"McCloud" Fifth Man in a String Quartet (TV Episode 1972) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Classical Music, Mystery & Murder
profh-130 October 2012
Warning: Spoilers
A concert conductor is stabbed in an alley. A student of his, who had a crush on his daughter, just happens by and is accused of the killing. As McCloud investigates, he finds wildly divergent descriptions of the suspect in custody. His landlord calls him a weirdo, the lawyer helping raise funds for a music conservatory says he was potentially dangerous, but all his friends say he was utterly focused on his music and incapable of hurting a fly.

But as his investigation continues, McCloud finds something far more twisted was going on behind the scenes, involving a (supposedly) reformed mobster who's up for the job of harbor commissioner; his lawyer who (coincidentally?) is the one helping to keep the music conservatory open with "anonymous" donations, and who happens to be dating the murdered man's daughter; and how the murder was really meant to bring the conductor's brother, who's been on the run from the mob since he witnessed a hit years ago, out of hiding. (It somewhat blew my mind when this dawned on me, about a third of the way into the story.) McCloud gets somewhat reluctant help from the suspect's friends, the other 3 members of his string quartet, who all work at a deli.

As usual for this show, the cast includes an interesting assemblage of known actors and future familiar faces. This time around there's Rick Weaver (Dennis' son) is "Louis Brocco", the shy, sensitive violin player conned into being in the wrong place at the wrong time, just so he could catch a glimpse of the girl he admires. Gary Collins (THE SIXTH SENSE) is "Kevin Mallory", the "helpful" lawyer whose boss pushes him to commit murder. Neville Brand (THE UNTOUCHABLES' own Al Capone) is "Fred Schultke", the crook-turned-politico who no doubt sees the job as harbor commissioner as an open door to controlling all the narcotics coming into the city for his own profit. Alex Henteloff (the sleaze-ball attorney "Arnold Ripner" in 8 episodes of BARNEY MILLER), Richard Haydn (AND THEN THERE WERE NONE, THE SOUND OF MUSIC) and Avery Schreiber (MY MOTHER THE CAR) are the 3 musicians who wind up helping Sam clear their friend of the murder charge. Shelly Fabares (THE PRACTICE, ONE DAY AT A TIME, COACH) is "Natalie Rudell", daughter of the murdered man. Timothy Carey (HEAD, THE NEW MIKE HAMMER) is the "Apartment Manager" who paints a bad image of the murder suspect, then surprisingly seems to make a pass at McCloud (who departs rather nervously). Lilia Skala (LILIES OF THE FIELD, GREEN ACRES) is "Eugenia Rudell", the conductor's wife, who proves the be the most outspoken defender of Louis Brocco, McCloud's staunch ally and perhaps the most interesting character in the story. Dick Miller (THE PREMATURE BURIAL, ROCK & ROLL HIGH SCHOOL) is the hit-man in the "green hat". Finally, Joseph Wiseman (DR. NO, CRIME STORY) is "Paul Rudell", who is shocked and cannot believe his brother could have been killed for the reason McCloud suggests (until he finds out that's exactly the truth).

This story continues to steer slowly back toward the style of the 1st season, with more action to balance out the long stretches of mystery and character scenes.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
this time McCloud is in action
trashgang13 October 2012
Was I surprised to see McCloud in this episode. The story looked great and our friend do things we aren't used to see. McCloud is running a lot here and he actually jumps on his victims, something I haven't seen before, but not only that. He also has a small fight and he's chasing a car with his police vehicle. Sadly in the chase it's clearly to see that they aren't wearing safety belts.

All over season two we see less of McCloud's boss. Still when he's confronted by him it's fun to watch. The script did remind me of another episode (The Disposal Man) in season two where a father rules over his son and even family. Nevertheless it's still worth watching, this time with a lot of action by the man himself.

Gore 0/5 Nudity 0/5 Effects 2/5 Story 3/5 Comedy 0/5
4 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Way too neat
bkoganbing18 May 2015
Dennis Weaver's son Rick is one of the cast in this McCloud story and nearly steals the show from a gang of character players any one of whom is a scene stealer in their own right.

Young Weaver is a socially backward kid who is a violin prodigy taught by master violinist Joseph Wiseman and who has a huge crush on the maestro's granddaughter Shelley Fabares. He's set up for the maestro's murder, but the package is way too neat for Marshal Sam McCloud.

Wiseman the maestro hasn't any enemies, but he's got a twin brother who rackets boss Neville Brand thinks he saw Brand do a murder personally. That's the crux of the story here. Brand has even given some big money to violinist Wiseman's conservatory. It's all part of a campaign to dry clean and spit shine his background. He's even got himself a white shoe lawyer in Gary Collins whom he succeeds in turning into both a gangster and a cad as Collins romances Fabares as part of the story.

This plot does get a bit hairy though because Rick Weaver to put it plain and simple is a stalker. But we didn't use that term way back in those days.

A nice cast makes this McCloud story acceptable, but barely.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed