"Sherlock Holmes" The Hound of the Baskervilles: Part One (TV Episode 1968) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Hound of the Baskervilles
Scarecrow-8810 January 2010
Warning: Spoilers
I was thrilled to find a set containing television episodes of Sherlock Holmes starring Peter Cushing, Nigel Stock as Watson. It is shot as a balance between video and film, working satisfyingly well, I felt. Exteriors are shot on film, interiors containing conversations/dialogue are shot on dressed up, detailed sets. The English countryside where Sir Henry Baskerville's manor resides is used to great effect. I guess this is as close we come to seeing how Cushing might've performed in theater, as his screen time mostly derives of major exposition with Watson over matters concerning Henry's safety and a murderer wanting him dead. Interesting enough, we only see the "hell hound" once at the beginning when the tale of Sir Hugo Baskerville is being told to us, setting up this part 1 of a double header containing the Arthur Conan Doyle story. You hear it's growl off camera out in the darkness, and that in itself is enough to "chill the bones" of our characters who are privy to it's presence somewhere on the Moor. Both Parts 1 & 2 never really deviate(..unlike the Hammer version which changed quite a bit of the Conan Doyle story)from the '39 version. In Part one Holmes has Watson traveling by train with Henry Baskerville to his estate to watch after his safety. A letter was sent warning him to stay in London. Like in other adaptations, Holmes isn't a major contributing factor until near the end of the second part. In this one, he tells Watson to go in his stead, as he has urgent matters keeping him from going with Sir Henry. Meanwhile, Henry and Watson notice that the maid(..butler's wife)is in sorrow, later to be determined why. Also established is the fact that an escaped convict is loose in the Moor. Established characters include Stapleton(Philip Bond), an entomologist/naturalist enamored with the Moor who lives not far from Baskerville manor, whose sister Beryl(Gabriella Licudi)tells Watson that Sir Henry must leave or else grave consequences await him. Meanwhile, the Barrymores, servants for the late Sir Charles Baskerville, seem to be harboring a secret which relates to the convict on the loose.

This episode establishes the characters who live near Sir Henry and the threat of the hound. Watson, as we see in this and the second part, as played by Nigel Stock, is as inquisitive and direct as ever, ruffling feathers with his straight, to-the-point questions regarding Sir Charles' odd death..such as who wrote a note getting him outside at Midnight, causing the fear of the hound which in turn brings on a heart attack.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A solid Hound, effectively recreated on a low budget
Leofwine_draca1 August 2016
Warning: Spoilers
Peter Cushing starred as Sherlock Holmes in a number of BBC TV episodes in 1968 and this two-parter must rank as the best of that collaboration. THE HOUND OF THE BASKERVILLES is a splendid TV film that easily overcomes the obvious minuses in terms of budgetary limitations and a set-bound feel to the proceedings despite plenty of location shooting. Back in the '60s, everything the BBC shot looks and feels like a play, and it's almost as if scenes are taking place at a theatre and you're in the audience watching. Still, there's a combination of two factors that make this one of the finest Holmes adaptations of all: atmosphere and acting.

The quality of the acting is rather self-explanatory. Cushing is excellent as Holmes, bringing a previously unseen authenticity to the role. For me, he's up there with Rathbone as the finest of the many actors who have essayed the role over the years. Watching him here is just a reminder of his skill at the business of acting, and the only complaint is that the nature of the narrative means that Holmes himself is absent for a lot of the time. Still, we're left in the capable hands of Nigel Stock's Watson. Stock looks like Nigel Bruce but is far from the ninny that Bruce once played; his Watson can be tough and is able to reason for himself at times. A supporting cast including the exotic-looking Gabriella Licudi and the matinée idol-looking Gary Raymond don't disappoint either.

The atmosphere in this production is spot on. The sound effects of distant screams and baying hounds are suitably chilling, adding to a wonderful ambiance. Another plus is that location filming was done on Dartmoor, creating many memorable scenes. The fog-enshrouded climax is, in particular, a creepy and suspenseful set piece. Old-fashioned this may be, but I loved it to bits.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Accurate But Dull
Hitchcoc10 April 2021
This has the spirit of the story, but is a bit plodding. Of course, it's the classic story of Henry Baskerville who comes to Baskerville Hall as an heir after Charles has died. We meet the principles here and have a bit of the setup. Watson has accompanied Henry, Holmes staying behind on business. We are introduced to Stapleton and his Beryl. There is little suspense at this point. We'll see how they finish it off.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
reasonably OK but rather flat 'Hound'
didi-531 October 2007
Perhaps because it is the most known Sherlock Holmes story, 'The Hound of the Baskerville' adaptations often suffer from bringing nothing new to the tale and therefore being pedestrian, but plain. This one really is no exception.

Peter Cushing, taking over from Douglas Wilmer, and Nigel Stock portray Holmes and Watson. Both are effective and it is certainly interesting to see Cushing out of his typecasting in horror roles. Still, they are not supported well enough by the rest of the cast and so this Hound has little tension, no surprises, and very little originality. It is a shame but perhaps the definitive version of the story has yet to be filmed.
5 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A competent Doctor Watson
dtucker8613 March 2024
The Hound Of The Baskervilles is the most beloved of all the Sherlock Holmes stories. I first read it when I was in the fourth grade. The most famous version is of course the one with Basil Rathbone as Holmes. I was lucky enough to watch this version with Peter Cushing as our favorite detective. Cushing did a Holmes series of which only five episodes survive and this is one of them. Despite the fact it was obviously shot on a low budget it is very entertaining and Cushing makes for a very enjoyable Holmes (even though Jeremy Brett was shoulders above). The other thing I like about this is that they play Watson as an intelligent and able person (even though he isn't as brilliant as Holmes). In the Rathbone movies they played him as a bumbling dolt! Oh and yes Cushing gets to say "The game is afoot Watson!"
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Peter Cushing's second take on the Baskerville Hound
kevinolzak25 December 2022
When Peter Cushing took over for Douglas Wilmer in the BBC SHERLOCK HOLMES series, "The Hound of the Baskervilles" was slated as the only 2-parter of his 16 episodes, 3rd and 4th to be broadcast (Sept. 30 and Oct. 7, 1968, completed July 22). Since he had essayed the part of Holmes in Hammer's 1958 version of "Hound," the main intrigue of this presentation is seeing him navigate the well worn storyline for a second time, his frequent use of props always engaging, in particular the ever present magnifying glass. Nigel Stock returns to play Dr. Watson, less a buffoon than Nigel Bruce but not as forceful as Andre Morell, carrying on without Holmes by the midway point, Cushing not seen again until part 2. Unfortunately, the considerably lower budget is plainly obvious, and the assembled actors incapable of producing any excitement during this installment, Philip Bond as Stapleton and David Leland as Dr. Mortimer looking very much alike in their choice of eyeglasses. As Sir Henry, Gary Raymond would never make anyone forget Christopher Lee, but Gabriella Licudi at least makes for a fetching sister for Stapleton. No sight of any hound apart from a small spaniel, just occasional howls and a growl or two to break up the tedium.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed