"The Big Valley" Presumed Dead (TV Episode 1968) Poster

(TV Series)

(1968)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Lew Ayres and Barbara Stanwyck team up in this nice episode
kfo949414 November 2012
Let me first start this out by saying that we all knew this was coming. Each season someone in the Barkley clan has amnesia.

This time it will be matriarch of the clan, Victoria, that is involved in a stagecoach wreck that leaves her unconscious. She is picked up by Jason Fleet (Lew Ayres) which obviously has a criminal background and taken back to a cabin that is occupied by two other characters with poor moral values.

When Victoria awakens she has lost her memory. Jason comes up with a plan to make Victoria believe that she is Hessie Fleet (his dead wife). Even with Victoria still asking questions about her life, Jason does everything possible to make Victoria believe that she is actually his wife. Including the fact that he and the other two are cattle rustlers.

As with every amnesia episode it will only be a matter of time before memory is restored. And with the restored memory comes sadness for some and joy for others. And this episode is no different.

Lew Ayres and Barbara Stanwyck work great together in this sad but entertaining show. As a person that cannot stand when the writers resort to shortcuts by means of amnesia- I will say that this episode was the exception. Perhaps it was because of Stanwyck and a Ayres.
17 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Sweet and Lovely
summerfields15 April 2010
Warning: Spoilers
A very nice episode which offers the unique Lew Ayres as a romantically involved with Victoria setting with a catch: Ms Barkley has amnesia this time.

The chemistry between Ayres and Stanwyck is fine: they're two old pros doing what they do best: act.

The allegory of having a certain type of hairbrush was cute (cannot remember - pine bristles?) It's great seeing Barbara playing along with such a group of talented co-stars with the stature of say Mr. Ayres.

As an exciting episode, it's only fair: what makes this one work is the heart-felt chemistry between the leads.

Quite good and a bit off the path.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Lew Ayres helps this one out
mlbroberts4 April 2021
Another BV episode echoing an earlier episode. In Season 2, we had Jarrod (The Man from Nowhere) suffering from amnesia and getting involved with a woman who wants him to stay, so she doesn't tell him who he is when she finds out. Here we have Victoria with a man who wants her to be his lost wife so he doesn't tell her she's not. As is usually the case, the replay is not as good as the first go round - The Man From Nowhere is better written and plotted and Sheree North and Richard Long were great together. But this episode has Lew Ayres together with Barbara Stanwyck. Definitely a good casting move, just not as good an episode.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Love this episode
karmakafebargain30 May 2021
The acting in this is just great. Of course The Big Valley is my favorite show of all time, just loving Barbara Stanwyck. Also love Lou Ayers and Gavin MacLeod as guest stars in this.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
a laff riot
grizzledgeezer15 September 2013
Warning: Spoilers
Inasmuch as general amnesia is uncommon -- to the point of virtual non-existence -- its use has to be presumed the result of the writers not having any good story ideas.

In fairness to this particular episode, it's handled fairly well, with Miss Barbara Stanwyck accepting Lew Ayres' claim that she's his wife. She comes out of her amnesia fairly quickly, prompted by a photo in her locket (rather than some sudden shock).

Though the amnesia plot dooms this episode to a low rating, what pushes it down to a 3 is the opening sequence. Riding back to Stockton, the stage coach's bar cracks, subjecting the driver to a lethal bellyflop worthy of Yakima Canutt. (The same sequence is used in "Gunsmoke" 17.1, "The Lost".) Naturally, the stage coach plunges over the side of a carelessly positioned cliff. This is so -- shall we say -- over the top, that I couldn't stop laughing.

That isn't all. Rather than being crippled, mutilated, and/or killed (as anyone in such an accident should have been), Miss Barbara Stanwyck is thrown clear, landing in what can only be described as a leg-cocked cheesecake pose, her bodily injuries indicated by a schmeer makeup on her temple.

In terms of simple entertainment value, these are the high points. The rest of the show can only go downhill (sorry!) from there. And it does.
7 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed