Hilde's Journey (2004) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
What Hilde Wants, Hilde Gets
robertconnor28 July 2007
When a struggling and solitary cabinet maker learns of the death of his former lover, he is forced to reconsider his feelings and all he considers important. Is the dead man still manipulating all around him from beyond the grave?

Bitter-sweet exploration of the stages of grief, as two men, one willing, the other begrudging, accompany the deceased's ashes to scatter them on the French coast. Although the premise is simple, it is expertly handled by all concerned, led by two beautifully placed performances from and Finger and particularly Stokowski, who expertly crafts a man with such repressed and buried emotions that when the barriers are broken, the consequence is very real and very moving.

Perhaps the conclusion is a little too neat, but it's worth the ride
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Bleak Lives
bob_bear25 June 2009
Warning: Spoilers
I bought this DVD for three reasons: 1. Oliver Stokowski. 2. German Language. 3. Gay themed. Beyond that and the melancholy trailer it was a gamble with only two other reviews on IMDb and no press reviews that I'd ever seen.

All the actors involved turn in uniformly excellent performances and it is photographed with panache. But the storyline raises many more questions than it answers. Indeed, the director seems to take pleasure in not making stuff explicit --as epitomized in the reading of the letter written to Hilde's gal-pal, which is only part read before she declines to read the rest as it is "too personal". I don't mind having to work for the answers but really?!

Bleak lives and mourning the death of another gay man to AIDS. Who was this film aimed at exactly --and what was its aim? It was hardly going to have a wide appeal and it's not like we don't know this stuff already. Some insight would have been appreciated. Instead, I feel ambivalent about the whole experience of watching it.

Well made and worthy? Certainly. Enlightening? No not really. In the final analysis, the actors and the cash would have been better invested in telling a story that was positive and uplifting IMO. I'm fed up with seeing gay lives endlessly portrayed as unrelieved misery. There are other songs worth singing.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A Theme of Interlocking Tenderness
gradyharp31 October 2006
'Hildes Reise' ('Hilde's Journey') is a surprisingly tender film despite the cover art suggesting a harsh and angry young man movie. Director Christof Vorster directs this screenplay he wrote with Gabriele Strohm and gives us a story that deals with difficult issues of AIDS, parental homophobia, relationship challenges met and squandered, and the power of shared love for a departed friend that can overcome almost any barrier.

Steff (Oliver Stokowski) works in an antique shop repairing furniture and longs for a shop of his own. His credit scores are low, he is unable to secure a business loan, and his outlook is bleak. Word reaches him that his ex-lover Martin, the son of a wealthy German family (the mother played by Heidi Maria Gloesser) who continue to deny his sexual preference, has died: the family calls the cause of death cancer, but the true cause is AIDS. Steff attends the funeral and Rex (Michael Finger) a young friend of Martin (who is also affectionately known as 'Hilde') shows up distraught, raging at the family for denying that their son died of AIDS. The will is read and Martin/Hilde left his entire estate to Steff: at last here is a source of money to advance Steff's career.

Martin/Hilde also has requested that he be cremated and his ashes thrown to the sea. The mother refuses this wish, attempting to deny her son's past and ensconce him in the family mausoleum. Steff addresses the family and tells them he will accept only a fraction of the money he has inherited, sacrificing the urn of ashes to carry out Martin/Hilde's wishes. Rex kidnaps the urn and together with Steff the two set out on a journey, initially for different reasons, but ultimately for the respect of Martin/Hilde whom they both loved (Rex also has AIDS, met Martin in the hospital and spent his last year with him as a caregiver). The way in which the potentially conflicting pairing of Steff and Rex is resolved is both touching and a satisfying ending.

The cast is uniformly excellent, the photography of the German and French countryside by Hans Meier is lush and moody, and the music score by Karsten Riedel is minimal but just right for the moods of the film. Yes, this could be categorized as a gay film, but its messages are so universal and the quality of the film-making so fine that it deserves a very wide audience. In German with English subtitles. Grady Harp
6 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A nice story in a triangle of friends!
javierubio7 May 2020
The story is about 2 guys who were in a relationship with this guy who died from cancer related to AIDS and a good best girlfriend who just wanted to his last wish to spread his ashes to the Ocean.. An emotive story where real friendship really truly matters and even with the stubborn mother who just wanted to keep his ashes with her willing to give some money to avoid to lose them! Even the landscape, picture, edition and production were not so bad, it was not good enough to make this movie one of my favorites, maybe it was the acting or direction of the acting but in general delivered the message that is the most important goal in a quality movie!
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Sexy Oliver Stokowski can't salvage a truly awful movie
jm1070125 April 2013
Warning: Spoilers
I expected and wanted to like this movie, but I just couldn't. Despite a wonderful lead performance by the subtly but profoundly sexy Oliver Stokowski as Steff (in the background on the DVD cover), this movie's story and dialog are so stupid, all the characters (including Steff) are so totally and cartoonishly unbelievable (particularly Martin's Cruella de Vil mother) and all the other actors are so bad that the movie is practically unwatchable.

If it had been a comedy, its absurdity might have worked to its advantage, but it is played with such unrelentingly earnest solemnity that it sank like a stone and dragged me down with it to its preposterously sappy end. Very, very, very disappointing.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed