"Perry Mason" The Case of the Dead Ringer (TV Episode 1966) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
18 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Dueling Burrs
zsenorsock9 September 2008
Warning: Spoilers
When the producers of a long running show learn they are about to be canceled, sometimes they just phone it in. Other times, they free themselves to have fun. This may not be the best episode in the Mason canon, but it is fun.

The story involves a patent case Mason is trying in court for the lovely Barbara (Indus Arthur, who has haunting good looks). The case is in trouble and soon we see Perry smoking a cheap cigar handing instructions and $10,000 in an envelope to a key witness, Sandra Dunkel (Arlene Martel, memorable as Spock's bride T'Pring in "Amok Time" on "Star Trek"). Nervous and upset, Dunkel confesses she's lying on the stand and points to Perry as the man who tried to bribe her. Perry loses the case (though he immediately appeals) and his reputation is suspect. When the man who won the patent case is found dead, Barbara becomes the prime suspect and Perry has to defend her while clearing his own reputation.

Burr is wonderful as Grimes, the man hired to pretend he's Mason. He creates a very colorful and fun character, something that must have been much more fun to play than the proper Perry Mason. The split screen effect is very good as Burr cross examines himself on the stand, and the dialog between Mason and Grimes about playacting and they are the only two real men here is full of double meaning.

The mystery is pretty good too, but it really takes a back seat to this show by Burr.
36 out of 38 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Was a surprising well acted show.
kfo94948 February 2013
When I first saw that Raymond Burr was going to play two characters in this show, I thought that the writers had run out of scripts and was using anything off the floor. But this was actually a very fine episode and a nice mystery.

The episode begins with Perry in civil court representing Barbara Kramer in a patent suit against Otis Swanson. When one of the witnesses advise that Perry Mason had given her money and a list of answers to questions it appeared poor for Perry. In fact, there are witnesses that testify that they saw Perry give the witness an envelope inside a hotel lobby.

But what has happened is that people from the other side of the lawsuit have found an old sailor that looks much like Perry. They use make-up and hair-dye and sure enough the person named Grimes looks just like Perry Mason.

After Perry loses the civil case, Perry has to appeal. In the meantime, his client, Barbara, is found inside Otis Swanson's home next to his dead body. Now Perry will have to defend her in criminal court for a charge of murder. Perry will need a lot of help from Paul Drake's private detective team if he wants his client released of the charge.

I really have never like those two character episodes, especially when it involves the main character. Most of the time the show is just so unbelievable that it makes no sense. This show proved me wrong. Raymond Burr was believable as he separated both parts with fine acting. Instead of the stuffy lawyer type, he became a rough and salty sailor. The mystery was interesting and the characters interesting. Good watch.
40 out of 43 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Raymond Burr, Shakespearean
madden-221 June 2013
Warning: Spoilers
SPOILER ALERTS THROUGHOUT.

All right. A bad guy hires a look-alike seaman to impersonate Perry Mason and implicate him in a nefarious scheme. Perry unravels it. You don't have to know more about the plot.

Burr, of course, plays both roles. Since Perry is such a stiff, he lets loose with everything in his acting repertoire when playing the impostor. Who knew that Burr could let loose with such a dramatic "ARRRGHHH"?

For a minute toward the end, I thought that the writers were going to avoid the obvious culprit, but they quickly reverted to the one that 99.9% of the viewing audience picked in the first ten minutes of the episode.

While this was not the last episode broadcast in this last season of the series, I suspect that it was the last one filmed. Why? Because Burr left no scenery unchewed.

Oh, heck. Why complain? It's utterly stupid and still great fun for fans.
22 out of 25 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Burr
darbski22 May 2017
Warning: Spoilers
**SPOILERS** In the epilogue, Paul Drake is singing in a British accent? Also, Hamilton is having drinks with Drumm, Perry, and Paul. The actress Indus Arthur, who plays Barbara Cramer looks quite a bit like Mary Travers, of Peter, Paul, and Mary.

When the dirtbag creeps were looking up Grimes in the dockside tavern "the Lagoon"? there was a beautiful woman sitting at the bar smoking a cigarette who looks a hell of a lot like Barbara Hale whoever she is, she's uncredited.

Also. Arlene Martel does a great job of playing a supposedly demure sexpot (she's anything BUT demure). She is one of the most exotic actresses on this show. She's played in other episodes, and always a pleasure to watch. There is one thing I'd like to point out, and if you get a chance to see this episode, watch for it. When Mason is interrogating Grimes on the stand, they either have an actor who has a remarkably close resemblance to Perry's facial profile, or (and I think this is the case) they've done an excellent job of film editing. It's only for a moment, but important. Check it out, if you get the chance.

Raymond Burr does a great job with this episode, and I recommend it to all. When I can I'll add it to my collection from Amazon

Yup. I finally was able to complete this collection, and I'm very happy with it. I'd still like to know if that was Barbara sitting at the bar, doing a smaller dual role, uncredited...
19 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
The good name of Perry Mason
bkoganbing6 June 2014
Usually a show that has had a run as long as the Perry Mason series gets a bit stale by a 9th season. But I have a feeling that the idea of both Perry Mason losing a case and having Raymond Burr play a double role was something they must have saved until they knew the show was concluding its run.

Raymond Burr is bringing a civil lawsuit on behalf of Indus Arthur who accuses Oliver McGowan of stealing an intellectual property. Stewart Moss who is McGowan's nephew has a plan to discredit Perry Mason by having a lookalike British cockney sailor offer a bribe to key witness Arlene Martel in a most public place.

Witness tampering is serious business for any lawyer. Later on however in addition to defending his own reputation Burr has to defend Arthur when she's accused of murdering McGowan.

Burr looks like he's having a great old time playing the cockney sailor Grimes. It's the kind of part where he can overact outrageously and does. William Hopper and that Drake Detective Agency do yeoman service in clearing the good name of Perry Mason.

You don't think Perry Mason loses even a civil case without the other side cheating?
24 out of 28 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Simply Superb
jlthornb5124 May 2021
In an unforgettable Perry Mason production, Mr. Raymond Burr gives what is nothing less than the performance of a lifetime. A dual role is always challenging but this is an actor who meets it with all the power and art of his craft. This is simply an unforgettable viewing experience and an hour of incredible acting that should be a monument to a truly fine actor and one that demonstrates his range and skill. This, indeed, is one for the ages and will stand for all time as Mr. Raymond Burr's lasting legacy as an actor.
12 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Perry and Grimes
jillbaeder26 April 2019
This is a great last season episode of Perry Mason and has been well reviewed and recounted by users. HOWEVER, I must say that it has NOTHING to do with robots, androids, a faked moon landing or the space race. Ignore big sky's rubbish. Frankly, I don't understand why IMDb would allow something so silly to be posted here! Have some respect!
11 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
THIS IS THE EPISODE THAT SHOULD HAVE BEEN IN COLOR
tcchelsey3 November 2023
So sad, but true. Considering the incredibly fun dual role Raymond Burr gets himself into here, you would think the producers would have given this a color sendoff!

This story is a camp classic, and even if you are NOT a PERRY MASON fan, you will get a chuckle or two out of the proceedings. Certainly not meant to be funny, but it has that over the top feel that will keep you entertained. A lot of credit goes to director Arthur Marks, who skillfully crafted so many episodes and truly got a winning performance out of Raymond Burr.

One important thing to illustrate. Burr was so closely identified with the role of Perry Mason, you really didn't see him as anything else. This outstanding episode shows off his talents, and after many years, since he began his career playing some dastardly villains. He was scary back in the day, much in the tradition of Lon Chaney, Jr. Theoretically, Burr could have also become a horror movie star.

This is a very ingenious story, and it's a surprise it did not come about sooner. The defendants of a lost case (thanks to Perry), attempt to turn the tables on the famous lawyer by finding a scowling, boozing seaman, called Grimes, who is the spitting image of Mason! Note the curious name, as in Grimey? With a little makeup and suitable clothes, they dress him to look exactly like Perry, now accused of bribing a witness! That throws the whole case out the window, and watch what happens next...

Just watching Raymond Burr as no-account Grimes is the whole show. This is one rare situation where the storyline is meaningless, it's ALL about the acting. Period.

Applause to writer Jackson Gillis, who like Arthur Marks, brought all of us the very best of Perry Mason for years. Without too much surprise, Jackson went on to write several top episodes for COLUMBO and, of course, was a hero to us kids due to the fact that he wrote many fun and memorable episodes for SUPERMAN.

Beautiful Indus Arthur plays Barbara, and in a very good role here. Indus was a very busy movie and tv actress, though her career was cut short due to ill health and eventual death at an early age. TV cult actress Arlene Martel plays Sandra, another wonderful actress, who not too long after this episode would become famous as T'Ping, the Volcan princess in STAR TREK. Arlene appeared at dozens of STAR TREK and nostalgia tv conventions for the rest of her life. She had quite a career.

Don't miss this one, just for the heck of it. OMG. From SEASON 9 EPISODE 26 remastered CBS dvd box set.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A rare Lost Case
jgarnant23 June 2023
Warning: Spoilers
This was a strange one. This is really 2 episodes in one., Where Perry occupies not only his normal presence, but the link to the main protagonist and catalyst, Mr Grimes.

There are 2 points of note, one already mentioned. First, why Raymond Burr rec'd no credit for Grimes, understood. But it's a major oversight

But the second is this is a rarely noticed and subtle buried "lost case" tho appealed on a mistrial (18 min). A patent case albeit not a murder (yet), but the patent case takes nearly a third of the episode and obviously leads to the main case.

Still, a great episode and hopefully Ray got paid for both roles.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Raymond Burr is made of 40% ham
academic-drifter5 September 2021
One of the more interesting aspects of the Perry Mason character in the television show is the scope of his practice. Though primarily known as a criminal defense attorney, his cases range from incorporations to patent cases. It's the latter that he's engaged in at the start of the episode, as he has taken on two clients suing over a patent. And as usually the case, Perry Mason is crushing it in the courtroom.

Desperate to turn their failing case around, the defendants try a desperate gambit by dredging up a drunken sailor who happens to look like the legendary lawyer. This gives Burr a rare chance to play a dual role in the show and he embraces it with gusto. His Grimes is a raspy and disheveled mess, played so over the top that the ham in Burr's makeup is on display. It's fun, but at times it gets in the way of one of the better plots in the show's final season, one that features a fun amount of intrigue on all sides.
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
What an accent
weavethehawk22 September 2020
All I will say about this is, I'm a Brit, and I admit that there are American actors who can pull off British accents, not many, but some. So, why do American actors who definitely CANNOT do British accents insist on trying to do the impossible? Raymond Burr's British accent made my teeth ache.
8 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
I expected this to be a "jump the shark" moment for Perry Mason...
AlsExGal1 October 2023
... but in fact it was very well done and an unusual showcase for Raymond Burr's versatile acting talent as he breaks out of his attorney persona.

The son of a man being sued over the theft of intellectual property from a now deceased boss decides to frame Perry for bribery by getting his look alike, a sailor on a fishing boat (Burr in a double role as Mr. Grimes), to dress up and imitate Perry and have him very publicly toss a witness in the case an envelope with ten thousand dollars in it along with instructions as to how to answer any questions put to her on the stand. The witness breaks down on the stand and testifies of his bribery attempt, and she has the ten thousand dollars to prove it. This undermining of Perry's credibility causes the rare occasion of Mason losing a case. But now he could be indicted for suborning perjury, so he must get to the bottom of what happened.

When I say that Grimes is a Perry Mason look-alike, that is a very loose description. Grimes is aptly named as he doesn't look like he's bathed in a month of Sundays and has a cockney accent and a very rough way about him.

An interesting factoid - One of the supporting players in this episode is Henry Beckman who you may remember, if you are old enough , played old salt Captain Clancey on Here Come the Brides from 1968 to 1970. His portrayal is so close to that of Raymond Burr's rendition of Grimes in this episode that I have to wonder if he used that performance as an inspiration for his own in that TV series.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
The things a man will do when he sells his soul
sol121813 February 2013
Warning: Spoilers
***SPOILERS*** Perry Mason is personally besmirched and discredited in this "Perry Mason" episode when handling a civil case of patent fraud ends up with him not only losing it but in danger of being disbarred.That's when the person that Perry's client was suing Otis Swanson, Oliver McGowan, got a dead ringer off a boat from Liverpool "The Lady Liverpool" to impersonate him this drunken and unclothe Cockney mariner, the exact opposite of the well spoken and fine mannered Perry Mason, Sailor Grimes also played by Raymond Burr. Being cleaned up with a shave bath and new suite of clothes Grimes is instructed by Otis Swanson's nephew Danny, Stewart Moss, to go to the local Bobson Arms Hotel and be seen giving a payoff to star witness Sandra Dunkel, Ariene Martel, of $10,000.00 and note in how to answer questions in the case that Perry Mason is now handling! Grimes even goes so far as in showing what a big sport he is by buying a cheap & smelly, even back then in 1966,.25 cent cigar and leaving a big .75 cent tip! When this is made public in court by Miss Drunkel the entire case against Otis Swanson falls completely apart with a confused and not so happy Perry Mason standing there almost, figurative not literately, bear a** naked with nothing but egg on his face!

It's only later when Otis Swanson is founded murdered and Miss Barbara Kramer, Indus Arthur, who was suing him for patent infringement at the scene of the crime with both the victim's blood on her hands and clothes and the murder weapon a .45 revolver. That ironically has the licking his wounds Perry gets a second chance or shot to finally redeem himself. Not by not only getting Barbara off on the murder charge but by getting his double or dead ringer-Sailor Grimes- on the stand and thus exposing his attempt to impersonate Perry and cause him to lose the Kramer Vrs Swanson case! But first Perry has to prove who really murdered Otis Swanson and that's not going to be that easy for him. In that his client Barbara Kramer was caught red handed at the scene of the crime by Perry's own private investigator Paul Drake, William Hooper, who the prosecuting D.A Hamilton "Ham" Burger, William Talman, will very likely use as a hostile witness against her!

***MAJOR-Don't read unless you already known the ending-SPOILERS*** Worth watching just for the explosive court confrontation between Perry Mason and the once dead drunk and now somewhat sobered up merchant marine Grimes that just about brought the roof down. It was Grimes' greed that in fact did him in by not getting enough, $2,000.00, in impersonating Perry Mason and by feeling he needed much more payoff money that in the end tripped him up. And Grimes was so brainless and clueless in what he was doing that he in fact had the incriminating evidence right on him, in the court room no less, when Perry Mason exposed him for what he was as he tried to make a run for it only having to fall on his face.
16 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Four More Episodes and It Was Time for This Show to End
kdspringer-727596 October 2021
No one likes it when you criticize anything about a beloved show like Perry Mason, and give it less than 5 or more stars. Sorry, you'll have to downvote this review then.

Watch this episode next to an episode from the 1st season, and the changes are striking. Barbara Hale, so lovely in the first season, looks here like the mid-40-ish mother of teenagers which she is. It looks like Burr had put back on all the weight he originally lost nine years earlier to get the role in the first place, and the old man haircut they gave him the last season did not help. Seeing him doubling as the portly cockney sailor emphasizes the issue - he could have never been mistaken for that overweight bum in season one. Paul Drake, who would pass away 5 years later, looks somewhet better, but still looks unhealthy.

To me, it's kind of sad to see, and it's just as well that they wrapped this show up four episodes later.

As for the story . . . Other than the trick of having Burr play two parts, examining himself on the witness stand, there really isn't much here. A lot of sound and fury signifying nothing. Some ridiculous plot elements - including what falls out of someone's pants during "The Reveal." And it almost seems like they flipped a coin at the end to decide who the killer was ging to be. Sure, it's fun watching Burr playing two such opposite characters. But once you get past that . . . Meh.
5 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A Little Change
Hitchcoc6 March 2022
A Cockney sailor who looks like Perry gets into the middle of a lawsuit that Perry loses. The guy is cleaned up and look just like Raymond Burr (of course, he is Raymond Burr). This filters into an eventual murder case where Perry's reputation is at stake. Ordinary except for Burr using his acting chops.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Cockney accent? You're 'aving a larf!
kenminns24 June 2022
Raymond Burr is unquestionably a good actor but he can't do a Cockney accent. His attempt was worse than the famous one by Dick Van Dyke in Mary Poppins. It sounded more like west country pirate to me.
3 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Bad direction
forryjesse10 September 2019
Another badly directed band acted episode. Burr did okay but storyline stinks. Guest actors were weak in their roles.
8 out of 38 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Typical PM...but not
pmike-1131224 May 2021
OK, they decided to do a cliched and trite episode with the lead actor playing a dual role - portraying an evil double. This is what shows do when writers have long run out of ideas ( that, and having the characters putting on a show). And in usual PM style, the plot is silly , the dialogue is horrible, the acting is over-done, and the direction is the worst. How people could tolerate this for 9 years is beyond me, but then there've been a lot of bad shows through the years that were on for multiple years.

Change, no-change. But always a good belly laugh.
1 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed