Max Takes a Bath (1910) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
An amusing short comedy from the man Chaplin called his "Professor"
wmorrow5916 February 2003
This is one of the most enjoyable comedies I've seen featuring Max Linder, the French film pioneer. The story, told without any explanatory titles, is easily understood, the photography is good, and, happily, surviving prints are clear and sharp. Linder himself is charming. Charlie Chaplin cited him as an important influence, and although each comedian had his own individual style one can see parallels between the two. Linder's screen persona "Max," like Chaplin's Tramp, is usually gallant towards the ladies, somewhat fussy about his grooming and appearance, and quick to retaliate when challenged. Perhaps the biggest difference between the two is that Charlie, in his early films, could be aggressive and even sadistic, while Max is generally civil towards others unless provoked. Based on his surviving films, it would appear that Max is more often a victim of circumstance than a deliberate instigator of trouble.

At any rate, as Max Takes a Bath begins our hero has just purchased an ornate bathtub, and is attempting to hail a horse-drawn cab to haul it back to his apartment building. A carriage stops for him, but, once the driver sees the big tub, the carriage moves off again: a Keatonesque moment. So Max hauls the tub home himself, on his back, like a turtle. Then he prepares to bathe, but is once more faced with difficulty: it appears that the only spigot to which he has access, bizarrely enough, is in the corridor outside his room, sticking out of the wall on a landing of the staircase. Max attempts to fill the tub one cupful at a time, but realizes that this would take too long, and therefore decides to park the tub under the spigot and bathe in the hallway.

Two points of interest: first, lest you conclude that French architects of the period must have been crazy, the corridor with the spigot is obviously a set made up of painted flats, devised for the sake of the plot. And when Linder lowers himself into the tub, no effort is made to imply total nudity -- his swim trunks are clearly visible. Still, Max's audacity seems to upset the neighbors anyhow. The situation escalates, and of course the law gets involved. If this had been a Keystone comedy made a few years later, the climax would have involved the actors racing across rooftops firing pistols, but instead the finale is fairly low key. Even so, Max Takes a Bath is clever, well-paced, and -- did I forget to mention this? -- quite funny.
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Goofy fun.
planktonrules12 January 2012
Max Linder, as another reviewer pointed out, was one of the first film comedy stars--predating Chaplain, Keaton and Lloyd. However, tastes change and his fame was far eclipsed by these three men--and today practically no one remembers him--though he was an international star in his day. Fortunately, a few of Linder's films are available to see--though the vast majority of his films have been lost to the ravages of time on nitrate film stock.

While I will readily say that this is one of the least subtle and goofiest films of Linder's I have seen, there is also a likable silly charm about it. So, if you watch it, be patient and turn off your brain and enjoy.

The film begins with Max at his doctor. He's got problems with his nerves and the doctor prescribes a regimen of cold baths (eek!). The problem is that Max lives in an apartment and doesn't have a tub. So, he gets one--but this is NOT the end of his problems. What happens next is extremely nutty but fun.

When you see the film, it's pretty obvious the sets are painted. And, when you see Max scale the side of his apartment building, it's very obvious that the camera was suspended and he and the rest were really crawling across a painted floor (this is in no way like Harold Lloyd's "Safety Last", that's for sure). But considering it's 1910, it's all still quite clever and charming. Not brilliant--but fun.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Max Takes a Bath
JoeytheBrit23 October 2011
Warning: Spoilers
Max Linder, muse of Chaplin whose film career was still a few years in the future, is here suffering from some kind of nervous tic that prompts his doctor to prescribe a daily cold bath. Max promptly purchases a bath tub, and after some trouble carrying it home, decides to immediately follow his doctor's instructions. The problem is he unaccountably doesn't have a tap in his flat and has to fetch water from the tap in the hallway. Deciding this is too lengthy a business, Max decides to take his new bath to the tap and bathe in the hallway.

This isn't one of Linder's best efforts, but neither is it his worst. It amuses, while failing to really create any laughs. It's odd how none of his neighbours seem bothered by his apparent nudity in the tub - in fact one guy doesn't even see him until he tries to climb in himself. The climax has Max scaling the side of a house with the bathtub on his back. The wall he and the pursuing police climb is obviously a painting on the floor across which the actors crawl as they pretend to climb.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Memorable Nonsense
glaulm29 March 2013
I find it so curious that people are hung up on pointing out the unrealistic aspects of this film. It was 1910, for Heaven's sake--it was never intended to reflect reality; it was intended to make people laugh. That one reviewer noted the building Linder scales with the bathtub on his back is obviously horizontal and painted is funny in itself since how many people do you know who can scale a building with a bathtub on your back?!?

While we might not be able to appreciate the humour of this film as much as an audience would have on its initial run, it remains a pleasant and very memorable short. Linder exhibits quite beautifully the kind of panache that made him the superstar Chaplin appreciated so much. If you've seen many comedies from this period, you will notice he doesn't mug as much others do, or even as much as he does in some of his other films. There is always dignity in Linder's character and it is that dignity that endures him to us today. He isn't just a clown; he's a man with issues to be resolved. Like how to take a bath without a tap in your apartment.

If you're not looking for its 'obvious' shortcomings, watching Max Takes a Bath is certainly a fine way to spend a mere ten minutes.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Take a bath yourself instead of watching this one
Horst_In_Translation8 February 2018
Warning: Spoilers
"Max prend un bain" or "May Takes a Bath" is a French 8-minute comedy short film from 1910, although I have read other years too. In any case, this one is over a century old already, around the 110-year mark in fact, and of course this makes it a black-and-white silent short film. Director is the highly prolific Lucien Nonguet and the star is Max Linder, one of the most known actors today from his era and he came before Chaplin, Keaton and Lloyd, even if he never managed their level of fame and popularity. This film here, one of his more known won't change this, even if Linder's parts are better, far better, than the scenes where the supporting cast is in the center of it all. There is one scene where you can easily see how little thought they put in this one. If we don't see Linder in the tub from our perspective doesn't mean the guy standing right above the tub looking inside won't see him either. Like seriously? Major story telling flaws here and the comedy that is funny on one or two occasions max cannot make up for these. Have to give this one a thumbs-down. Not recommended.
0 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed