"Maigret" Maigret et la vente à la bougie (TV Episode 1995) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Chance plays strange tricks.
garywhalen20 August 2023
This episode is based on Simenon's short story "Sale by Auction," one of several Maigret short stories. Normally I want things to go by the book as much as possible, but here I must commend the scriptwriter(s) for creating a delightful "locked door" murder mystery that, though it borrows the basic story line from Simenon's story, goes its own way. The characters here are much better developed than in the short story. And the plot and the "who done it" moment much more satisfying. I especially enjoyed seeing an elderly Daniel Gelin dominate the scenes he is in.

Maigret is sick and forced to stay at an inn run by a former criminal. Several men have gathered there in anticipation of bidding on a house and land in an upcoming auction. One of them is murdered, and Maigret forces everyone at the inn to re-enact their actions during the night of the murder. A few twists and turns and surprises and then the key to it all is revealed.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Murder in the inn
zutterjp4816 May 2019
Maigret has come to a small town to get informations from a the innkeeper,who hss participated in robbery some years ago.There are many guests in the inn because there will be an auction of a house (a very desired house for some secret reasons).Suddenly a guest is killed in the night.Maigret decides to maintain in the inn all the guests and the employees and begins his investigation.This situation of closed doors (huis clos in French) is very interesting and alive. Thanks to Pierre Granier-Deferre for this good film.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Watch this episode when you are feeling healthy
wjspears17 January 2021
Warning: Spoilers
This episode begins with Commissaire Maigret spending the night in a village, at a small local hotel, staying upstairs in a rented room. Maigret, beginning to come down with the flu, is awoken to a scream downstairs. Coming downstairs, in his robe and pajamas--and his unlit pipe--Maigret is confronted with a bevy of frightened hotel guests. Searching the rooms, Maigret finds that one of guests has been stabbed to death in his downstairs room.

Poor Maigret, can get no rest or any peace.

For almost the entire rest of the episode. a fevered Maigret is either downstairs in his overcoat and pajamas, interviewing annoyed guests, sitting alone puzzling over the case, or laying in bed upstairs, sipping hot toddies and sleeping!

Bruno Cremer does an excellent job playing an under-the-weather Maigret. Speaking of weather, for the whole show, the weather outside looks miserable--cold and rainy. (If you are subject to hypochondria, I recommend skipping this episode!)

The mystery itself is sort of a "locked door" mystery, with the killer having to be one of the several guests, the proprietors, or the lone maid working at the small hotel.

The show does a good job of keeping us guessing until the end, when the now healthy Maigret brings everyone downstairs, to reveal who the killer is.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Not exactly by Simenon
lucyrfisher19 October 2023
I learn from other commenters that this episode is based on the skeleton of a Simenon short story, with much fleshing out. Never mind, as a "Simenon pastiche" it works well. Loads of atmosphere as usual, with the rain unstopping outside the hotel where everybody is trapped. Maigret is probably breaking several laws by keeping the suspects, and the two corpses, on the premises. And one of the corpses won't lie down - but it's only a director's trick.

A couple of commenters have called this a "locked door" mystery, since only those inside the hotel could have dunnit. There are "locked room" mysteries, in which the corpse is found in a locked room with no other entrances. And there are "closed circle" mysteries, in which suspects are confined to a small group in an artificial setting - often an English country house. These are sometimes called "lifeboat mysteries".
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed