Un chien qui rapporte (1932) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Prehistoric.
dbdumonteil31 July 2005
Why reviewing "un chien qui rapporte" ? Who on earth is going to read that?But why write the 12,896th comment on "the whatsisname redemption" anyway?

"Un chien qui rapporte" has in French two meanings:"a dog that fetches " and " a dog that brings in" .And in Jean Choux's work ,the title does have these two meanings.The dog fetches rich men (who bring in a lot of money) .Then he brings them back to his mistress.

And the mistress is none other than Arletty,who would become one of the biggest actresses France had ever known ,whose career would reach an unsurpassed peak ten years later with "children of the paradise" .Arletty was ahead of her time:she appears briefly topless,and in some scenes ,she does not wear any bra.(in 1931!)

Choux's film lacks tempo ,and many musical interludes get in the way.It was originally a play and the director made laudable efforts to transfer it to the screen in a cinema way(Pagnol did not do better at the time for that matter;all his movies resemble film stage productions ,which they were anyway).His dream scene is quite interesting:for that sequence,he comes back to the silent cinema technique,which was smart:most of the dreams are silent.

Best scene : the dog brings home a person with leather boots.Then the movie camera shows the face:it's a woman!Some of this lady's lines suggest she might possibly prefer women.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Both prehistoric and ahead of its time
guy-bellinger7 May 2007
This could easily be a mere product of its time, an adaptation of a successful risqué comic play as there are millions of examples but thanks to director Jean Choux, "Un Chien qui rapporte" is better than just that. First thanks, as DB Dumonteil puts it quite rightly in his comment, to the presence of Arletty in her first leading role. Tall, at ease with her body and witty, she brings a modern cool touch to her character. And also because Jean Choux is not content to film the play flatly like the majority of his colleagues at that time. He experiments throughout the film, trying his hand at strange angles, using slow motion or else paying homage to the silent era with the concierge's dream, a wonderful sequence which has nothing to do with filmed theater. His editing is also striking and the sound effects (often tied with the image editing) are inventive. Remember this was 1931 and how difficult it was to shoot a picture at the time because of the constraints of mikes, enormous spotlights and big cameras. Even if this film is no masterpiece (the subject is a bit light), Jean Choux is not a lazy director. His passion for cinema shows through and "Un chien qui rapporte deserves better than a 3.3 out of ten given by viewers who are persuaded his ridiculous-sounding name (Choux means "cabbage" in French) means he is hopeless.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Best In Breed
writers_reign17 May 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Between 1925 and 1945 Jean Choux directed some 27 films, an average of just over one per year. To the best of my knowledge these were all strictly domestic which is a great pity because he displays an inventive use of both camera and sound in this entry which dates from 1931 when, instead of being content to merely 'film' a stage play he opted to experiment with unusual (for the time) camera angles and optical trickery. This was only Arletty's second film and her first in a leading role and watching her work it is clear that she is on the verge of stardom. Choux surrounds her with some fine actors including two, Paulette Dubost and Rene Lefevre, who would also go on to enjoy distinguished careers (indeed, Dubost is still going strong at 97 and has almost 200 films to her credit) in French cinema, Lefevre as both writer (Sous le ciel de Paris) and actor. The story - a guy has a trained dog which he rents to gold-digging girls on a daily basis; the girl slips her phone number/address into the dog's collar and the dog then jumps into high-priced cars with only one (presumably loaded) occupant and refuses to leave. The driver finds the address, calls on the girl et voila! - shows that it's not only Hollywood that was creative in the 'meet-cute' department. Ultimately it's just fluff, of course, but it's French fluff so it comes complete with that old je ne sais quoi. Definitely worth seeing.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed