A Tale of Sorrow (1977) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Not Suzuki's best, but it has some interesting elements
zetes5 May 2012
After Seijun Suzuki directed what would eventually become his most popular film, Branded to Kill, Nikkatsu fired him. He successfully sued them for breach of contract, but that led him to be blacklisted from the Japanese studio system for a decade. In 1977, Shochiku hired him to make this film (more commonly known as Story of Sadness and Sorrow). It's a very odd potboiler about a sports magazine that hires a model (Yoko Shiraki) to become a professional golfer. They previously promoted a famous Olympic gymnast, but once she became too famous, she left them behind. This time, they plan on keeping their new cash cow under wraps. After winning her first tournament, Shiraki becomes an overnight sensation and gets her own television show. While riding home with her manager and lover (Yoshio Harada, who would go on to star in several of Suzuki's later films), they are involved in a hit-and-run accident. The injured woman (Kyoko Enami), Shiraki's neighbor and stalker, then blackmails her to feed vicariously off her fame. The plot, as I said, is quite odd, and not all that well told. It does pick up when Enami is introduced. This is far from Suzuki's best work, but it is, as one might expect, visually interesting (much more so than his somewhat boring Taisho trilogy, which followed directly afterward) and quite well acted. The Region 1 DVD was released in 2009 by Cinema Epoch. I only found out about it a few weeks ago (mostly because I had always known of the film as Story of Sadness and Sorrow). I almost passed it by because the reviews on Amazon are very harsh toward the DVD itself. Thankfully, the quality is far better than I had read. The biggest problem cited was that there seem to be missing subtitles. It is true, there are small handful of lines which apparently didn't get translated. I'm not sure if this was a mistake or just lousy production, but, really, it's not that bad. There are two sequences in particular with missing subtitles, and the gist of what's being said is pretty obvious. It's disappointing, sure, but, in the age of DVD, we're more than a little spoiled. Back in the VHS days, it would have been unheard of to see 95% of the lines translated. If you were even luckier, you'd be able to read those subtitles some of the time. This DVD is more than acceptable. And, most importantly, the picture looks tremendous.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Elite stuff
RegisteredKC26 August 2012
This is a magnificent piece of work. The irony is that if you're reading this, you already saw it, and if you're not reading this, you're either a non-English-speaking Japanese person, or someone else who will never hear of this film.

Suzuki is one of the best. Always challenging, always rewarding. Trademark to his wild perspective is that he's called it "Tale of Sorrow", but it's so funny and entertaining. It's weird, cool, unexpected, sexy...everything a really jaded art-wastrel is looking for.

If you liked "Kill Bill", you need to see Suzuki's "Tattooed Life".

This film is Highly Recommended. Recently viewed: Documentary "America The Beautiful", Neil Jordan's near-perfect pulp "Interview With The Vampire", lots of pornography, Cannes winner "Dogtooth", Louis CK's amazing television show.

RIP Neil Armstrong.
5 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Hishu monogatari
RaulFerreiraZem9 September 2022
My favorite Suzuki so far. The plot might seem a bit convoluted to some but to me that is one of its biggest strenghts. It feels like watching two or three very short but very good films. The first one a sports movie, the second one a really good suspenseful thriller and the third one just pure madness. The last segment of the film felt to me (who has just first watched this film in 2022) like Aronofsky's Mother but significantly better and its not even fair to compare. I always thought Seijun Suzuki was really good but in this one he is absolutely killing it. The visuals, the colors, that one tone of green (if you watched fang in the hole you know what tone im talking about), the soundtrack (and sometimes the abscence of it) the pacing, everything. Really really impressed by this one.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A Tale of Sadness and Sorrow.
morrison-dylan-fan30 August 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Seeing a 70's cinema viewing challenge taking place,I made one of my goals to be watching auteur Seijun Suzuki's credits from the decade. Keeping the Horror flick Miira no koi (1973) for Halloween,and having seen the gripping Giallo-style The Fang in the Hole (1979-also reviewed) I turned the page on the tale.

View on the film:

The lone cinema release by him in a decade spent blacklisted by the industry, (he successfully sued Nikkatsu studio for wrongful dismissal) directing auteur Seijun Suzuki reveals he has not lost his swing from the surrealist disembodied golfing opening sequence.

Expanding on a motif driven in Our Blood Will Not Forgive (1964-also reviewed), Suzuki spins the sports cars of the rich with Japanese New Wave stylisation, splashing back-screen projection in the chic open-tops,tracking a speeding car from long off in the distance wide-shots, which slam into a slow-motion of distorted screams.

Making it rather clear in the final shot his feelings about pushed into doing TV work, Suzuki gloriously takes his unique Pop-Art styling to a shimmering level of excess befitting the consumerism golfing society from the brash green pitch which Suzuki swings on with razor-sharp match-cuts, to the brightly coloured backdrops exposed in excellent long tracking shots by Suzuki dipping into the consumerism lining the walls.

Picking up a club from the Manga by Ikki Kajiwara, Suzuki's regular collaborator Atsushi Yamatoya interestingly places this adaptation between their genre creations,and the oncoming epic surreal mood-pieces.

Yamatoya superbly shaves at the Sports genre in Reiko Kashiwagi's (played with a alluring flare by Yoko Shiraki) transformation from model to sporting pro, which Yamatoya hits with a hole in one into a violently excessive socialite society, where vapid TV shows play in the background as Kashiwagi becomes increasingly submissive to losing all that had made her stand out as a individual,who has now swung into a tale of sadness.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed