Secondo Ponzio Pilato (1987) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
SECONDO PONZIO PILATO (Luigi Magni, 1987) **1/2
Bunuel197626 March 2008
The resurgence in Italian cinema of Biblical films, particularly those dealing with the times of Jesus Christ, in the late 1970s and into the 1980s – such as Pasquale Festa Campanile's IL LADRONE (1980), Ermanno Olmi's CAMMINA, CAMMINA (1981), Damiano Damiani's THE INQUIRY (1987), etc. – was an odd one and, needless to say given its title, the film under review is yet another example.

However, this is not really a philosophical meditation on those times or anything heavy like that – which one would have perhaps expected from director Magni, an expert at politically-oriented historical dramas such as NELL' ANNO DEL SIGNORE (1969) and IN THE NAME OF THE POPE KING (1977), with his own script veering uneasily between the literary and the vulgar (apart from including ample gratuitous nudity, actors incongruously adopt modern slang in their speech when they should have probably been using Latin all along – as seen in THE PASSION OF THE Christ [2004])! Rather, it's an agreeably irreverent and occasionally whimsical fictionalization of famous events (with recognizable figures such as Caiaphas, Annas, Joseph of Arimathea, and the centurion Longinus putting in sizeable appearances) and, accordingly, features a trio of stars equally adept at comedy. Magni regular Nino Manfredi is typically fine as an aging and world-weary Pontius Pilate, while perennial beauty Stefania Sandrelli is his wife Claudia – who, with Lando Buzzanca (as Pilate's lieutenant), is revealed to have been a secret admirer of Jesus; both, actually, convert to Christianity soon after the crucifixion.

For what it's worth, the film's highlights all occur during its latter half: Herod Antipas (Flavio Bocci) hilariously deconstructing the myth of his father Herod The Great's notorious massacre of the infants in his quest to eliminate Baby Jesus (coming to the logical conclusion that the victims couldn't have been more than six at the most!) – here, too, it's amusing that the voluptuous Salome' is never allowed to finish her proverbial Dance Of The Seven Veils!; Pilate's meeting with a crazed and crippled Barabbas (Roberto Herlitzka) in a prison cell – where the latter dementedly claims that it was he and not the Veronica who wiped Christ's face on the way to Golgotha!; and Pilate's own trial before Emperor Tiberius (Mario Scaccia) – for having sent to death the King of the Jews and a God to boot! – where he miraculously cures his sovereign of leprosy by covering the latter's face with Veronica's…er…Barabbas' blessed handkerchief. This is followed, at the conclusion, by Pilate himself being visited at the moment of execution by a female angel – whom he had already encountered but denied seeing in the presence of others! Italian singer/songwriter Angelo Branduardi's folksy acoustic soundtrack provides effective accompaniment to the film.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
terrible movie but good acting from Nino Manfredi
vernetto28 March 2007
I have watched this movie because I love Nino Manfredi, but I felt deeply offended by the lack of historical honesty in this movie, which reports the most fabulous inventions about the life of Jesus. Winged angels speaking to humans, Jesus ascending to the sky surrounded by a halo of light, callous roman centurions converting in a wink to the Christian faith...the most outrageous offense to history is the alleged orders of Tiberius ordering the Roman troops to slaughter the Jews because they persuaded Pilate to kill the God-Jesus. Later trial of Pilate by the Romans is never mentioned in any historical account. Miracles performed by Pilate on behalf of Jesus are a simple offense to intelligence.
2 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed