- Shopkeeper: Only you, Carly Beth. You're the only one that ever wanted them, the only one who ever loved them.
- Carly Beth Caldwell: No! No! I want it off! I want it off, now! Take it off me! I hate this stupid face! I hate it! I hate it!
- Shopkeeper: Carly Beth, I'm sorry, but this face is your face now.
- [first lines]
- R.L. Stine: Hello. I'm R.L. Stine. I write the Goosebumps books. In a few minutes, you're going to see one of my favorite stories come alive. "The Haunted Mask" is a frightening Halloween story about a girl named Carly Beth. The horror begins when Carly Beth puts on the evil, haunted mask. And it ends when she discovers there is nothing more powerful than the love of her family and friends. What's so scary about that? You'll see. Viewers beware, you're in for a scare.
- Sabrina: [Storming off after Chuck and Steve's prank] Carly Beth, slow down!
- Carly Beth Caldwell: [Crying a little] Why? So you can laugh at me some more?
- Sabrina: I swear, I had nothing to do with that.
- Carly Beth Caldwell: Yeah, right!
- Sabrina: You know, I'd never hurt you.
- Carly Beth Caldwell: [Coming to her senses, while Chuck and Steve are still laughing as they leave the scene] I know.
- Sabrina: Chuck and Steve, they're sickos, you know that.
- Carly Beth Caldwell: I can't believe they followed us all this way just to scare us like that.
- Sabrina: They're creeps, they have no life.
- Carly Beth Caldwell: Last weekend at your house, they pretended they were prowlers.
- [Sabrina starts to smile a little]
- Carly Beth Caldwell: That wasn't funny.
- Sabrina: Mmm... Sorry.
- Carly Beth Caldwell: Last summer, they put that dead octopus on me. They're always pulling stuff like that.
- Sabrina: I'm sorry they scared you, I really am. It was a mean and stupid joke.
- Carly Beth Caldwell: I know your sorry, it's just... they don't do this to anyone else but me, Sabrina. Why me?
- Sabrina: [as Carly Beth puts her head on Sabrina's shoulder] Don't be mad, Carly Beth. It's just... it's just you're so scare-able. That's all.
- Carly Beth Caldwell: [Taking her head off of Sabrina's shoulder] I am not! Come on, that's not fair!
- Sabrina: Carly Beth, come on.
- Carly Beth Caldwell: [She stammers over her words] Well, I might be afraid sometimes-...
- Carly Beth Caldwell: Everyone knows you're afraid of everything.
- Carly Beth Caldwell: [after a short silence] Okay... I don't like be scared, I don't like being afraid, alright?
- Sabrina: Carly Beth.
- Carly Beth Caldwell: Maybe, someday, they'll know how it feels.
- [She walks away]
- Sabrina: You didn't get your pumpkin.
- [last lines]
- R.L. Stine: Now that wasn't too scary, was it? Let's ask my family. Mom, Dad, what did you think?
- [the camera pans over to his parents who have shocked expressions and crazy hair]
- R.L. Stine: I think they liked it. I hope you did, too. Have a scary day, everyone!
- Carly Beth Caldwell: [Trying to take the mask off] The mask...it won't come off.
- Sabrina: Really? Can't get it off?
- Carly Beth Caldwell: It's like it's stuck to my skin.