Max Wants a Divorce (1917) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Too complex and contrived
planktonrules8 March 2012
Warning: Spoilers
This film is not an especially good Max Linder film. Much of it is because of the story. The plot is way overly complicated and the idea is just too contrived. I think keeping the story simpler would have worked better.

Max has just gotten married when he receives word that he's to inherit a fortune--provided he's NOT married. His wife hates the idea, but Max wants a divorce. He reasons that once he's gotten the money, they can remarry and live happily ever after--but she isn't quite convinced. Now you'd think they'd just get their new marriage annulled or they'd just file for a divorce but instead they plan on having Max caught in the act of committing adultery by a detective so they can divorce. But, when Max and a girlfriend are trying to get intimate, a psychiatrist and his group of ridiculously insane patients get mixed up in the situation with silly results.

The film suffers due to dopey writing. Not only does the main plot make little sense, but throwing in the psychiatrist only made things worse. His patients, even by 1917 standards, were ridiculously over the top (with one thinking he's an automobile, another thinking he's a ballerina and another running about with a butterfly net). The result is a very, very contrived film that lacks the simplicity and charm of a typical Linder film.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Max's American Debut
boblipton17 February 2009
After Charlie Chaplin left Essannay, they needed a new comedy superstar and who but Max Linder, who had been France's leading comedy movie star -- and the world's -- for ten years? So Max left Paris and came to Chicago. Here in Max's second American film, we can see him adapting his style from the realistic French style to a more American style.

The plot is simple and the complications amusing: Max stands to inherit seven million dollars if he is not married. So he tells his bride they have to get a divorce until the money comes through. In order to get a divorce, though, they need a cause, so Max arranges an assignation and for a private detective to show up. In the meantime, the apartment he has taken is at the back of an insane asylum and his wife disguises herself as the maid in order to make sure no funny business really takes place....

The entire situation is far more slapstick than Max usually indulged in, but he is certainly up to the task, behaving just as Charley Chase would a decade later in his great series for Roach. Plus Max manages to insert a few beautiful shots, including a lovely silhouette. If the series was not as successful as had been hoped, this is still a fine two-reeler.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed