Belle étoile (1938) Poster

(1938)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
It's a wonderful life in France!
dbdumonteil18 March 2019
Jacques De Baroncelli was a prolific director ,active from the silent age (1916)up to post-war years ("Rocambole" 1947)."La Duchesse De Langeais"(1942) is considered his best work.

This one is a comedy.The beginning might remind some users of a famous scene of the all-time classic "it's a wonderful life" -which had still to be made in 1938-: a young man ,weary of life ,wants to throw himself into the river ;but a young girl does it at the very moment he is about to act.He saves her and a "guardian angel" welcomes him ,in the shape of a tramp ,played by the always wonderful Michel Simon.Nothing magic,nothing religious ,like in Capra's beloved work.Simply the two young people decides to live under the stars ,like their mate .The chick (Meg Lemonnier)is a wealthy banker's daughter and the boy (Jean ¨-Pierre Aumont) a poor artist ,but he is handsome whereas all the men the rich dad wanted his heir to marry were graybeards.

Dad gets out of his way to find back his precious darling;but gangsters get wind of the disappearance and demand a ransom.This is a pleasant cops and robbers comedy in which everyone ,the bad guys and the good ones all wind up in a court .
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Sleeping out in the open.
dbdumonteil25 February 2011
Warning: Spoilers
Jacques De Baroncelli was a prolific director ,active from the silent age (1916)up to post-war years ("Rocambole" 1947)."La Duchesse De Langeais"(1942) is considered his best work.

This one is a comedy.The beginning might remind some users of a famous scene of "it's wonderful life" -which had still to be made in 1938): a young man ,weary of life ,wants to throw himself into the river ;but a young girl does it at the very moment he is about to act.He saves her and a "guardian angel" welcomes him ,in the shape of a tramp ,played by the always wonderful Michel Simon.Nothing magic,nothing religious ,like in Capra's classic .Simply the two young people decides to live under the stars ,like their mate .The chick (Meg Lemonnier)is a wealthy banker's daughter and the boy (Jean ¨-Pierre Aumont) a poor artist ,but he is handsome whereas all the men the rich dad wanted his heir to marry were graybeards.

Dad gets out of his way to find back his precious darling;but gangsters get wind of the disappearance and demand a ransom.This is a pleasant cops and robbers comedy in which everyone ,the bad guys and the good ones all wind up in a court .
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed