Le survenant (2005) Poster

(2005)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Wanderer stuns woodland village
rowmorg20 September 2005
Warning: Spoilers
Here's another of those Victorian morality tales the Quebec film industry produces to order. You've seen the farmhouse interiors in other movies. You'll recognise the town of Sorel, it's on the Montreal back-lot. The characters wear each others' costumes and utter the same rough-hewn bigotry and rustic wisdom. There's big, soaring music and they talk about The Land.

Le Survenant (The Outlander) is a creature from legend, straight out of a Scottish Border Ballad, the fairy feller who can do anything, win a farmer's hoary heart and charm the pants of all the girls. But he has his faults like anyone else and he ties one on down at the hotel once too often, until he seems to have a permanent headache. It's either the booze or the wanderlust, we're not quite sure. Anyway, it's curtains for his limping true-love as he wanders off into the mist.

There's about three hours of this (it felt like it) and they do it like masters of the craft. The dames are devoted, the men wear big hats, and a river runs through it. The last one I saw, the house burned to the ground, wiping out the old misery-guts of a husband. In this one, although his nuts must ache as the gorgeous heroine promises him anything, anything, lover-boy apologises and turns away (is he gay, or something?). It's a three-hanky job. But do they ever make a sixteen-course lunch of it. If you like to suck on a piece of hay for hours, weeping for joy or for sadness, you'll love this one.
8 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Guèvremont's book better but...
obelix_le_faf18 May 2006
This movie was quite good but the book is better. The Outlander (Le Survenant) really deliver the merchandise with a marvelous acting. If anybody read the book, they'll agree that Jean-Nicolas Verreault did a marvelous job. The problem of the movie is the psychological approach and the fact that they made from the movie, a big Love Story between Angelina and Le Survenant. In the book, it's present but it's not all about that. In fact,this is a really important book in Quebec Litterature history because it break with the Traditional Clerk society. Survenant is the symbol of a changing Quebec society that is coming : The Quiet Revolution. When Guèvremont wrote this book, she had a «happy ending» where Survenant was revealing his story. The second version kept the magic: We don't know where's Survenant is from, neither what's his secrets. We only know that he's disturbing a Traditional society, and his passage trough this town is a announcement of the Changes that are above.
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A non-lover of love movies.
simon6478 November 2006
I am certain that purists of the genre will make references to the book itself. Quite frankly, I will assume that the movie is much better when you haven't read the book, because you don't have anything to complain about. I know what it is to flame a movie because it doesn't respect a highly acclaimed work of Litterature. And when you harass Quebec people about their pride, they flame on you quite hard, even if they'll turn back seconds later because of... Nevermind. Le Survenant struck me as a wonderful love movie. The only I've ever appreciated in my whole life. A plot well-written, music to break your heart at the right moments. A musical appearance by Sylvain Cossette and characters to get attached to. If you wanna watch this, make sure you haven't read the book first. I didn't and I loved the movie.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed