There is a 4.2% chance of monkeyface Gideon showing any human emotion this episode.
Having the gasoline magically leap up on the first student, covering him from head to toe doesn't make sense.
Having the second student fan the fire instead of smothering it was also nonsense.
Gideon waits until the very last moment before telling the team: no badges. Try not to look official.
Using a road flare to light flammable liquids doesn't make sense.
Gideon, with his vast knowledge, should know that to successfully fight a fire attacking the base of the fire is the preferred method. Spraying at random is a waste of chemical.
The team knows where the Karen phone call originated but there is no effort to collect fingerprints.
The original film that Reid is so interested in shows the doorknob is out of frame at 05:57 so Reid couldn't possibly know is was turned three times.
It would take crazy strong fingernails to pry open elevator doors.