Nothing Doing (1927) Poster

(1927)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Not one of the typical surviving Charley Bowers films
planktonrules20 September 2009
Warning: Spoilers
While many of Charley Bowers' films from the silent era no longer exist due to the ravages of time on nitrate film stock, most of those that remain feature him as an amazing crackpot inventor. However, this one is very much unlike these films and features the comic in a much more conventional type film--one I could have easily imagined Keaton or even Chaplin starring in instead.

The film begins with Charley being thrown out of his girlfriend's house (literally). It seems that his prospective father-in-law refuses to allow her to marry any man who isn't a cop! So, Charley goes to sign up with the police. These police have very low standards, as the only requirements to join the force are your height and weight. Poor Charley is a small guy but he comes up with a way around this (you'll have to see it for yourself). As a cop, Charley is pretty awful--making a mess of most everything.

A few things about the movie made me laugh. First, I loved the formula that the moonshiners used to make "bathtub gin". I also liked seeing the moving pictures in the room. The only problem with this scene is that part of it is missing. It started with Charley outside the house and then in the very next scene, he's inside with his police helmet dented and he appears to be under the influence. I assume the bad guys grabbed him and made him drink some of their nasty concoction--but this is only a guess.

Overall, a decent silent comedy. While it's far from Bowers' best, at least it's a nice change of pace.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Something of a Change of Pace For Bowers; Works Well Enough
Snow Leopard22 February 2005
This short comedy is something of a change of pace for Charley Bowers, in that it relies mostly on slapstick and some themes familiar from other comedies of the era, rather than his usual array of gadgetry and special camera effects. It works well enough, though, at least as long as you don't have the wrong expectations, and it has some amusing material.

The story is fairly simple, with Charley trying to become a policeman in order to win the approval of his girlfriend's father. The early part, which sets things up, is a bit slow aside from a couple of good visual gags. It hits its stride when Charley gets on the job, and there are some very good visual gags as well as some decent slapstick.

"Nothing Doing" is a much more conventional comedy than is usual for Bowers, and the same kind of story could have been made by some of the other comics of the era. But he does perfectly well at this kind of material. His character is his own, and he gives it a slightly different feel than it would have had with someone else in the role. While his calling card usually featured unusual camera effects and the like, Bowers also knew how to perform this kind of material pretty well.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed