A Catholic priest is infatuated with a woman who comes to confession regularly. This week, the woman says she wants to commit suicide. She disappears before he can catch up with her so he decides to go to Blue Moon Investigations to ask them to find her. They manage to find her but are in a dilemma about whether to tell the priest as she is married. Shortly after they tell him, she apparently commits suicide. When Maddie proves that suicide was impossible, it is up to Maddie and David to find out what actually happened.
—jem