The Stephens' quiet Thanksgiving dinner for three turns into four with the unexpected arrival of Aunt Clara. Reminiscing about the first Thanksgiving, Aunt Clara decides she'd rather spend it with her friends who settled in Plymouth. Her incantation to get herself there unexpectedly takes everyone else in her vicinity there also: Samantha, Darrin, Tabitha, and Gladys Kravitz, who had just dropped by. But getting home could be more difficult: Aunt Clara zapped them to Plymouth just in time for the very first Thanksgiving Day. Luckily, Mrs. Kravitz believes it's all a dream. As Aunt Clara tries to remember the incantation to get them home, the others get caught up in celebrating the first Thanksgiving with Miles Standish and John Alden. But Darrin is concerned about the anti-witch talk among some of the menfolk.
—Huggo