"Gunsmoke" The Cage (TV Episode 1970) Poster

(TV Series)

(1970)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
3/10
The story was not bad- Problem was with writing
kfo949419 August 2013
This episode started out in an interesting way with two brothers in a prisoner wagon. Then the story went left when it ended up in Southern New Mexico as Matt is looking for a gang of gold robbers. The story was not really bad it was the fact that the writers threw in a love story on top of an unbelievable storyline.

This complicated story begins when Matt and Festus find a prisoner wagon where all the guards have been killed. However inside are Roy and Luke Stewart brothers that was part of the gang that was stealing gold. Matt finds out that the gang the Stewart boys rode with wants to make sure they do not talk and jumps the wagon thinking they have killed everyone including the Stewarts. But Roy survives and now is ready to turn evidence against his old gang.

Here is when the episode turns from interesting to unbelievable. Roy tells Marshal Dillon that the gangs hideout is in southern New Mexico. So the next day Matt, Festus, Newly and Roy set out to get the bandits and the gold. On horseback this would have been near a ten day hard ride. Why did they need the entire law enforcement division from Dodge City taking near a whole month away from Dodge while chasing bandits in far away lands? And then Matt agrees to let Roy handle finding the gold, even though the outlaws have already tried to kill him once before. It did not make sense.

Now throw in a side-plot about Roy and a relationship with a young mute Mexican woman and you have a story that loses interest at a high rate. And the sad part is that the love story was more interesting than finding the gold or outlaws.

There is a lot of things wrong with the story. Even trying to tell who Roy was really after was sometimes confusing since there were like two main bosses or two gangs- I really never knew. The only bright spot was when Festus had dialog with Burke and Newly. When Festus drank Burke's beer (not seen in heavy edited episodes) or when Newly and Festus are talking about learning a foreign language- both of these scenes were actually very funny. But that was the exception rather than the norm.
15 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Season 15 Ends on a Flat Note
wdavidreynolds6 July 2021
Brothers Luke and Roy Stewart are locked in a prison wagon. Luke is dying, but both men are in a desperate situation as the ground around the wagon is littered with dead deputies and no one else is around to help. Roy spends his time trying to make Luke as comfortable as possible while yelling at the vultures attempting to feed on the dead bodies.

The sheriff in Hays had wired Matt Dillon to expect the prison wagon. When the wagon did not arrive as expected. Matt and Festus Haggen go to investigate. They eventually arrive at the site where the wagon is located and release the brothers from the wagon. Luke soon succumbs to his injuries. The Marshal takes Roy into custody.

Luke and Roy were part of a gang led by a man named Benson. The gang had robbed a train. Although Luke insists Roy was not part of the robbery, he and Luke were apparently captured after the robbery. Benson and the other gang members attacked the prison wagon, killed the guards, fired shots into the wagon, and left the brothers for dead.

Back in Dodge City, Roy reluctantly agrees to cooperate with Matt and reveals the outlaws that ambushed the prison wagon are headed to New Mexico to sell the gold from the train robbery to a man named Sanders. Marshal Dillon, Newly O'Brien and Festus set out on the long journey to the village in New Mexico with Roy guiding them.

When they arrive near the village where Sanders is located, the Marshal allows Roy to ride on into the village while he, Festus, and Newly camp outside the village.

To further complicate the situation, Roy is in love with a mute woman named Maria that lives in the same village. Roy is conflicted between his love and devotion to Maria, his desire to build a future with her, and his lust for revenge against Benson and the other gang members. Roy concocts a scheme to resolve everything the way he wants.

Several actors make their only Gunsmoke appearance with this story. Steve Carlson plays Roy Stewart. Paul Stewart is Sanders. Laura Figueroa portrays Maria.

Other contributors include Gunsmoke veterans Gregg Palmer as Benson; Ken Mayer as Blake; Hank Brandt, who had recently appeared in the "Morgan" episode, as Luke Stewart; and Allen Jaffe as one of goons that works for Sanders.

Season 15 certainly had its fair share of bad episodes. The ratio of poor to good leaned heavily on the side of poor. This final Season 15 entry is not one of the better efforts. The performances are fine, and the idea is not bad. However, the story as shown is a convoluted mess. There are too many unexplained elements in the story.

Why did Benson and the gang attack the deputies and the prison wagon? It is implied they did it to prevent Luke and Roy from revealing their identities and their destination, but it is never made clear. If it was so important to make sure Luke and Roy were killed, why didn't the gang make sure the job was complete? Why wouldn't they have killed the deputies, freed Luke and Roy, and made the original gang whole again?

The idea that a U. S. Marshal based in Kansas would travel to New Mexico in pursuit of outlaws makes little sense. Taking the entirety of Dodge City's law enforcement with him makes even less sense. (It is not unusual for Matt to travel long distances as part of his job duties, but taking both Festus and Newly with him is.)

Furthermore, it is unclear exactly why Festus and Newly were needed on this long trek from Dodge City. Except for the shootout scene with Benson's gang, they serve little purpose, and they inexplicably completely disappear by the final scenes.

With this story, Season 15 ends on a flat note.
5 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed