Pancho Barnes (TV Movie 1988) Poster

(1988 TV Movie)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
the Right Stuff
petershelleyau14 October 2002
Valerie Bertinelli is Florence 'Pancho' Lowe Barnes, a pioneering female aviator from Pasadena, California. Leaving an arranged marriage with Reverend Rankin Barnes (James Stephens), Pancho takes an interest in flying light planes in the 1920's, and soon rivals Amelia Earhart (Nance Williams), breaking world speed records. Pancho is hired by Howard Hughes (David Kockinis) to do stunt flying for his film Hells Angels, instigates the formation of the Motion Picture Pilots Assocation, is a WW2 Air Force Civilian Pilot Trainer, establishes the Happy Bottom Riding Club as a mess hall for pilots and ex-servicemen.

Looking thin, Bertinelli wears her long hair in buns and snoods in the 1940's rolled style but earlier it is short and triangle-shaped. Pancho's boyishness is expressed in her masculine clothing, at one point she has a cigar, and when she leaves Rankin and ships to Mexico, she disguises as a boy. This androgyny fits Bertinelli's spunky persona well, though she is framed beautifully after the death of her mother (Cynthia Harris) standing in front of red curtains wearing a black dress. We see Pancho riding a horse, driving a truck, frolicking in the sea clothed, in her wedding dress, with dirt on her face, and dancing with Gene. Bertinelli twists her mouth to show how bored she is at a Reverends wives convention that leads to her sea frolicking, but although she has multiple suitors, isn't presented as a romantic figure.

The teleplay by John Michael Hayes, based on a story by Blue Andre and David Chisholm, introduces Florence as a tomboy with `few social graces' who `everytime I put on a silk dress, it rips', defying her mother to ride in a hot air balloon. The name Pancho is given to her by Roger Shute, who befriends her on the ship to Mexico, as he sees himself as Don Quixote and thinks she is more Pancho than Sancho. Hayes has Pancho describe flying as to `dance with the angels' which makes her later rationale for quitting `I loved flying. I just didn't love myself' a huge disappointment, and a seemingly anachronistic `Get stuffed'.

The narrative gives her nothing to do once WW2 begins, apart from play barmaid, which works against Bertinelli, since she isn't the passive type, though the bars use of `hostesses' implies something that isn't revealed. There is also a morally dubious glorification of war and bombing raids as an extension of the love of flying, and thankfully evidence of the danger with several pre-war deaths and war fatalities.

Director Richard T. Heffron uses news footage of the war, subjective camera, creates laughs from Pancho's first flying lesson via the grimacing of her teacher Ben Catlin (Geoffrey Lewis), frames a car being parked with a stained glass door, and makes the image of pilots boarding their planes at sunrise in silhouette beautiful. The sentimental music score of Allyn Ferguson is used subtly, except in the I-didn't-love-myself scene where it whines melodramatically.
10 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Liked it so much I just bought it on DVD
brucebaker-679639 June 2019
I know one cementer, thought Valerie Bertinelli was wrong for the part, she didn't look tough and hard like the real Pancho Barnes , but also said he had seen the documentary with the real Pancho in it...fine that was a documentary . This one is for entertainment...Actually I saw both also and thought the documentary was fine and informative.....but I thought Valerie was great in this one and have been trying to find it for a long time, bought the VHS, then my last VHS player died, , just found it put on DVD, and ordered it for my library .........
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Excellently executed!!!
defleppardvanhalen10 May 2010
I remember seeing this film around 1988-1989, while living in Frankfurt am Main, West Germany, when I was a small kid (4-5 years old). Looking back, I always thought Valerie Bertinelli's portrayal of Pancho Barnes was excellently executed in every detail. And the aerial scenes in that film were awesome. And the backstory reveals a lot about her upbringing, how she got her nickname, etc.

Personally, I feel Pancho Barnes was always overshadowed by Amelia Earhart in some respects, but after seeing this film over 20 years ago, it gives me a lot more perspective on women flying high. I hope this film comes out on DVD in the near future, as well as a lot of Valerie's films.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Valerie Bertinelli? Really?
charweb314 November 2014
I just saw the documentary of this woman's life. Hollywood has been and always will be out of touch of real people. Pancho was, let's say "rough" in her looks and personality. Bigger than life, loved by all, DESPITE her looks! No way could the likes of Valerie Bertinelli give a portrayal that's even close to an accurate depiction of Pancho. But I guess American audiences aren't looking for accurate, just "cute".

I have nothing against Valerie, I just think this is extremely poor casting here. Kathy Bates did the voice in the documentary, and even she is not as rough as the real Pancho! I wonder if there are any Hollywood actors who could do this character justice.
2 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed