"Carnets d'ado" Life After All (TV Episode 2003) Poster

(TV Series)

(2003)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Summary
mclovendahl30 July 2005
Warning: Spoilers
Drama. French sensibility.

Two brothers bond after their parents are killed. Vincent (Mathieu Tribes) is eighteen, and he learns to be the older and wiser influence on little brother Lucien (Maxime Monsimier).

His confidence in the new role is bolstered by support from Jessica (Clemence Poesy) and she comforts him in dealing with his loss and new responsibility.

In the meantime, Lucien drifts into an idiosyncratic fantasy world -- in which his parents are alive.

The crisis comes when Vincent and Jessica break off their relationship, and, at the same time, Vincent must be persistent in rescuing his brother, helping Lucien orient to a less fabulous, everyday reality.

This is a good quality, reasonably well-made television drama episode ... originally made for an audience with somewhat different cultural values than might be common in the US.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Tales from the orphanage
el gato-226 July 2004
Life After All appears to be a part of a series of films entitled Tales from the Orphanage. Clearly a cheery start to any uplifting drama. To begin with, it was quite obvious that this was a TV movie, in terms of appearance and acting. Not that television doesn't produce fine movies but that this never had the appeal of a feature film. I was never convinced by the actors in this film particularly the young boy who plays the little brother. My annoyance with his character grew with each passing scene. Furthermore I just felt that the movie dragged on and caught myself on the remote with my finger over the fast forward button a couple of times. I've decided that any movie in which I desperately want to fast forward to the end cannot be a good film. I would stay away from this unless you are looking to improve upon your French or English (via the subtitles.) I'll give it a 3 out of 10.
2 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Period of Adjustment: Coping with Sudden Loss
gradyharp6 August 2005
La vie quand même (LIFE AFTER ALL) is another film in a series collectively called 'Tales from the Orphanage'. The story is simple on the surface (children coping with the sudden loss of parents), but in the hands of writer Sophie Tasma and director Olivier Péray this storyline unfolds a tale of brotherly love that is well worth watching.

The film opens with a family argument between father (Laurent Olmédo) and mother (Françoise Michaud), a scene that is apparently routine in this disturbed household. But this time the couple's two children 18-year-old Vincent (Mathieu Tribes) and 11-year-old Lucien (Maxime Monsimier) not only overhear the fight but Vincent defies his father in a stringent manner. The mother attempts to assuage the situation as the parents are leaving on a trip. But once the parents leave they are killed in an accident and the two boys are informed of the abrupt loss. Vincent loves Lucien and vows to remain his legal guardian so that Lucien will not be placed in a foster home or orphanage.

The two boys react differently to their new life without parents: 1) Vincent begins to sleep with his girlfriend Jessica (Clémence Poésy) and at the same time tries to lose his thoughts in a consignation with longtime neighbor Marion (Marianne Basler), all the while dealing with social workers, convincing them he is a fit guardian for Lucien. and 2) Lucien begins to act out his pain in antisocial behavior, following a delusional path that his parents are not only still alive but are still at home with Lucien and Vincent.

How each brother works through the guilt (Vincent) and broken spirit (Lucien) of the loss of their parents forms the line of the conclusion of the film. The power of brotherly love is palpable and manages to provide avenues of coping with tragic loss.

The film's weakness is in the pacing of the story with too much time being devoted to Vincent's escapades and insufficient development of Lucien's character and transformation. Despite these flaws this is a touching film of significant situational reactions played in a realistic manner. In French with English subtitles.

Grady Harp
17 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed