User Reviews

Just when I thought there wasn't anything else I could see from Old Hollywood in terms of pure weirdness, here comes THE DOGWAY MELODY, an approximately 20 minute short which spoofs THE Broadway MELODY and THE Broadway REVUEW OF 1929 in an original way. Instead of using humans or doing an animated short, dogs on puppet strings re-create scenes from these two movies using hilarious, almost crazy dialogue. One highlight is the sequences that spoof both "Mammy" from THE JAZZ SINGER" and "Singing in the Rain". Part of a series of movies called "Dogville" (not to be confused with the 2003 film DOGVILLE) that hit the theatres between 1929 - 1931.

Dog lovers will find a lot of amusement in this short subject satirizing the MGM movie "Broadway Melody." All sorts of pups are attired in costumes and hats to give a strangely weird look to their appearance which is oddly human.

The sketch actually follows the plot of the original movie and how it's done is absolutely amazing.

Still, I had the feeling when it was all over that it was a highly contrived sort of thing with some nice staging and background effects. However, I have to admit it's an oddity and comes across as more of a curio for fans able to appreciate the early shorts designed to entertain audiences between showings of the feature films.

I accidentally discovered this after it came on following a film I was watching on TCM. It's an all dog cast performing a spoof of The Broadway Melody, and it's one of the most absolutely insane things I have ever seen.

The dogs are all adorable, and one of them sounds like he was voiced by Bert Lahr! There's funny parody sequences of "Mammy" from The Jazz Singer (performed by "Al J. Olsen") and "Singin' in the Rain".

Don't miss this one. 3/5

Dogway Melody, The (1930)

** 1/2 (out of 4)

A mildly entertaining entry in MGM's Dogville series is a spoof of their THE Broadway MELODY from 1929. This time out, naturally, we have dogs spoofing that movie and for the most part the story here stays pretty close to that of the film its spoofing. This Dogville series is going to be love it or hate it but I'm somewhere in the middle as I find most of the films to be incredibly bad but at the same time they're so darn surreal and at times creepy that you can't help but watch them from start to finish in some sort of morbid fascination. I actually found this to be one of the better episodes especially if you've seen the film that they're spoofing. The spoof of Anita Page is pretty spot on and also quite funny. The highlight of the film would have to be when Al J. Olsen comes on stage to sing "Mammy". Of course, the film features a black dog just to fit in with the real actors most famous way of singing. Like most of the others, making this a two-reeler is somewhat pushing it as I'm sure the film would have moved and worked better at an eight or nine minute running time but if you're a fan of the series you'll want to check this one. If you've never seen a film from the series then you might as well start here.

This is the last thing I watched on The Broadway Melody DVD. It was co-directed by one Jules White, yes, later the producer and director of The Three Stooges shorts at Columbia, and it spoofs not only the movie it's based on but also the "Mammy" sequence from The Jazz Singer (performed by "Al J. Olsen"!) and the "Singin' in the Rain" sequence from The Hollywood Revue of 1929. Oh, and there's also a blackout sketch about a father and his best friend awaiting the birth of the wife's baby that ended the way you've probably predicted if the premise I just told was any clue. Oh, and the way those dogs either dance, play instruments, or just walk on hind legs are good for some laughs. So, yes, I highly enjoyed The Dogway Melody though I did think it probably could have ended sooner after the revue segment ended...

I happened to find this... thing... as a special feature on the DVD for The Broadway Melody. I had just watched Broadway Melody, and found myself immediately pulled into watching Dogway Melody. I was agog.

I have never seen anything like it, it was just bizarre! I just don't have the words, you really should see it for yourself. And you spend half the time watching for "how'd they do that?" For instance, at one point, there's a dog playing the cymbal; if you look, you can see that there's a big rubber band connecting the cymbals, so all they have to do is pull the dogs legs/cymbals apart, and then the rubber band pulls them back together. Still, it looked great. :) My only complaint, I thought it went on a little long for what was essentially a one-gag premise. But it was really well done. :)

I saw this short film in film school. I can say that I have never laughed so hard in all my life. The shear lunacy of what those dogs do in this film, not only acting and dressing like humans but satirizing the whole musical genre is brilliant. I highly recommend this rarely seen film to anyone who wants a laugh. However, dog lovers have to have an open mind as in the thirties, I doubt there were labour laws for the fair treatment of animals.

An MGM DOGVILLE Comedy Short Subject.

A couple of song & dance mutts try to make a hit on Dogway.

One in a series of Dogville shorts, THE DOGWAY MELODY is a hilarious spoof of MGM's Academy Award winning hit THE BROADWAY MELODY (1929), with costumed canines performing all the parts. The characters played by Charles King & Anita Page in the original film are given a doggie interpretation, as are two of Arthur Freed & Nacio Herb Brown's best tunes (‘The Broadway Melody' & ‘'You Were Meant For Me.') Highlight: A Ziegfeld-style revue complete with tableau, leggy chorines and a Jolson impersonator.

Often overlooked or neglected today, the one and two-reel short subjects were useful to the Studios as important training grounds for new or burgeoning talents, both in front & behind the camera. The dynamics for creating a successful short subject was completely different from that of a feature length film, something akin to writing a topnotch short story rather than a novel. Economical to produce in terms of both budget & schedule and capable of portraying a wide range of material, short subjects were the perfect complement to the Studios' feature films.