User Reviews

For the past ten episodes 'Gunsmoke' has dealt with some serious and powerful issues within the plot of the story. This episode takes a break from the serious side and features a more comedy centered theme.

The story centers around a family of hillbillies with the last name Cathcart. The family consist of the father and two sons Sweet Billy and Orkey. Sweet Billy is set for marriage which would leave Orkey as the only Cathcart boy not to be married. So with a little help from Pa, Orkey makes his way to Dodge to find a woman.

Orkey picks out Ms Kitty to be his wife. Of course this is rejected by Kitty and Sam has to throw Orkey out of the Long Branch. But since Pa said that Ms Kitty must be shy, the three Cathcart's decide to kidnap Ms Kitty until she grows to love Orkey. So Ms Kitty is held hostage inside the Cathcart shack well outside of Dodge.

Meanwhile Matt and Chester are trying their best to find the whereabouts of Ms Kitty. While Doc is trying to prevent a cholera epidemic from taking hold around Dodge. But it will not be long until cholera takes hold at the Cathcart shack. And with the sickness a new purpose of life.

The writer did go somewhat overboard with trying to make the script comical - but the sad thing is that it was not needed. The show, in its own way, was a sweet tale of priorities of life. Nice Watch.

The Cathcart family--Pa, Orkey, and Sweet Billy--are mountain folk (Sam the bartender thinks they are probably from Tennessee) that have moved somewhere not too far from Dodge City. The Cathcarts are facing a bit of a problem: Sweet Billy and another local girl have fallen in love and want to marry, but "the Cathcarts marry in line." That is, Orkey, being the older brother, must marry before Sweet Billy. Since there aren't any women anywhere around for Orkey, Pa instructs him to take the mule and "look a-purpose" for a woman to marry.

Orkey travels to Dodge City and fairly quickly sees Miss Kitty in the Long Branch Saloon. When he tells Miss Kitty he is planning to marry her, she first thinks it is a joke. When she and Sam realize Orkey is dead serious, Sam throws Orkey out onto the street and tells him not to return.

Not to be deterred, Pa decides he, Orkey, and Sweet Billy will return to Dodge and abduct Miss Kitty. Thus, our story. While Matt and Chester are searching for Miss Kitty, the Cathcarts are doing everything they can to convince Kitty she must marry Orkey. There is an additional side story involving cholera spreading through the area. (It is worth noting that cholera is normally spread through contaminated water, not through contact with an infected person as this story seems to imply.)

I can understand one of the other reviews that criticized this episode for viewing kidnapping as an amusement. However, there is nothing malicious in the Cathcart men's actions. Obviously, they see nothing wrong with treating women the way they treat Kitty. In their culture, a man chooses a woman, and even if she doesn't initially view this as a positive, they believe she will eventually come around to the man's way of thinking. Such thinking is definitely outrageous in more modern, developed cultures. But despite their wrongheaded view of male-female relationships, the Cathcarts are caring, kind--albeit peculiar--people.

There are several notable things about this episode:

• The episode was directed by Dennis Weaver, the last of four Gunsmoke episodes he directed.
• Kathleen Hite named this episode as a particular favorite of the episodes she wrote.
• The very recognizable Don Dubbins plays Orkey Cathcart. This character is a stark contrast to the Ed Potts character he played just a few episodes earlier in the season in "Milly."
• A very young Warren Oates is great here in the role of Sweet Billy.
• The veteran actor and musician Taylor McPeters, aka Cactus Mack, is wonderful in the role of Pa. McPeters was actually Glenn Strange's (Sam Noonan) and cowboy actor Rex Allen's cousin. McPeters appeared in many Gunsmoke episodes, as well as other westerns of the period, but he was usually only credited as a "townsman." McPeters was injured during the filming of this episode. He required abdominal surgery as a result. This was his last appearance on Gunsmoke, as he died of a heart attack while filming The Ugly American with Marlon Brando a few months later.

This episode is a particular favorite of mine. I enjoy getting to know the Cathcarts every time I see it.

Of all attempts at this type of storyline I have ever seen, this is by far the most realistic in recreating the American Mountain people or hillbillies as they were known during 20th century references. Without speaking to the plot I have to give Dennis Weaver great praise for his directing in this masterpiece of true Americana. Having had come from a childhood that was exposed to the very people this episode is based on I am taken back with such an accurate interpretation and superb performance. 19th century hill people are an extinct blend of what became of free living Americans before the establishment of necessary social systems that provide education and middle class goal setting.

After viewing this storyline you will no doubt be reminded of other attempts at explaining a logical conclusion but with various situation set-ups provided for humor and entertainment but Dennis Weaver obviously did his homework and maintained an artistic yet documentary feel to this memorable episode.

One of my favorite episodes of the non-serious episodes. Don Dubbins is excellent.

Yet another variant on the yokel-kidnaps-himself-a-bride plot, this one is typical, trying to be funny but not succeeding; there just isn't much that's funny about being kidnapped. The little lady's oh-so-feminine shrieks of dismay, the kidnapper-swain's indulgent certainty that she's just playing hard to get--it's all standard and all unfunny. A sentimental turn at the lame climax of the story, done to soften up the viewer so that he won't want to see the kidnappers punished, seems forced and is unconvincing. A couple of errors against continuity also bothered me. Kitty is kidnapped wearing the sort of evening garb, complete with dangling earrings and pinned-up hair, that she would have worn in the saloon; after a day or two she is seen in the kidnappers' cabin wearing a pretty but modest daytime dress of the sort a prosperous settler's wife would have worn. Did the kidnappers wait while she packed? It didn't appear so at the time. Also, Doc is shown burning the personal effects of a cholera victim to thwart the spread of the disease; he takes no such precautions when someone else later succumbs to cholera in his presence. Seems like sloppy storytelling in a series I don't associate with sloppiness.

I don't like being a downer but, for me anyway, this episode was a misfire. Let's put it this way...one bonk early on from Miss Kitty with a frying pan over the head of any one of these hill people would've reduced the show to 10 minutes at best.

Maybe they did, but if they're as ignorant as presented in Gunsmoke over the years, I don't know how they could have gone to Dodge City from the hill country.