(1991 TV Movie)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
exploration of the meat industry and how it affects personal and environmental health
Brook-1731 May 2006
Based on the book of the same name by John Robbins, son of the man who co-founded the Baskin-Robbins ice cream empire, Diet for a New America is a powerful exploration and expose of the negative health and environmental consequences of the meat production-and-consumption cycle, as well as the cruel treatment and suffering of animals. Growing up in a dairy family, and literally having an ice cream-shaped swimming pool in his backyard, Robbins decided to find out for himself what he and other Americans were eating and how it related to his health. Through his research, reading medical journals and interviewing doctors and others, what he learned shocked him, and will shock viewers too, perhaps even those who think they are familiar with this subject matter. This documentary is a necessary eye-opener and is recommended for everyone who eats.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Something everyone should watch
endurofsr1 July 2008
Like the book, this is something I think everyone should see. It will no doubt create some debate, but perhaps that is why it's so important for people to watch it.

As far as the previous person's comments regarding the osteoporosis connection, you are quite mistaken that there is no science that backs up the claim. In fact just about all the reputable scientific literature out there would back it up, though it might take some understanding of what is being said, since it isn't always spelled out in easy to digest bites. I learned about the way that the body handles protein metabolism as a biochemist at UC Davis (an agribusiness focused University) and while not everyone would see the writing on the wall, it's right there, in the very textbooks that any modern scientist or doctor would have to read during the course of their studies.

Evolutionary biologists, anthropologists, nutritionists, and doctors have a lot information in their. fields that are commonly accepted, but not based on scientific fact. The real challenge for me was learning what I needed to learn, while still having a seeking mind and taking the time to really learn enough to separate fact from fiction. Ironically, in my experience the conclusions were usually the ones I had previously come to using simple common sense things that I saw in nature. I find these things to be the best examples of what is right vs what is wrong with respect to "what are we supposed to eat" type questions. Looking to the animal kingdom, and our closest biological relatives, looking at our own anatomy and physiology according to common taxonomic practices, and realizing that we are not built to need meat, or dairy products at all, let alone in such high quantities, and certainly not given the costs associated with modern industrial farming practices.

I guess my point is, find out for yourself, don't fill in the blanks with what you expect or what you want to find, but seek real answers. If you don't find them, keep searching, but please don't be blinded by the corporate sponsored BS that supports the business that is medicine, and industrial agriculture.
9 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A Must See
judithkays-677958 May 2017
Too bad no one listened thirty years ago. Watch for free on YouTube. Still an eye-opener. The statistics are probably worse now than they were then, but the underlying premise of eating less meat is still valid. I urge you to watch this video and share it with your relatives, friends, neighbors and anyone who will listen. There is time to change your life and help others change their lives. Animals are treated terribly in factory farm environments. If you eat meat or dairy only two or three times a week is better for you than eating it three times a day.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Stupidest movie I was ever forced to watch in a class
merlymerly12 March 2008
Warning: Spoilers
This has got to be the stupidest movie I have ever had to watch in the classroom. The declared message is "eat less meat", but what is really meant is "eat no meat". The "Diet for a New America" goes on and on about the evils of animal protein but offers no alternatives. This movie exhibits an obvious bias against the cattle industry. I agree that there are problems with America's agricultural system, but the problem is with the American government, not the cattle farmers. The movie also mentions that the consumption of animal protein causes osteoporosis. There are no conclusive studies that this is fact. I can't find anything nice to say about this movie at all.
2 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed