The Butcher Boy (1932) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Cute characters and smart use of music
ramon-rodriguez313 October 2011
About as much as I have interest in Oswald the Rabbit, I also developed some for Pooch the Pup. Both these characters have been featured in Walter Lantz shorts.

Pooch here is in his initial design, although he would change in the last three films. In the story, he delivers a piece of meat but the feline of the place runs off with it. The cat then puts a rope around his leg and pulls him around the house. But how Pooch ends up in that ride, the same would also happen to the cat.

The catchy musical score here was made by James Dietrich, who happens to be the same person who provided sound to those 1927 Disney Oswald shorts which were originally silent.

If there's anything that makes heroes popular, it's that they can win in the end but should have some mishaps in the middle.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Some Cats are Bad, Other "Cats" Can Be Good
DLewis20 July 2011
This 1932 Pooch the Pup entry is based on a very simple idea; Pooch gets a call from his girl -- who doesn't seem to have a name -- ordering one chicken, please. So Pooch goes to the back of his butcher shop and selects one, and understandably the chicken in question is less than cooperative in going along with the idea, but ends up in the basket. At Pooch's girl's house both Pooch and chicken face off with the pet cat, who is particularly conniving; the cat winds up running off with the chicken. Pooch's girl gets knocked out, and the cat manages to hook Pooch up to a tether that sends him careening through various household objects and down the side of a tall building. It all happens with no real rhyme or reason, and watching at least the first time can be a bit of a chore as it is hard to follow; the lack of distinctive character designs on subsidiary players in the story can make events confusing. Nevertheless, James Dietrich's score has about three exceptionally good minutes of music in it, with some hot players; without naming names, these appear to be well-known soloists though speculating as to who is something best reserved for further research.
0 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed