ScaredSacred (2004) Poster

(2004)

User Reviews

Review this title
10 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Transforming the scared into the sacred
howard.schumann31 October 2005
Directed by Vancouver documentarian Velcrow Ripper, ScaredSacred looks at how people who have experienced brutal disasters during their life have been able to maintain their humanity and devote themselves to working for social change. Scared Sacred, which was voted into the Toronto International Film Group's Canada's Top Ten list in 2004, takes the viewer on a personal journey to visit some of the most troubling spots on the planet and shows that the only meaningful response to hatred is compassion. Ripper, who is also the film's narrator, explores the possibility of transforming the "scared" into the "sacred" by "breathing in" the pain and "breathing out" compassion.

Ripper visits the site of a Union Carbide pesticide plant in Bhopal, India where a gas leak (deliberately caused or not) killed 8000 people in 1984; the killing fields of Cambodia, where reminders of Khmer Rouge atrocities are everywhere; Sarajevo, where anger still haunts the survivors of the Balkan civil war. Included are visits to Hiroshima, refugee camps in Pakistan, women's schools in Afghanistan, and Israel and Palestine where survivors mourn the loss of their loved ones. Reminiscent of the documentary Promises, Ripper finds that when Israelis and Palestinians realize their common humanity, they can no longer be enemies as they tell him that "we paid the highest price possible" so "if we can talk, anyone can."

The director reveals that part way through his journey that he had "become a tourist of darkness," and that he "was filling my pockets with images while leaving my heart untouched." He pauses long enough to reflect on this in a Buddhist monastery and discovers that meditation brought him closer to the pain rather than shielding him from its reality. One of the most moving sequences is at ground zero in New York City after 9/11 where Ripper shows us a Zen teacher who says the reason tourists come to look at the ruins is not to simply stare but to "connect with their vulnerability."

Another affecting sequence is in Cambodia where Aki Ra tells how he was forced by the Khmer Rouge to lay land mines in the jungles and how his entire family was murdered without reason. Aki Ra today spends his life uncovering and disarming from 15 to 100 of the land mines each day. In Sarajevo, he interviews artists that lived on the infamous Sniper's Alley during the war and who used their art to transform the "negative energy of the war into a positive vibration of the human soul". In India, he listens as the Dalai Lama tells his followers that "the concept of war is based on the concept of 'we' and 'they'" and that the first disarmament must be internal.

Over and over, Ripper meets people to whom pain is not a trigger for revenge but an opening for spiritual advancement. A Rabbi even dares to articulate that there is a larger context for our pain even though hidden to our conscious mind. Although ScaredSacred does not probe how these events might have been prevented or who is responsible, it does provide a deeply moving response to those who despair for humanity's future. Ripper himself concludes the film with the statement that brings home the underlying theme in the film: "dread allows me to see each face as my own."
12 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Definitely worth seeing.
rheamccarroll5 November 2005
I thought this film was great, it got me thinking, and I've encouraged everyone I know to go and see it. However, I wish the filmmaker could have figured out whether he was telling his OWN story, or telling the story of his interview subjects. Either one is fascinating, but the tension/indecision was a bit frustrating while I was viewing the film.

I was most impressed with the VARIETIES of "sacredness" he discovered. There was a nice variation in the interpretations of what could be considered "sacred". I liked how he let the interview subjects speak for themselves. Not too much narration. However, this relative lack of narration did leave the viewer hanging at times. I wanted to know more about the filmmaker's personal experience.

Now I'm going to get all critical. I thought the film was a bit random. I sort of wished that he would have made it clearer when he was changing locations. A more structured approach might have been more effective. I also would have appreciated a bit of more of a synopsis of the "scary event" that happened in each location. Especially in the case of Bosnia, this would have been useful (I know I'm making myself look ignorant here). I found that the whole 9/11 issue got a lot more screen time than other locations. This annoyed me a bit, but I do understand why he did it: it's recent and it affected us all.

At times this film became about "religious responses to suffering" and things got a bit fuzzy. When you start talking about religious traditions it's hard to know where to "meet" your audience. It isn't safe to assume that the audience has knowledge of Buddhist or Hindu responses to suffering. However, it wouldn't be advisable to take up too much screen time with generalizations about religious doctrines.

Then the narrator alluded to his time with the Buddhists in the monasteries and his time with the Sufis. Footage of whirling dervishes seemed to be included for aesthetic value, which was a bit frustrating. Since the film was about responses to suffering and he said that he ended up spending time with Buddhists and Sufis, I was incredibly curious about WHY he spent time with these two groups and WHAT he got out of it! Did facing all this suffering make him more receptive to these traditions? What were their responses to his situation, or to "our" situation? I enjoyed this film. I'm glad it was made. I think the subject matter is relevant and compelling. There are scary things happening in the world and we're all coming to terms with them in our own ways. This film is a record of one man's journey. It was personal, but not too sappy. It didn't try to provide answers or easy happy endings, and that's what won me over.
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A Ray of Hope
angie1913013 March 2005
In the world today documentaries are hot. Michael Moore and others have exposed moviegoers to society's and government's frightening mores. Although I applaud these filmmakers, most of their films have only added to my personal confusion and dismay at the world I find myself living in. Velcro Ripper's thought provoking film, SacreSacred, has done just the opposite. By exploring the stories of individuals who have dealt with some of the modern world's deepest tragedies Ripper has offered much more than your average political documentary. A path through life during these difficult times feels clarified by this brilliant, yet simple film. If you're sent reeling by the evening news and are looking for a film that offers hope, despite tragedy, I highly recommend this film.
10 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
I cried.
NemoRulez25 July 2005
Warning: Spoilers
Well, what is there to say about this great piece of art? Yesterday night on a rather artistic channel I was lucky enough to be able watch this documentary from the beginning. The images alone were really worth watching it. The viewer is taken upon a journey interviewing people from all over the world who in one way or another survived tragic events. Whether it is Hiroshima, Cambodia, Israel, Afghanistan, or Ground Zero, Velcrow shows us all sides and perspectives while making us "breathe" in the pain that all those people felt and still feel. Some of those stories are just astonishingly moving. A man from Sarajewo tells us about snipers that would shoot the rhythm of their national anthem. He knew that after they repeatedly "played" their anthem for the third time they would have to recharge their weapons. Those were the seconds he used to "safely" cross the street to his home. Some of the stories are not proved to be correct or accurate but they are just amazingly great. One of which is the story of a musician who was told to neither perform nor listen to music any longer. In order to ease his sufferings he started to listen to birds sing instead. After a while his house was full of birds knowing no one could forbid him having birds in his house. This goes way beyond than what mainstream documentaries pursue. It is not only about pain and suffering it is also about life as a whole. Some of the stories are philosophical and poetic. Enjoy this great moving documentary!
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
ScaredSacred finds Hope, Beauty and Compassion in a Devastating Universal Reality
ayala-77 September 2005
ScaredSacred is a rare, beautiful, and emotionally and spiritually transforming film. It is a personal and spiritual journey, searching for light and hope amidst darkness and pain. That aside, it is beautifully filmed and edited, to tell a story of one's soul in search for understanding and redemption in its existence. The story is told as a mysterious tale and the cinematography is visually stunning and captivating.

It was personally touched by this film and it truly spoke to my heart. Having been raised in one of the "Ground Zero's" shown in the film, I found ScaredSacred surprisingly sincere and non-biased, and spiritually uplifting and transforming in a most positive and genuine way.

Velcrow Ripper's moving documentary film ScaredSacred is one of my favourite documentary films of all times.

A must see film!!!
7 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
A few touching moments in a sea of uninspired film-making.
spiralmonkey200124 January 2010
My overall feeling about this film is that it was a slow, drawn-out, structureless wander through some of the worlds genuinely unfortunate situations with a bit of redemption and an obvious message. The film is composed mostly of fairly uninteresting video footage of the countries he visits with bad reenactments, all slow-mo'ed down to a snails pace and overlaid with depressing music. Certainly some of the materials and interviews contain some compelling stories, but unlike what the description on the back suggests, it wasn't so much the victim's story that's being told as it is the director's, Mr. Ripper, and he doesn't tell it well. This film could have included longer, better interviews with the people themselves, letting them tell their stories. Instead Mr. Ripper indulgently draws the story towards himself making it some kind of personal journey, and unfortunately it doesn't end up being much of one. I never really got a sense of any growth as he explores the subject, and he never indicates what about the subject pulled him in in the first place. He just drags us from one place to the next, brushes lightly on the situation and characters, hangs around showing too much uneventful slow-motion footage of people just walking around the streets, then moves on to his next destination. He does this over, and over, and over again without any real development. I felt like this film could have been cut down to 45 minutes but it's drawn out to close to 2 crushingly slow hours. We feel morally obliged to care about the topic, but the director's self-indulgent, meandering, uninspired delivery of his journey makes you grow numb after a while.
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
See this film!!
shoehead13 July 2005
A beautiful peek into the human condition. Velcrow Ripper does an amazing job of allowing subjects to make sweeping statements and then disproving them with a single shot.

For example - while explaining to a Palestinian border guard that he is on a mission to find hope for the future while in his country. The guard replies "you will not find hope here". Boom - cut to three children laughing and sitting on their porch. The best typo ever is seen in a shot from the Kabul Afghanistan airport. A sings prohibits you from bringing in "dangerous things like gasses and passions". They obviously mean poisons but passions can be dangerous there too.

Take the trip, you won't be disappointed.
7 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Hope springs eternal
c_viewer31 December 2006
Long after the news cameras have turned away from some of recent history's "ground zeros", the effects are still present. Velcrow, brings these experiences back to us but not to dwell in the tragedies, rather to learn and celebrate the hope that springs from them. His intimate use of the camera allows us to see what is usually missed in mainstream media and his sincerity of the subject seems to transcend language and culture. His message is clear without being preachy or exploitive. The visuals and soundtrack create a moving sense of humanity that never stops and continues to flower

His compassion is what comes across and I look forward to the next two films in this (hopefully) trilogy.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Makes Farenheit 9/11 look like propaganda
natalemusic22 October 2005
You gotta see this one!

I saw it at opening night at The Carlton in Toronto. Mr. Ripper has a gentle, no B.S. way of exposing the truth, or at least his truth, about this troubled world of ours. The film is not AIMED AT any wrong-doers, it simply shows the situation, and asks us to open our hearts. His focus is on the positive, the hope, rather than on the bad guy; on what we can do right versus what they have done wrong. I prefer this to a Farenheit 9/11, where Moore, though extremely witty and brave, sometimes discards objectivity in his pursuit of a Gee Dubbya, or whoever happens to be his enemy of choice, and therefore misses the beauty of the human spirit in the face of all the world's 'ground zero' disasters.

Ripper should be thanked for telling his story, as should the many incredibly brave souls in the film who tell THEIR story.

Technically, I thought the cinematography, editing, and sound design, including the music, were highly creative.
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A wake up call for the complacent.
eastwood006 January 2006
Will this time in history be recorded as the beginning of the end for humanity? It's not impossible! History tells us so.

Our acceptance of greed, aggression and violence is unprecedented. So many children aren't even aware of an alternative to the hatred they are immersed in from birth.

Step back for a minute and think about Union Carbide's refusal to reveal the ingredients of their poison to the Doctors because it was a "trade secret". Now imagine it was your children dying, I dare you to take a few more minutes to think about it. Take your time.

Scared sacred allows you to make up your own mind while you to stare the monster right in the face.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed