody Allen. Best in the supporting cast is Tony Roberts as Allen's sidekick actor buddy.

This really is a timeless classic. It's humor has no temporal limits. Annie Hall can be made today with the same script and you wouldn't lose a scintilla of humor.
7 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Stand-up comedy with depth
Teyss19 August 2016
Warning: Spoilers
When Woody Allen stars in one of his movies, you either love it or hate it. In the latter case, you can find it wordy, narcissistic, confused and neurotic. If you love it, well, you'll find it... wordy, narcissistic, confused and neurotic... but with talent!

If we wanted to categorise Allen's films, we could discern a first period that ends with "Annie Hall": these are generally comedies that look like a succession of sketches. As a reminder, before being a playwright and a film director, Allen started his career as a comedy writer and then a stand-up comedian, for almost twenty cumulated years: this influenced his first pictures.

After "Annie Hall", he found a style where comedy, if present, is a supporting element instead of a central focus. This movie is hence a turning point in Allen's career; it certainly is the best of his first period, and arguably one of his best ever. With retrospect, it seems as if he wanted to crown his first style before moving on to something different.

STAND-UP, WOODY/ALVY!

"Annie Hall" feels like a stand-up long feature, which constitutes its originality as well as its limit.
  • The stand-up comedy style is fully assumed: it starts with Allen telling two jokes to the audience, and ends with another joke.
  • The main character is a comedian and we see him on stage once, a reference to Allen's former career. Revealingly, he narrates the whole story. There is a self-parody component, whereby Allen caricatures himself as Alvy and the tone is detached.
  • Throughout the movie there is at least a joke every minute, addressing very different topics, some of them serious, albeit generally in a light mode: life, love, death, the universe, relationships, time passing, childhood, WWII, knowledge, culture, humour, lifestyles, Jewish identity, psychoanalysis, drugs, sex and how (not) to cook a lobster.
  • The movie is loaded with funny directing tricks. Even if most of them are not new, they efficiently support the humorous tone and keep the audience focused, since the stand-up style on its own is difficult to sustain on the long term: talking to the audience, placing the adult character in childhood scenes, having characters comment past scenes shown to them, subtitling characters' thoughts as they talk about something else, introducing a cartoon sequence, having an actual celebrity (McLuhan) intervening in the fiction, etc.


VOYAGE INTO ALVY'S BRAIN...

However "Annie Hall" is more than this. Form, far from being random, is clever. Narration is non-linear, transitions are frequently made by thought associations (as in psychoanalysis), past and present mingle, shots are on average long: we are in Alvy's brain.

Progressively, the movie gains depth, as the relationship between the main two characters evolves. Annie Hall matures from a naive woman, intellectually dominated by Alvy, to an elaborate lady who knows what she wants, while Alvy stagnates with his issues. (Here we must ask: what does the beautiful, classy, witty Annie find in the neurotic, possessive, paranoid Alvy? Answer: the mysteries of love.)

... AND NOSTALGIA

Additionally, the movie increasingly becomes nostalgic. What gives it a special touch is the fact the story between the main two characters is partly inspired by the actual relationship between Woody Allen and Diane Keaton themselves: Keaton's actual family name is Hall and her nickname is Annie; Keaton admitted she recognised herself in the role; Allen and Keaton had a relationship for about a year in 1970, broke up and remained friends... as in the movie. The fact the actual relationship ended approximately six years before the film adds a melancholic element.

Retrospection is an essential theme. At the beginning we see past scenes (childhood, flashbacks), mainly in humorous mode. Occasionally some past scenes are tragic, for instance WWII with an extract of the documentary "The Sorrow and the Pity", followed by the characters asking themselves: what would we have done during these troubled times?

Increasingly, past elements are not coming from "outside" of the movie (i.e. before the love story) but "within". This creates a nostalgic feeling: the happy times we witnessed are now gone.
  • When Alvy comes to Annie's place to chase the spider after they broke up, on her wall are the photos she took when he was previously struggling with the lobsters.
  • Later on, Alvy dates another woman and again tries to cook lobsters. However while the earlier lobster scene was funny, his new date does not understand his humour: we are sorry the relationship between Alvy and Annie has ended, with their complicity and wits.
  • At the end, Annie goes to see "The Sorrow and the Pity" as she did before with Alvy, even though now they are separated.


Accentuating the sense of nostalgia, the whole movie actually is a flashback made by Alvy about his relationship with Annie. Eventually, the end sequence culminates in nostalgic mood: past scenes between Alvy and Annie silently flow, while Annie sings off-screen "Seems Like Old Times", a melancholic song if there ever was one. They are now simple friends; instead of spending time together, they just have a drink in a café. In the last shot, Alvy stays on the sidewalk to watch Annie leave: he still is in love with her.

On top of flashbacks, this final sequence subtly refers to earlier episodes: a final nail in past's coffin.
  • Annie singing refers to her previously singing "It Had to be You" in the nightclub. But whereas the nightclub sequence was a noisy disaster, the final song is perfect: past scenes then shown are hence beautified and idealised.
  • Alvy makes a final joke about the absurdity of relationships: it closes the loop with his two jokes at the very beginning of the movie. However instead of facing the audience, his voice is now off-screen: without Annie, he fades into a shadow of his former self.


Funny, nostalgic, partly absurd (as life is), sometimes awkward (as life is), "Annie Hall" does deliver the eggs.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A nervous romance.
Lady_Targaryen30 March 2007
Warning: Spoilers
The movie is set in New York, as many of Woody Allen's movies. Alvy Singer is a comedian trying to maintain his relationship with his girlfriend Annie, who is a singer. The movie shows Annie's and Alvy's relationship over the years, and their ups and downs, as well as their similarities and differences.

'Annie Hall' is considered a great movie and it won numerous awards. Being referred as one of Woody Allen's best movies, I personally don't agree with it, preferring many other movies made by this great director. The movie was not even close of what I expected it to be, and I am a fan of all types of movies and genres, from all different times and years. My question is: why this movie is a classic? I don't hate it, but I don't understand why it is considered to be SO good. The only thing really positive I have to say about this movie, is that it doesn't end in a ''cute'' and predictable way, since both Annie and Alvy stay apart.
14 out of 25 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Defines Modern Romantic Comedy Genre. #4 Greatest Comedy Film 💯
Instant_Palmer13 June 2023
'Annie Hall' (1977) is the pinnacle of Woody Allen's own style of romantic comedy film-making that he refined starting with 'Play It Again Sam' five years earlier in 1972, picking up pacing and editing style cues from that film's Director Herb Ross, one of his many film making influences that included Ingmar Bergman.

Allen's most popular and endearing film, Annie Hall is a truly iconic 1970s film. At least partly autobiographical, the story integrates Allen's and Keaton's real-life off-screen love relationship (and individual neurosis) into the story. The connection with the audiences of that period was huge - Keaton's character styling even created a wildly popular fashion style "the Annie Hall Look".

Annie Hall is a "must-see" film, and sits on many Top 100 Greatest Films lists for good reason - it is Allen's greatest and most important film, #4 on my "Top 10 Greatest Comedy Films" list (1960-Present).

There is simply no comedy film Director/Screenwriter that does this narrated story telling form better in the comedy genre than Woody Allen. Frank Capra was witty and humorous, but Allen keeps the comedy on equal or greater ground than the drama (tied to complex relationships and personalities, focusing on the protagonist's inner angst).

Allen resides atop the genre he evolved and redefined for 5 decades, influencing film-makers/screen-writers like Judd Apatow, Charlie Kaufman, Wes Andersen, and the Coen Brothers, making Woody Allen one of the most influential and important film makers.

He also established the interstate highway for stand-up comics to make the jump to hyper-space of serious oscar-worthy acting, opening the flood gates for comics like Tom Hanks, Robin Williams, Michael Keaton, and many others.

Must See - Highly Recommended

👍👍
6 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A relationship, I think, is like a shark. It has to constantly move forward or it dies. And I think what we got on our hands is a dead shark.
hitchcockthelegend25 August 2012
Annie Hall is directed by Woody Allen who also stars and co-writes the screenplay with Marshall Brickman. Cast alongside Allen is Diane Keaton, Tony Roberts, Carol Kane, Paul Simon, Shelley Duvall, Christopher Walken and Colleen Dewhurst.

Alvy Singer (Allen) investigates the reasons why his relationship with Annie Hall (Keaton) failed.

It's just not for me! This film I mean. I like a lot of Woody Allen stuff, Manhattan is a big favourite, but I just can't see why Annie Hall is so revered. I recognise the major talent in Allen's armoury, his dialogue is choice and often witty, observations wry and reaction timing sometimes supreme. And I know, I do, that Annie Hall is a template of sorts that must have been seen as fresh back in 1977. But it appears to me that the film's central flaw is largely ignored on account of what has been termed as unique genius!

The relationship at the core between Annie and Alvy is just dull, hardly anything happens between them, so are we meant to care about them? Or is it just a ruse for Allen to say some jokey one-liners? Interestingly, Allen himself has stated he was far from happy with how the film turned out, even going so far as to say it's not what he envisaged, was in fact disappointed that people only focused on the Alvy and Annie relationship. This makes sense to me since that aspect of the film is only a small thread of the intended whole cranial quilt. Does that make Annie Hall a fluke? That so many people missed what Allen was aiming for? To wit! It ultimately plays out as a series of disjointed witticisms formed around Allen's neurosis. Plenty of classical moments are within, and the actors are very good in making the scenarios work, but lots of little good bits do not make a 10/10 Academy Award winning classical whole.

Yep, I'm very much in the minority, I know that, but Annie Hall's gigantic reputation bewilders me. Rest assured, though, I'm happy with that and it's unlikely I could ever sit through it again. 6/10
8 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Smug Woody Shows up More Often Than Self-Deprecating Lovable Loser Woody in This Tale of Neurotic Love
Turfseer15 January 2024
Warning: Spoilers
Before Woody Allen's recent foray into more decent films as a director, he was immersed in a series of films mainly in the '70s where he portrayed a fictional version of himself. While there were gems like "Play It Again, Sam" and "Crimes and Misdemeanors," "Annie Hall" epitomizes Woody's penchant for blending stand-up comedy with a dubious film narrative, stringing hit-or-miss one-liners throughout.

The central intrigue revolves around which Woody will emerge - the neurotic, self-deprecating, lovable loser, and witty social critic, or the smug elitist who belittles straw men while grappling with his own hostility towards women. The recurring joke about not belonging to a club that would accept him hints at the underlying issues jeopardizing his relationships.

A flashback featuring Woody as a precocious child predicting the planet's doom stands out as a classic moment. In this scene, Woody's youthful insight into the expanding universe's ominous future is met with his mother's myopic response: "What business is that of ours?" This exchange captures a comedic yet poignant reflection on the generational gap and the triviality with which some view significant matters. However, when schoolchildren recite their future professions, it becomes condescending, comparing successful individuals (whom Woody clearly looks down on) with drug addicts, fetishists, and even orthodox Jews.

While Woody mocks those quick to perceive antisemitism and those enamored with celebrity, his hostility towards women, exemplified in jokes about periods, remains cringeworthy. The movie theater face-off with a pretentious professor turns absurd with the awkward cameo of Marshal McLuhan.

In a flashback featuring his first wife Allison, portrayed by Carol Kane, Woody delivers an amusing line questioning her background, probing whether she was a "NY Jewish left-wing, liberal intellectual, Central Park West, Brandeis University student who attended socialist summer camps and had a father with Ben Shahn drawings." While this showcases Woody's wit, a subsequent political rally joke takes a cheap shot, implying what he wanted to do (sexually) to his wife was what Eisenhower did to the country for eight years, crossing a line and utilizing historical context in a tasteless manner.

On a lighter note, during a rather lackluster kitchen confrontation over lobsters, Woody provides a clever line in response to the issue at hand: "Speak to them-- you speak shellfish." This quip demonstrates Woody's knack for wordplay, injecting humor into a seemingly mundane situation.

The bulk of Act 2 explores Alvy and Annie's burgeoning relationship leading to the first split up. Annie is revealed to be a less interesting, insecure character (her two "Karaoke" singing performances are particularly grating). Their relationship encounters turbulence upon cohabitation, exacerbated by Alvy's disapproval of Annie's marijuana smoking. The tension escalates as Annie harbors resentment towards Alvy's persistent insistence on taking adult education courses (and driving her crazy when he reverses himself and criticizes them). She interprets this as a suggestion that she may not meet Alvy's intellectual standards, adding a layer of discord to their evolving dynamic.

The low point in Woody's one-liners arrives with tasteless remarks about Alvy's grandmother when Alvy tells Annie that his grandmother never had time to give any presents because she was "too busy being raped by Cossacks!"

I appreciated the humor in the joke about Sylvia Plath's suicide being misinterpreted as romantic due to a female college student mentality. However, the subsequent interior thoughts subtitles failed to resonate as they were unrelated to the actual conversation taking place. This disconnect between the spoken words and the accompanying thoughts undermined the comedic impact of the scene.

As Alvy and Annie's relationship stumbles over trivial issues, Woody's standup routine proves more effective than the one-liners that populate the narrative throughout. The joke at the college campus, where Woody reveals he cheated on his metaphysical exam by staring into the soul of the student next to him, stands out as a more successful moment of humor. However, Alvy's visit to Annie's Gentile family, including a portrayal of Annie's weird brother by Christopher Walken, fails to deliver genuine laughs.

The first split occurs after the two realize they're incompatible following their respective therapy sessions. We segue into Alvy dating the Rolling Stone reporter played by Shelley Duvall. While in bed together, Alvy receives a frantic phone call from Annie, who is freaking out after finding a big spider in her bathroom. This leads to a temporary reconciliation between the two, but the scene is not funny.

At this point, the narrative loses steam even further as the couple visits California, and Annie finally drifts away, falling in with a record producer played by Paul Simon. The film reaches a wistful get-together back in New York, but by now, the laughs are few and far between.

In the '70s, Woody Allen sometime adopted an apparent unconscious, aggressive, unappetizing persona, particularly towards women. While many one-liners miss the mark, occasional moments of endearment do emerge. Tony Roberts, as Alvy's buddy, stands out as a non-cringeworthy presence in a film marked by inconsistency.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed